|
20th June 1925 Low Temperature CarbonizationColliery Owners' ViewWhile submitting that the amount of smokeless fuel and oil produced by processes of low temperature carbonization of coal have during 20 years of experiment been so small as to be of no economic importance, the Secretary for Mines, in his report for 1924, is able to announce that there are now plants in course of erection which it is hoped will begin in the present year to run on a commercial basis. It is noted in the report that the importance of the process lies in the fact that it enables motor spirit and fuel oil to be obtained from coal and yields a smokeless solid fuel suitable for purposes for which coal is used at present. If the process were employed on a large scale it would furnish, from home resources, an appreciable fraction of the liquid fuels that are at present almost entirely imported, and, in addition, the use of smokeless fuel for domestic purposes and for the smaller industrial plants would go far to abate the smoke nuisance. The importance of such developments to the coal-mining industry hardly needs to be emphasized. Apart from increasing the demand for coal generally, a new use would be created for inferior grades for which at present there is often very little use. The main difficulty that has so far prevented the commercial development of carbonization at low temperatures, the report adds, is that of devising a means by which the capital and running costs of the plant can be reduced sufficiently to leave a margin of profit. The problem has been the subject of very careful investigation by the Fuel Research Board and by private investigators, but the practical economical difficulties have proved greater than was anticipated. In July last year the Government, at the instance of the Secretary for Mines and the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research, offered to conduct tests free of cost of any experimental plant and process which appeared likely to give reasonably good results under normal working conditions. Following on tests made the report takes the optimistic view mentioned above that there are hopes of the process being established on a commercial basis. Solving A Difficulty. There has been a suggestion in some quarters that the coal and gas industries, in not immediately abandoning the high temperature process for that of low temperature carbonization, have shown themselves to be behind the scientific discoveries and best technical practice of the day, but those who can speak for the coal and gas industries point out that these have been closely connected with the experiments and investigations into the process for the last 20 years. A representative of the coalowners said yesterday that any suggestion of antagonism on the part of the coal-mining industry towards low temperature carbonization or any other process for the scientific utilization of fuel resources must be emphatically repudiated. Much of the research work now in progress on the subject was being conducted by colliery proprietors and those engaged in the production of coal and its transformation into heat, light and power should rather be regarded as one body of investigators having as their common object national fuel economy. Should the experiments now proceeding result in a greater demand for the slack, waste, and inferior coal for which buyers could now scarcely be found at any price, one of the greatest difficulties confronting the coalmining industry would be in a fair way to solution. Up to the present, however, the successful experiments had been conducted with specially selected coal. Dr. Lander, the Director of Fuel Research, had himself pointed out in his book on low temperature carbonization that many of the excellent results obtained from materials in the laboratory were unquestioned, but before the same results could be produced by a plant on a commercial scale many technical problems had to be solved and much large-scale experimental work undertaken. It is the view of leading colliery owners that while difficulties may eventually be overcome, it should not be assumed that the wholesale establishment of plants constructed for the operation of one particular process will immediately solve all the difficulties facing the industry. A market, it is pointed out, must be found for all the products of carbonization, and it has yet to be proved that a market exists at remunerative prices for the commercial products of low temperature carbonization. Coke, suitable for burning in an ordinary domestic grate, has been on the market for many years, but the quantity consumed is an infinitesimal proportion of the 35,000,000 tons of coal used annually for domestic purposes. With regard to the importance of securing supplies of fuel oil independent of foreign influences, coalowners submit that while oil is undoubtedly obtainable from coal by low temperature carbonization at a cost, the possibility, short of a subsidy, of producing this ore commercially depends on the ability to sell not only the oil but all the products. "The coal and gas industries," it is stated, "will follow with the closest interest the commercial development of low temperature carbonization, and will be swift to adopt any process that will either reduce their costs or enhance the value of their own products, but they are mindful of the fact that they are established on a commercial basis and actually supplying the public needs, and that any change in process which they adopt must also be on a commercial basis.
|
|||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||