Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

6th November 1924

Entombed 28 Hours

Bigrigg Mine Accident

10 Men "Like Rats In A Trap

Graphic Interviews With Rescued Men

West Cumberland, this week was happily spared the pain inflicted by a mining disaster of the type which has in the past darkened the industrial career of the district. On Monday afternoon 10 iron ore miners were entombed in Lord Leconfield's Croft Pit, at Bigrigg. Beyond slight reverberations on Monday night, which some of the rescue party took to be the firing of detonators by the imprisoned men, no signal was received by the rescue parties until nearly noon on Tuesday. That morning's dark pessimistic cloud had thus a silver lining, and in the evening the rescuers completed their task of carving through hundreds of tons of debris. All the ten miners emerged unscathed from their 24 hours imprisonment. Their arrival at the pit head was the signal for a silence more eloquent than words. It was the silence of thanksgiving that man had won a race against death. Dramatic stories of their experiences are told by the rescued.

Cause Of The Accident

Rescue Party's Magnificent Achievement

Pit Head Scene After Liberation

The collapse of a supporting pillar at the junction of two roads in the top eye level on Monday afternoon, caused a fall of roof which brought with it many hundreds of tons of metal. At that time 12 miners, forming part of the afternoon shift, were entering the level. Of this party two men — Joseph Kitchin, married, of Bigrigg, and Tom Nicholson, married of Egremont, had a miraculous escape. As the roof caved in with a deafening roar they were swept off their feet by a blast of air and momentarily stunned. They quickly recovered, and, failing to find any trace of their ten mates, they ran to the shaft to report the accident.

A rescue party of 40 was immediately formed, and the difficult task — a task not to be completed until some 28 hours later — was begun of driving through the extensive fall, which completely blocked the two roadways. All night long this band of workers toiled in relays, fortified by the slight encouragement that some of their members thought they heard distant reverberations which might be caused by the firing of detonators beyond the fall. Owing to the dangerous condition of the roof what would ordinarily have been the quickest route to win through to the missing men had to be abandoned and the longer but safer deviation was decided upon.

On Tuesday morning the outlook was indeed black, but about 11 o'clock the rescuers heard a faint shout. Spurred to greater endeavours by this welcome sound they rapidly drove their way through the fallen metal, and later, clearer vocal communication was established. Almost the first inquiry uttered by the spokesman of the imprisoned men was with reference to the fate of their two mates, Nicholson and Kitchin. Great satisfaction was expressed on learning that they had escaped unhurt and had returned that day to take part in the rescue operations.

Men Released

Later, the barrier between the rescuers and imprisoned was narrowed sufficiently to supply the latter with food and drink, and about six o'clock in the evening they were finally liberated from their enforced imprisonment which had lasted from 2.30 p.m., the previous day.

The names of the men thus relieved were :—

John Glover, married, Bigrigg
George Armstrong, single, Bigrigg
William Shepherd, married, Moor Row
John Walsh, married, Cleator Moor
Tom Donaldson, married, Cleator Moor
W. H. Armstrong, married, Bigrigg
John Stevenson, married, Bigrigg
John Waring, married, St Bees
Tom Shepherd, married, St Bees
Ben Hardisty, married, Cleator Moor

Slight rain was falling as the rescued and rescuers arrived at the pit head, where a crowd of relatives and workers had assembled. No boisterous greeting was accorded these men returned from a nerve-racking experience. There was no outburst of enthusiasm — just silence, the silence of thanksgiving that man had won this race with death.

The silence was broken by the voice of a wife anxiously inquiring of her husband, "Are you all right? Are you sure you are all right?" The man answered brusquely but kindly "I'm, all right, don't worry lass." Others answered friends and relatives with the equally evasive replies, "I am in the pink." And "It was nothing, just a little accident."

But behind all this there was suppressed emotion that was not for the public gaze. There were no irresponsible remarks, this confinement underground had left its mark on some of the men; and the hands of one of the party were unsteady as he gratefully filled his pipe from a proffered pouch.

Conveyed Home

The majority after receiving a stimulant in the changing house declined to discuss their experiences with relative, friend, or stranger, and those living at a distance were conveyed home in cars lent by Mrs. R. S. Hudson, Mr. Robert Jefferson, J.P., CC., Mr. C. C. Davidson, the manager of the mine; and the Whitehaven Colliery Company.

An official described the work of the rescue parties as magnificent. It was dangerous work, but, as an illustration of the spirit which prevailed in their ranks, he said some had worked from 2.30 on Monday afternoon, to nine o'clock on Tuesday morning, and were back again in the pit a few hours later.

Amongst those present at the operations were Mr. Foster, Chief Inspector of Mines, Newcastle, and Mr. Loudon and Mr. Goodwin, the local Inspectors. There were many anxious inquirers at the mine during the day, including Mr. R. Jefferson, J.P., CC., and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, CC., the secretary of the local Iron Ore Miners' Union.

Croft Pit now employs about 80 men as compared with 120 before the industrial depression caused a reduction of the number of workers. On Monday afternoon only the 12 men involved in the accident were employed in the top eye level, which is about 60 fathoms below the surface.

Veteran's Graphic Account

In an interview, one of the rescued men, Glover, who is 60 years of age, and has been an iron ore miner for 28 years, said hundreds of tons of metal and stone must have fallen when the roof came in. Respecting the escape of Kitchin and Nicholson, he said they went down another working to that taken by the ten men. A rumbling noise warned them that some part of the roof was unsafe and they raced for the protection of a place supported by four pillars, a cul de sac, declared Glover, "as safe as any house." At the same time they were not prepared for such a huge fall as to completely cut them off. In this underground sanctuary they were in no danger of suffocation from lack of air and they decided to make their bait, and the water in their bottles last as long as possible. They kept signalling by knocking and on Monday night they thought they heard a reply. Their worst enemy, concluded this veteran of the mine, was the intense cold.

Another of the rescued, George Armstrong, bemoaned the loss of his cap which was brushed off his head in the desperate race for the protection of the pillars.

"Like Rats In A Trap"

In an interview with a "News" representative yesterday, Tom Donaldson, another veteran iron miner, aged 65 years, and one of the rescued men, gave a graphic description of their experiences underground. After the confusion and darkness they succeeded in lighting candles and surveyed their position. With dismay they found that all three exits were completely blocked and they were confined in an area about six feet by 18 feet. "It was a queer experience, caught like rats in a trap," continued Mr. Donaldson, "one that I have never before faced in all my 50 years' experience as an iron miner."

Their first thoughts concerned what had happened to Kitchin and Nicholson and then they discussed the question as to what time might elapse before workers in other parts of the mine would become aware of their plight. Later some of the party helped to relieve the tedium of waiting by exchanging jokes about politics and football. One asked another what time he would kick off at Saturday's match and like lightning came the retort, "I'll kick off into bed as soon as I get out of this."

But all this was merely surface humour, added Mr. Donaldson, designed to cover the fears which gripped every member of the party. On Monday night they fired three detonators to attract attention, if possible, but could not hear any reply.

Outside their stronghold of the four pillars the roof continued to drop in places, and, to strengthen their position, it was decided to build two walls of the fallen stone. This work kept their minds employed and also assisted in warding off the intense cold.

At nearly noon on Tuesday they first heard the rescue party. "I have never heard a more welcome sound in my life," added Mr. Donaldson. After a consultation among the imprisoned men it was decided to help the rescuers by digging with pick and axe, but several times they were driven back to the pillars by falling pieces of roof which threatened further collapse.

Eventually a small hole was driven through by the rescuers, and the imprisoned men were pulled through feet foremost, safe, uninjured, and happy to be liberated from their would-be tomb.

In glowing terms Mr. Donaldson expressed his admiration of the work of the rescue parties. The fall, he estimated to be from 36ft to 39ft and that this had been cut through in so short a space of time was a magnificent achievement in his eyes. Only three of the rescue party could work at the face at one time and every foot had to be timbered.

"If I had been a policeman I would not have been in that fall but would have been enjoying a nice pension," jocularly remarked this intelligent warrior of the industrial battlefield as the writer bade him "Good morning."

Unlike the Cumberland coal field, the iron field has been singularly free from serious accidents. The last "big" accident occurred at Egremont in 1913 when Townhead mine was flooded. One man lost his life and two others were imprisoned in a high working above the flood for five days before being rescued. During that time they were fed through a small bore hole.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Armstrong, George    Miner  
Armstrong, W. H.    Miner  
Davidson, C. C.    Manager  
Donaldson, Tom    Miner  
Foster, Harold Taylor    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Secretary  Whos Who Page
Glover, John    Miner  
Goodwin, W.    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Hardisty, Benn   58 Miner  Individual Page
Hudson, R. S., Mrs.      
Jefferson, Robert    J.P.  
Kitchin, Joseph    Miner  
Leconfield, Lord    Mine Owner  
Loudon, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Nicholson, Tom    Miner  
Shepherd, Tom    Miner  
Shepherd, William    Miner  
Stevenson, John    Miner  
Walsh, John    Miner  
Waring, John    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Bigrigg (Iron Ore)  Bigrigg (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print