|
30th December 1925 Colliery Dispute In DurhamWorkers' Claim To BenefitThe Umpire's Award(From Our Labour Correspondent.) The umpire appointed under the Unemployment Insurance Act (Mr. J. G. Pease), as the independent and final authority for the purpose of determining disputed claims to benefit has again been called upon to adjudicate with reference to the payment of benefit to the workmen at the Boldon and St. Hilda Collieries, Durham. This is the third time the case has been heard. In the first place, it was held that the men were out of work in consequence of an industrial dispute and were not entitled to benefit. A new claim was lodges, and it was then decided that the men were entitled to benefit on the ground that the employers had not withdrawn the notices terminating contracts which were given in the middle of July. The umpire held that the notices should have been withdrawn in accordance with the terms of the July settlement, and that failure to withdraw them was a contravention of a national agreement which entitled the men to succeed in their claim by virtue of section 4 (1) of the Act of 1924. The fresh points raised were as to (1) whether the applicants were "not unable to obtain suitable employment" ; and (2) whether, when a stoppage was originally due to the contravention of an agreement, but its continuance was due to other causes, there was still a title to benefit. The Umpire does not express a final opinion on the difficult question of construction involved in the second point. He finds in favour of the workmen on other grounds. The Act of 1920 by section 7 precludes situations vacant through a stoppage of work due to a trade dispute being regarded as "suitable employment" for other persons than those affected by the dispute, and equally (the Umpire decides) prevents the same employment being offered to the men who are concerned in the dispute. He also finds that the employers are not willing to resume work at the colliery as if the notices of mid-July had not been given. The employers say it is commercially impossible for them to go back entirely to the old conditions, and that they cannot afford to reopen the colliery if there is a risk of another stoppage of work in a short time. Umpire's Decision. P> "on the facts before me (the umpire states) my decision is that the claim for benefit should be allowed." He adds :— "The applicants lost employment by reason of a stoppage of work which was due to a trade dispute, but were, during the stoppage of work, in receipt of benefit in accordance with Section 4 (1) of the Act of 1924 pursuant of my decision of 1969/25."While the dispute was still unsettled and the stoppage of work was continuing, the employers made an offer of employment on certain terms, some of which were the subject matter of the dispute, and the question submitted by the chief insurance officer and considered by the Court of Referees was whether the applicants were ‘not unable to obtain suitable employment.' The Court of Referees were of opinion that the employment offered was suitable, but it was contended before me that by reason of Section 7 (1) (b) of the Act of 1920 it must be deemed to be unsuitable. "The employment offered was admittedly at rates of wages lower than those which the applicants had obtained at the same colliery up to the time of the beginning of the stoppage of work on August 1 ; but the employers were prepared to give evidence showing that the rates offered were not lower than those which the applicants might reasonably have expected to obtain having regard to the rates which they habitually obtained in their usual employment in the district or would have obtained had they continued to be so employed. "I do not propose to embark on the inquiry whether the employment offered was suitable, for it appears to me that the offers of employment were in situations vacant in consequence of a stoppage of work due to a trade dispute, and therefore the applicants cannot, by declining the offer, be deemed to have failed to fulfil the statutory conditions. Although no doubt section 7 (1) (a) was especially directed to offers made to persons who have not themselves lost employment through the dispute, I think it applies equally to an offer made, as in this case, to the disputants to return to the situations which they had themselves vacated in consequence of the trade dispute. "A further point was raised on Section 4 (1) of the Act of 1924. In decision 1969/25, I held that the applicants were entitled to benefit, as the stoppage of work was ‘due to an employer acting in a manner so as to contravene the terms of a national agreement' ; and it was suggested that as the employers were now willing to condone that contravention and their offer of employment is on terms which do not involve a contravention of the National Agreement, the applicants are no longer entitled to the benefits of Section 4 (1) of the Act of 1924. This raises the question whether, upon the true construction of that section, the relief given by it can only be claimed so long as the contravention of agreement is the cause of the continuance of the stoppage of work, or whether, if the stoppage of work was originally due to such contravention, the relief given by the section continues so long as the resulting stoppage continues although the continuance is due to other causes. This is a difficult question of construction upon which I do not propose to express a final opinion, but, assuming that the first is the proper construction. I think in this case the applicants are, nevertheless, still entitled to relief under Section 4 (1), for, in my opinion, the original cause of the stoppage is still operating and the continuance of the stoppage is due to that cause. "The employers are willing to put the applicants back on 14-day contracts, but only on certain terms. They do not offer, and say they cannot offer, to restore them to the status on which they were before July 31 — to simply take them back unconditionally as if the 14 days' notice given on July 17 had been withdrawn. The employers are not now, and never have been, willing to resume work at the colliery as if the notice of July 17 had never been given, but offer only to resume work on new conditions and terms of employment, which were not in operation at the colliery before July 31. "It is fair to add that the employers appear to be most anxious to remedy their mistake and to avoid any further contravention of the National Agreement, but they find that it is commercially impossible to do so. They cannot, from a business point of view, incur the great expense of reopening the colliery while the dispute as to rates of payment is still unsettled and might result in another stoppage of work in a very short time."
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||