|
6th August 1925 Killed In Engine RoomWorkington Widow's ApplicationBody In RecessJudgment For Company At Workington County Court, on Thursday, before His Honour Judge Gawan Taylor, Mrs. Jane Lister, of Elizabeth Street, Workington, widow of Richard Crayson Lister, applied for £300 as compensation against the Allerdale Coal Company, Ltd., Great Clifton, Workington for the death of her husband, an employee of the Company, who was killed at William Pit, Clifton, on November 23rd, 1924, in an accident alleged to have occurred whilst defendant was following his employment as a crusher-engine attendant. The respondent company denied liability to pay compensation on the ground that the accident did not arise out of and in the course of his employment; and further brought to the notice of the judge that the applicant was not wholly dependent upon the earnings of the deceased. Mr. W. Gorman, of Manchester, instructed by Messrs. Wood, Lord, and Sumner, Whitehaven, was for the applicant; and Mr. Proctor, of Liverpool, instructed by Messrs. Chapman and Baxter, Whitehaven, was for the respondents. Mr. Gorman said evidence would be called that the crusher engine-house was very dark. The whole of the pathway round was very muddy. Deceased's job was to look after the crusher-engine. The roof of the shed was less than five feet high, and the man would have to stoop in going round. The darkness was such that deceased's assistant actually fell over the body. It was a most dangerous place; there were projecting beams there. They could not know exactly what deceased was doing at the moment of his death. He was known to be performing his work a short time before. He had been seen in the cabin a quarter of an hour previously. Room Very Dark. Stanley Waters, 80, Brewery Brow, Workington, aged 17, said he was employed as a crusher-engine attendant, and on the day of the accident was working on the same shift as deceased. It was deceased's job to look after the engine, and he would generally be knocking about the engineroom. There was a cabin, in which they had their food and hung up their coats. They had breakfast at about 9-30. He last saw deceased alive at 7-15 p.m. in the cabin. He was sitting down, and the engine was running, the pulleys moving, and the belt going round. The room was very dark, added witness. He had been in the place since the accident, and there was now a window in it, just where the accident happened. The window had then been boarded up. The floor was muddy at the time of the accident, but was not muddy now. Witness went to look for Lister to tell him to stop the engine, but being unable to see him he went to stop it himself. He had to stoop to avoid the roof. On the way he stumbled over something. He went on, stopped the engine, and on returning found that it was deceased who was lying there. He was lying with his head toward the belt, lying on the bed plates. Mr. Gorman: How do you think he got there? — I do not know. His Honour: It seems very difficult to see how, if he was going here and slipped, he could have fallen under the pulley with his head in the recess. Mr. Proctor: That is my case, your Honour. His Honour: You contend that he must have been doing something outside the sphere of his duty. Mr. Proctor: Yes; he must have been doing something outside his duty. Mr. Gorman: I contend that he was going one way or the other past the pulley, and that he slipped on the floor or tripped over a projection and was thrown into this position, striking, the belt fastener. The case I have to meet is that he deliberately put his head under the pulley for some reason or other. A Greasy Floor. William Kirkpatrick, Moor Cottages, Stainburn, employed by respondents on the aerial rope, said he was called into the engine house, and saw the body of deceased. The mark was on his forehead. Witness used to be employed in the engine house. It was in a very bad state. It was very dark, and was not lighted at all, except the first thing in the morning. The lights had been put in when he went in. The floor was slippery and greasy, caused by the dripping in of water. He had slipped himself. The engine-house was no lighter, had been white-washed, and had a guard rail. Henry McVay, William Street, Clifton, crusher-engine attendant, said he worked on a different shift from that worked by deceased, said the floor was of wood, and had been covered with coal dust. Mr. Proctor (cross examining): Did you say at the Coroner's inquest that if he had been struck by the pulley he would have been knocked backwards. If he had slipped against it, you said? — Yes. Mr. Proctor said that the applicant's burden of proving that the accident happened in the course of the man's employment had not been discharged if they left in doubt how the accident happened. He did not deny that the man was acting in the performance of his duties shortly before, but he was found in a most remarkable position, and Mr. Gorman had left it to His Honour to surmise, to conjecture. He thought His Honour would agree that no man who slipped could have fallen into that position. There was nothing in connection with his duties to make it necessary for him to go there. There was only one mark on the back of his head, and no other mark to suggest that he might have fallen and struck something. He suggested that he could only have got there by crawling. His Honour pointed out that if the man had been walking round there and his pipe had fallen under the pulley, and he had tried to retrieve it while the belt was revolving, that was an added risk. The fact that there was a bar outside would be in favour of the defence, as if he had slipped he would either have broken it or remained outside. Mr. Proctor: He could not have got there without crawling. If he had slipped and struck the belt he would have been thrown backwards. The belt revolves in such a direction that he could not have been drawn underneath. Mr. Gorman submitted that it was the onus of the respondents to prove that deceased was not in the course of his employment. Wound Caused By Belt Fastener. Dr. James Young, Workington, said he examined Lister, and found a lacerated wound on the left side of the crown, and beneath it was a tri-radiate fracture. The wound could have been caused by the fastener of the belt. There were no other injuries. If he had slipped and fallen against the belt it would not have caused the wound. He would become unconscious immediately, and there would be no subsequent movement, except twitchings. Thomas Davis, chartered civil engineer, Liverpool, said he had seen the place. The aperture was 2 feet 6 inches wide. He did not think it possible for a man to fall into the recess. The pulley revolved 500 times per minute. He had tried experiments at his work, and he had found it impossible for a man to slip into such an aperture unless he were end on, and in any case he could not fall beneath the pulley. A Voluntary Action. Dr. Crerar, Maryport, said he had conducted certain experiments. He had had a man lying on the bed-plates with his arm outstretched. The man's head came into contact with the bottom of the belt. He thought the man could not have got into the position except voluntarily. He thought deceased would be rendered unconscious immediately. His Honour: What inference do you draw? — I drew the inference that he got into the position voluntarily, and the he must have put out his right arm, thus bringing the left side of his head into contact with the belt. If he had slipped he could not have got into that position? — No. The blow could not have been received as he was going down? — No; he must have raised his head. Mr. Gorman: There would have been other wounds if there had been other points of contact? — No. If the man put out his hand on the muddy floor he would not receive bruises? — It is quite possible. You think that, generally speaking, the position in which he was found was the position in which he was struck? — Yes. You think that the position in which he was found was the position in which he fell? — I do not think he fell. Do you agree that it is instinctive for a falling man to put his hand out? — Yes. His Honour's Views. Mr. Gorman said the best possible evidence had been given, evidence by one of deceased's colleagues. What he thought was that the man had fallen, and in trying to get up was struck. Such evidence was more valuable than that of men who, in the calm of a laboratory, studied the possibilities. No man fell according to pattern, or stumbled at a given angle. He might have fallen sideways, or slipped, or anything might have happened to bring him into any conceivable position. His Honour: If he tried to retrieve his pipe, you agree that that would take it out of the sphere of his work. Mr. Gorman: There is no evidence of his having lost his pipe. His Honour: Nor is there any evidence of whether he slipped. Mr. Gorman said that it was quite natural that if he fell the pipe would be found near his right hand. Nobody but a madman would put his head under a revolving belt in order to recover a pipe. His Honour, in summing up, said that the evidence was consistent either with deceased's having slipped or with his having tried to recover his pipe from under the pulley. The applicant therefore had failed to discharge the burden of deceased's employment, and judgement must be for the respondent company.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||