15th August 1925, Page: 28, Column: 1
The Coal Inquiry
The Court of Inquiry with the Rt. Hon. H. P. Macmillan, K.C.,
as chairman, very promptly reported concerning the Coal Mining
Industry Dispute, 1925. The report (Cmd. 2478) is obtainable
through H.M. Stationery Office, the price being 6d. net. Pointing
out that the report was prepared under the pressure of extreme
urgency; that they cannot hope, in dealing so summarily with the
complicated investigation, to have escaped errors either of omission
or commission; and that they are very sensible of the inevitable
inadequacy of their treatment of the subject, the Court present
their conclusions as follows :—
We are satisfied on one point, that the workers are justified in
claiming that any wage agreement which they can be asked to accept
should provide for a minimum wage. What that minimum should
be is a matter for negotiation between the parties. We do not
think that a method of fixing wages which allows of their indefinite
diminution can be regarded as satisfactory. It may be said that
when under such a system the wages fall too low the worker can
decline to continue to give his labour, but the absence of any basis
of security is the feature which renders unacceptable a scheme
which provides for unlimited variations downwards subject only
to the mitigation by unspecified subsistence allowances, with the
result that until the minimum subsistence allowance level is
reached for every worker in each district the process of diminishing
wages could continue to proceed. The claim that wages must be
a first charge on the proceeds of industry is a contentious and ambiguous
one. If the meaning be that wages at some agreed minimum
rate must in practice be a charge before profits are taken, we
concur in that view. We have not overlooked the existence of the
Coal Mines (Minimum Wage) Act, 1912, which applies to all underground
workers, subject to certain conditions and exceptions. The
provisions of that Act cannot, of course, be abrogated by anything
which the parties may choose to do. We expressed surprise
that so little was heard of this Act in connection with the present
controversy, but Mr. Williams explained that as it applied in effect
to only a limited number of the workers it was really negligible
as a basis of regulation of wages in the industry.
We have hitherto discussed the situation on the footing that it
discloses a conflict between the economic wage which the coal industry
can afford to pay, and the social wage which the worker can
be asked to accept. But that is not the whole of the case. Apart
from the wages costs which constitute the largest part of the outgoings
of a colliery there are other costs of a lesser but still important
character. The Miners' Federation in their series of propositions
have indicated a number of directions in which they suggest that
some measure of relief might be found apart from reductions in
wages. Owing to the abstention of the Miners' Federation from
our proceedings we were deprived of the opportunity of hearing
these proposals expounded by their promoters and of examining
them in any detail. We drew the attention of the representatives
of the mine owners who appeared before us to these subjects, but
the view which they expressed was that there was nothing in them,
taken collectively, which would enable the industry to pay any increase
in wages over what it is able to pay as it Is conducted at the
present time. Nevertheless, we venture to think that there is considerable
room for improving the efficiency of the industry as a
whole, and in this way affording some aid to its economic position.
Further collective action on the part of collieries, for example,
would enable facilities and resources to be used in common to greater
advantage and would promote economical working. It is also for
consideration whether the industry should remain in isolation or
whether by its co-ordination with other enterprises better results
might not be obtained. The increased cost of the transport and
shipment of coal is another factor meriting investigation. The improvement
of the distribution of coal while not entering directly
into the present question has an important indirect bearing upon
it, for it would result in lowering the price to all classes of consumers
and might have a considerable effect in stimulating demand.
The question of the continuance of the royalty system on its present
basis is also an important one, for although the charge upon the industry
under this head is unimportant relatively to the wages bill,
it is not negligible. It has been the source of much ill-feeling
among the ranks of the workers, where the promotion of goodwill
is of so much importance. As we have not had the advantage of
evidence upon any of these or other similar matters we leave the subject
with the general observation that we cannot believe that there
is no room for improvement in the management, organisation and
development of tile industry, or that no alleviation is to be found
in these directions. It should bo added that any steps of this
nature would not meet the present emergency for they would
necessarily take some time to produce any appreciable results.
Some of them might involve expenditure for which it would be difficult
to obtain money while the industry remained in its present
condition, which is not calculated to inspire confidence in the investor.
But these matters ought not to be overlooked in any projects
for the permanent rehabilitation of the industry.
One general conclusion has been forced upon us by our investigation.
The present crisis in the industry, unlike other crises which
have arisen in the past, is to a large extent the creation of neither
party to the dispute. It has arisen in the main from without, and
is due to causes not within the control of either party. These causes
are to be found in the operation of national and international disturbances
and dislocations which are the inevitable sequel of the
economic upheaval due to the war. They are causes which may continue
to operate for a considerable time to come. In such a crisis
it is perhaps not unnatural that each party should seek to transfer
to the other as much as possible of the consequences of the common
calamity. But just because the calamity is a common one not
primarily due to the fault of either, we venture to think that in
taking common counsel together the parties are most likely to find
a means of averting its worst consequences.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Macmillan, H. P., Rt. Hon. | | Chairman | |
| Williams, — | | | |