|
18th December 1924 House Of LordsRating Appeal : Gross And Rateable ValuesGateshead Union Assessment Committee v. Owners Of Redheugh Colliery, Limited(Before the Lord Chancellor, Lord Finlay, Lord Shaw of Dunfermline, Lord Carson, and Lord Blanesburgh.) Their Lordships to-day, by a majority, allowed this appeal from an order of the Court of Appeal (40 The Times L.R., 169 ; [1924] 1 K.B., 360), reversing an order of the Divisional Court (39 The Times L.R., 661), on a special cases stated by the Durham Quarter Sessions in an appeal against a poor rate. The appeal raised questions of general importance with regard to the law of rating. The following statement of facts is taken from the judgement of the Lord Chancellor :— In a poor rate and supplemental poor rate made by the overseers of the parish of Gateshead in the months of April and June, 1921, the respondents as the occupiers of the Redheugh Colliery were rated upon the basis of the valuation list then in force for that parish, in which the gross estimated rental of the colliery was put at £2,205, and the net or rateable value at £2,152. These figures had been in operation since the month of April, 1915, and had been approved by the appellants, the Gateshead Union Assessment Committee. The respondents on September 20, 1921, gave notice to the Assessment Committee under section 1 of the Union Assessment Committee Act, 1864, objecting to the above valuation list so far as the rateable value was concerned ; but the committee sustained the assessment. Thereupon the respondent's appealed against the rates to the Durham Quarter Sessions and raised a number of contentions, of which two only were now material — viz., (1) that the net rateable value was excessive apart from any consideration of the gross estimated rental as stated in the valuation list ; and (2) that in any case the just rateable value was excessive because the allowance of the statutable deductions from the gross to the net was insufficient, and that in view of the decisions in Horton v. Walsall union (14 The Times L.R., 391 ; [1898] 2 Q.B, 237) and in Hendon Paper Works Company v. Sunderland Union Assessment Committee ([1915] 1 K.B., 763) the amount of the net rateable value could not exceed the amount of the gross estimated rental less the statutable deductions. The appellants (the respondents at Quarter Sessions) met the first of these contentions by calling evidence to show that the rateable value shown in the rate was in fact correctly estimated according to the definition contained in section 1 of the Parochial Assessment Act, 1836. With regard to the second point, they admitted that the average annual costs of the repair, insurance, and maintenance of the colliery were more than sufficient, if deducted from the gross estimated rental of £2,205, to reduce the net rateable value to a nominal figure ; but they contended that, having regard to the course taken by the present respondents before the Assessment Committee, the latter were not entitled in law to raise this contention. The justices at Quarter Sessions found as a fact that the rateable value shown in the rate was a proper one ; but holding themselves bound by the decision in Hendon Paper Works Company v. Sunderland Union Assessment Committee (supra) to accept the second contention above referred to, they allowed the appeal and reduced the rateable value to £1, subject to a special case. The questions submitted by the special case for the opinion of the Court (omitting the first, which was not now in controversy) were as follows :— (2) Whether the justices were right in holding that the appellants at Quarter Sessions (the present respondents) were entitled to raise the question of the sufficiency of the deductions made from the gross estimated rental in order to arrive at the rateable value : and (3) Whether if they were right on questions (1) and (2), they were right in holding that they were bound by the decision in Hendon Paper Works Company v. Sunderland Union Assessment Committee to reduce the rateable value to £1. If all the questions were answered in the affirmative, their decision was to stand ; if any of the questions were answered in the negative, the rateable value shown in the rate was to be restored and the appeal was to be dismissed, with costs. The special case was argued before a Divisional Court, consisting of the Lord Chief Justice and Justices Avory and Greer, and judgement was given in favour of the Assessment Committee, Mr. Justice Greer dissenting, but on appeal (by leave) to the Court of Appeal (Lords Justices Bankes, Scrutton, and Atkin), that Court reversed the decision of the Divisional Court and restored the order of Quarter Sessions. Hence the present appeal. Mr. Konstam, K.C., and Mr. Mundahl appeared for the appellants ; and Mr. Mortimer, K.C., and Mr. Simey for the respondents. Judgement. The Lord Chancellor (after stating the facts) said that before dealing with the question whether the respondents were entitled to raise at Quarter Sessions the question relating to statutable deductions, it was necessary to refer in more detail to the proceedings on the respondents' objection before the Assessment Committee. The material parts of the notice of objection, which was in a form provided by the committee, were as follows :— We hereby give you notice that we object to the valuation of the Rateable Hereditaments belonging to [or occupied by] us, situate within the above-named Parish or Township ; and that the ground of our objection is that such valuation is unfair, incorrect, or excessive, and illegal. The particulars of each Assessment against which we intend to appeal are stated in the Schedule below. We will attend and state the grounds of our appeal at the Meeting of the Assessment Committee, to be holden at the Poor Law Union Offices, Prince Consort-road, Gateshead, on Tuesday, the day of, 19, at o'clock p.m. The schedule to the notice included the Redheugh Colliery and referred to the rateable value of £2,152, but did not refer to the gross estimated rental. At the hearing before the Assessment Committee the respondents were represented by their manager, who supported the objection by arguments based (as counsel for the respondents admitted) on commercial grounds only, such as the output of coal, the costs of getting the coal, and the sale prices, and not on any grounds relating to the statutable deductions. After some argument the hearing was adjourned pending correspondence with the respondents and inquiries by the committee's valuer, and it was stated in the special case that "after several intermediate adjournments, although the appellants requested and were refused a further hearing before the committee, the committee on April 19, 1922, informed the appellants that they had decided to sustain the assessment at the sums above stated. No express objection was made to the said list either in the said notice or at the said hearing on the ground that the deductions made from the gross estimated rental in order to arrive at the rateable value of the said colliery were insufficient." The contention of the appellants now under consideration was based upon the fact that no express objection was made to the valuation list, either in the notice of objection or at the hearing before the committee, on the ground that the deduction of £53 made from the gross estimated rental, in order to arrive at the rateable value of the colliery, was insufficient. So far as this contention was based on a supposed insufficiency in the notice of objection, he agreed with the Court of Appeal in holding that it failed. He thought that if the notice specified as the grounds of objection all or any of the grounds referred to in section 18 of the Act of 1862, such as unfairness or incorrectness in the valuation of a specified hereditament or the omission of any rateable hereditament from the list, the notice was sufficient, and that it was not necessary that the objector should in his notice inform the committee of the reasons upon which he based his objection or the arguments by which he proposed to support it. This view was supported by the terms of section 19 of the same Act, which expressly referred to "unfairness or incorrectness in the valuation of any hereditament of any person other than the person objecting" as a ground of objection to the list. If this was the correct view of the meaning of the section, then the notice given in the present case was sufficient ; for one way in which a net valuation might be shown to be incorrect was by showing that the statutable deductions were insufficient, and the objection on the ground of incorrectness therefore covered this point. In any case he did not see how the appellants, who themselves provided the form of notice which was used by the respondents, could be heard to say that it was inadequate. On the second branch of the contention under review — namely, that at the hearing of the objection before the Assessment Committee no point was made as to the insufficiency of the deductions from the gross value — he had felt some doubt ; but, although he could not help feeling that the silence of the objectors on the question of deductions might have misled the committee, he agreed with the Court of Appeal in holding that the action of the committee in first adjourning the hearing and then refusing a further hearing prevented them from raising the point. He would add that in his opinion it was undesirable that a ratepayer who after an objection under section 1 of the Act of 1864 appealed to Quarter Sessions should be held closely to the points taken orally before the Assessment Committee. The proceedings on an objection were (he thought) intended to be informal and inexpensive ; and if objectors were confined at Quarter Sessions to the precise points taken before the committee, it might be necessary for them in future to obtain legal aid and for the committee to take accurate notes of the proceedings. Upon the whole, therefore, he was of opinion that this argument also failed. The Third Question. He proceeded then to consider the third question reserved by Quarter Sessions for the opinion of the Court — whether Quarter Sessions were right in holding that they were bound by the decision in the Hendon Paper Works case to reduce the rateable value to £1. Strictly speaking, the reference in this question should have been, not to the Hendon Paper Works case, but to the case of Horton v. Walsall Union ([1898] 2 Q.B., 237), which in the Hendon case was approved by the Court of Appeal, but was held on the facts of the latter case not to be applicable. In the Walsall case the appellant (the ratepayer) accepted as correct the gross estimated rental shown in the valuation list, and claimed to have the rateable value ascertained by deducting from that rental the average expenses of repairs, &c., the amount of which was not in dispute ; and it was held that he was entitled so to claim, and that it was not open to the respondents to call evidence to show that the gross rental fixed by the valuation list was too low. A similar conclusion was reached in Brown v. Rotherham JJ. (64 J.P., 580), and in the recent case of John Fowler and Co. v. Hunslet Assessment Committee (33 The Times L.R., 200 ; [1917] 1 K.B., 720), where the appeal was from special sessions. He did not question the correctness of these decisions. But in all the cases cited other than the Hendon case the appellants came to Quarter Sessions admitting the gross valuation and claiming only to have proper deductions made from it according to the statute in order to ascertain the rateable value, and he greatly doubted whether these decisions applied to the present case, which was of a wholly different character. In the present case the appellants to Quarter Sessions, by their notice of appeal, questioned both the gross and the rateable value fixed by the valuation list ; and when the appeal came on for hearing they still declined to accept the gross estimated rental as correct, and adduced evidence to show that upon the facts, and apart from any question of statutable deductions, the net rateable value shown in the rate was excessive. They were, therefore, inviting Quarter Sessions to investigate the merits of the case, and after such an investigation, which necessarily involved a consideration of both the gross and the rateable values, to determine the value upon which the rate should be levied ; and it was on this invitation that the justices entered upon the inquiry, which resulted in their finding that the rateable value of £2,152 shown in the rate was a proper one. In considering this question the justices must obviously have had in mind the fact, which was then common ground, that the statutable deductions alone exceeded the estimated gross rental of £2,205 ; and they must, therefore, have been satisfied before they arrived at their conclusion as to the rateable value that the real gross rental was not less than the sum of these two figures or £4,357. In these circumstances the contention of the respondents amounted to this, that the justices, who at the instance of the respondents had investigated the gross and rateable values of the colliery and had found as a fact that the true gross value was not less than £4,357 and the true rateable value not less than £2,152, were bound by law to throw their conclusions to one side and on the basis of an estimated rental which they knew to be grossly and palpably wrong, to fix the rateable value at £1. Such a result was described by Mr. Justice Avory as "ridiculous and absurd" and by the Lord Chief Justice as "grotesque" ; and Lord Justice Scrutton, while feeling himself compelled by the decisions to accept the conclusion, referred to it in terms hardly more complimentary. He thought it must be admitted that a conclusion which could be described by learned Judges in such terms called for the careful and unfettered consideration of that House ; and it appeared to him that if the law really compelled their Lordships to subscribe to the same conclusion the law would deserve the worst that had been said of it by its detractors. In his opinion their Lordships were not subject to any such compulsion, and effect could in this case be given to the requirements of justice without infringing upon settled law. Whether the justices could have raised the gross value need not now be considered. Possibly they could not ; but it appeared to him that, having regard to the course which the proceedings had taken, it was open to them to affirm the rateable value as shown in the valuation list, leaving it to the overseers in some future list to bring the gross valuation (which outside the Metropolis was of little practical importance) into harmony with the ascertained facts. The decision in Hendon Paper Works Company v. Sunderland Assessment Committee appeared to him not to conflict with but rather to support the conclusion at which he had arrived. Although in this case there was no agreement showing the gross estimated rental to be fictitious, there was a decision of the justices at Quarter Sessions showing it to be wholly incorrect and illusory ; and to permit the ratepayers to rely upon that illusory figure as being a real figure and to set off against it the real statutable deductions in order to reduce the rateable value to nothing would be unjust to the Assessment Committee and to the general body of ratepayers whom they represented. For these reasons he was of opinion that the third question reserved by Quarter Sessions for the opinion of the Court should be answered in the negative, and accordingly that this appeal should be allowed, and that the order of the Court of Appeal should be set aside and the order of the Divisional Court restored, with the costs here and below. Lord Shaw of Dunfermline gave judgement to the same effect, and Lord Blanesburgh concurred in the opinion of the Lord Chancellor. Lord Finlay differed. He agreed with the Lord Chancellor in deciding that the Quarter Sessions were right in holding that the colliery company were entitled to raise the question of the sufficiency of the deductions. But he differed from him on the question whether the Quarter Sessions were right in following the Hendon case. It had been said that to follow the Hendon case would lead in the present case to an absurd result, as the rateable value must be far in excess of £1. That was not a legal point, and the question here was one of law, which must be answered according to law whatever the result might be in the particular case. If, indeed, the result were obviously absurd it would give good ground for thinking that there must be something wrong in the process by which such a result was reached. But as the point had been made it was worth while observing that there was no sufficient ground for saying that the result in the case of this colliery was absurd. If the expense of getting the coal was excessive a colliery might become commercially worthless. He did not see what ground there was for saying that the conclusion which the Quarter Sessions came to on the authority of the Hendon case did, in fact, give absurd results. But the real question was whether the course taken was legally right. He was not prepared to overrule the decision in the Hendon case. That decision was given in the year 1915 — it followed a decision given in 1908 in Horton v. Walsall Union, and it was itself followed in Fowler v. the Hunslet Union. No sufficient reason had been shown for disregarding such a catena of authorities. In his opinion, the decision was right. There was no ground for saying that the entries as to gross value could be treated as mere fancy figures, in which case they would be worse than useless ; if wrong, they should be set right, but only in due course of law. In his opinion, the Hendon case was rightly decided and the Quarter Sessions were bound to follow it. He therefore thought that the appeal should be dismissed, with costs. Lord Carson gave judgement to the same effect as Lord Finlay. Solicitors. — Messrs. Maples, Teesdale, and co., for Messrs. Lambert and Lambert, Gateshead ; Messrs. Crossman, Block, Matthews, and Crossman, for Messrs. Murray and Richmond, Newcastle-upon-Tyne.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||