6th December 1925, Page: 153, Column: 2
Miners' Phthisis
In introducing his paper at the annual general meeting of the
Institution of Mining Engineers, his subject being Miners' Phthisis
on the Witwatersrand, Mr. A. E. Mavrogordato said that
Dr. Piron, who was over here and working at the School of Mining
and Technology, had been allowed to do some sampling on the
collieries here where hand drills were in use, and the amount of
dust in the air here with the use of hand drills was far greater
than they had on the Witwatersrand. The author explained
that while heavy concentrations of dust produce the disease
quickly, say in a couple of years, a comparatively small concentration
may produce it well within the working life of a miner,
say in ten years. The effect is cumulative, because the lung rids
itself of some dusts less readily than it rids itself of others, and a
"phthisis-producing dust" is a dust in which accumulation readily
gets ahead of elimination. Dust inhaled in sufficient quantity
will produce disablement per se, but a quantity not sufficient
to produce disablement per se may pave the way to consumption,
i.e., tuberculosis of the lungs. For many years past on the Witwatersrand
there has not been sufficient air-borne dust to produce
disablement per se, but miners' phthisis is still occurring, because
the workers contract tuberculosis. One may say that the concentration
of phthisis-producing dust in the air of the mines of
the Witwatersrand has now been reduced to below 2 milligrammes
per cubic metre, but miners phthisis is still occurring.
The most hopeful methods of dust control are: (a) Ventilation;
(b) the use of water; (c) the use of dust-abstractors. For ventilation
to be effective, the air delivered to the working-place must be
clean in the sense of being dust-free, Air delivered to the face
should not contain more than 0.5 milligramme per cubic metre.
This condition should be easy to realise with air from the downcast,
as is the case with British collieries, but this will not give
safety in the case of dry-drilling as far as can be judged from such
returns as are available. At one time it was thought that a sufficient
quantity of clean water properly used would produce safe conditions,
but experience on the Witwatersrand shows that it is
so difficult to wet really fine particles that water only will not
produce safe conditions. Dust-abstractors may be used to clean
air delivered to working-places, or they may be used as attachments
to drills. The miner is sure to object to any addition to
the equipment of his drill, but there are circumstances in which
abstractors might be used with great advantage, and even serve
up to a point as a substitute for water.
Judging from experience on the Witwatersrand, there can be
no safety without a thorough system of inspection on phthisis
producing mines. The air must be tested as regularly for its
content in dust as it is tested by gas analysis. Machines, too,
require constant inspection from this point of view. Careful
selection of steel has improved cutting edges, and the more the
drill cuts and the less it pounds the smaller the amount of fine
dust. A blunt drill is apt to break up comparatively coarse fragments
and then grind them up fine. The hole down the drill steel
is apt to lose its shape and get constricted. If this happens
when air and water are being used, then the water stops and the
air goes on.
The average number of miners employed at the Witwatersrand
mines in South Africa in the six years 1918-1919 to 1923-1924
inclusive was 13,457, and of these 1,557 had five years' service,
617 eleven years' service, and so on. The average annual phthisis
production was 388, and while there were 10 cases in the 1,567
men of five years' service, there were 47 in the 517 men of eleven
years' service. While 388 cases in 13,457 give an average production
of about 2.9 per cent. per annum, the rate rises to above
10 per cent in those of 13 years' service.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Mavrogordato, A. E. | | | |
| Piron, —, Dr. | | | |