Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

23rd October 1924

Gassed Miner

Inadequate Ventilation Charge

Sequel To Death In Clifton Pit

£30 In Fines

There was a sequel at Workington yesterday, to the death, last June, of a miner, from gas poisoning in William Pit, Clifton. The Allerdale Coal Company, Great Clifton, were charged with failing constantly to have an adequate amount of ventilation, to dilute and render harmless inflammable and noxious gases in Main Band Dip, at William Pit, Clifton, on June 10th, contrary to the Coal Mines Act.

The same charge was also preferred against John Frederick Foggo, managing director, and John Wilson, colliery manager at William Pit.

Mr. J. N. St. G. Curwen prosecuted on behalf of Mr. T. G. Davies, Inspector of Mines. Mr. G. A. Lightfoot appeared for defendants, who pleaded not guilty.

Mr. Curwen said the prosecutions were made at the instance of the Public Prosecutor, on information laid by Mr. Davies. They were under the Coal Mines Act 1911, an important statute and one that must be strictly complied with. The Act provided that an adequate amount of ventilation should be constantly produced in every mine. There were two essentials. There must be constant ventilation, and that ventilation must be such as to render the mine safe to be worked in. A qualifying clause provided that the employers were not culpable if the ventilation was interrupted on account of an accident. He submitted, on the authority of a King's Bench Division decision, that it was necessary for the ventilation current to be continued over a weekend, or during a short holiday, or at any time when the colliery was not closed down completely.

Walter Smith, of 3, Pinfold Street, Workington, pumpsman at William Pit for six years, said he was employed at the Main Dip. On June 6th his shift finished at 8 o'clock. It was his duty to attend to the electric fan at the head of the dip drift. He was followed after eight o'clock by a man named Metcalf, who would work until five o'clock on Saturday morning. A man named Moffat, who was now in America, then went on the shift. The electric fan was not running over the holidays, on Saturday, Sunday, and Monday. On the Tuesday night he went down to the Inspection Station just after 10.30, and waited for his deputy, Richard Lamb, who had gone down at 9.30. They waited until 11.30, and Norman Tuke and he went to look for him. They passed the fan, which was then running. No one save Lamb had passed that way on that night, so far as he knew. Further down the drift they found a deputy's safety lamp, which they left. On reaching the bottom, Tuke decided to go on while witness waited to keep Lamb's lamp in sight. Some time later Tuke shouted, "He is here." Witness went through the brattice door, and smelled gas. They decided to try to get to Lamb, but further up the drift the gas put his lamp out. They found Lamb's waistcoat on the ground. In an endeavour to clear the gas, they turned on the compressor that worked the rock drill. The gas was so bad, however, that they had to return, and he went for help, leaving Tuke just through the brattice door. On his return Tuke and he got Lamb out, and tried to bring him round, but he was dead. Witness collapsed from the effect of the gas. He stopped the fan after Lamb had been brought out.

Mr. Lightfoot: Were you always in attendance at the fan on your shift? — Yes.

You know something about ventilating? — No.

You found that the deceased man had left his testing lamp about 100 yards from the face of the drift? — Yes.

Can you give any reason for that? — No.

Did you notice the condition of the last three lengths of pipe? — Yes.

Did you notice that two were loose and the third slightly out of position, though not entirely dislocated, but in such a position as to block the current of air? — Yes.

Mr. Bowerbank: Is it usual to turn the compressor on? — Yes.

Could Lamb have done it if he wished? — Yes.

Norman Tuke, stone drifter, of 10, Duke Street, gave corroborative evidence regarding the finding of Lamb. He had never known gas to be reported in that drift.

Fan Questions

Robert McFarland, under manager at William Pit, said it was the practice before the accident to stop the fan at the weekends. There was now a new ventilation system in operation, but since the accident, on the advice of the inspector, they ran the fan over the weekend. In his opinion the ventilation was adequate at all times.

Mr. Lightfoot: Do you account for the extra gas on this weekend by the fact that the dislocated section at the end of the air pipe retarded the flow air? — Yes.

Witness stated that the Mines Act provided that if there were less than 2½ per cent of gas in the general body of the air, the men could work in it, but shot-firing could not take place. The purpose of the fan was to clear the air altogether for the purpose of shot-firing. There was no shot-firing over the weekend.

William Loudon, Whitehaven, Inspector of Mines for the district, in answer to Mr. Lightfoot, said that the fan provided adequate ventilation — when it was kept running.

Re-examined by Mr. Curwen: Witness said the custom of the deputies was to set the fan going before they inspected, and as they came to this drift last it was generally clear.

Harold Taylor Foster, of Newcastle, Assistant Divisional Mines Inspector, spoke of inspecting William Pit. Having stopped the fan he went to the end of the ventilation pipes and found that there was no natural current. There was not adequate ventilation without the fan.

The Defence

Mr. Lightfoot, opening for the defence, said the prosecution properly included the owners in the prosecution. The Act stated that if the owners were not in the habit of taking part in the working of the colliery; if they made the financial provision necessary to enable the manager to carry out his duties; and if they had no connivance or knowledge of the matter concerned, they were not culpable. He would call evidence to show that the owners complied with all three points. Mr. Foggo was their agent, and he, with the manager Wilson, accepted all responsibility in the matter. It was the contention of the defence that all that was necessary to effect adequate ventilation in the drift, except when firing was going on and every vestige of gas must be cleared, was the use of the ventilation pipe, without the use of the fan. This was a stone drift, where firing had to go on. These operations did not go on during the weekend. Consequently, it was not necessary to clear every vestige of gas from the air. No section of the Act stated that it was obligatory to have a fan. The legislation said that they must constantly and adequately ventilate, whether or not a fan was necessary.

With regard to Lamb he might have avoided the fatality to himself if he had not done the remarkable and unaccountable thing of leaving one hundred yards behind him the only instrument with which he could test the intensity of the gas — his oil lamp. No one would condemn a man who had lost his life, but strictly his action was not such as to comply with the regulations, which required him to go down an hour before the workmen and test to see if the pit were safe for the men to work in. The stopping of the fan over the weekend was not a question of the Company's saving labour. They had two men down the pit, and they would merely have had to see that nothing happened to it. The cost of the power to drive the fan was a miserable 15s for the thirty hours over the weekend. It was with no idea of effecting a saving that the Company stopped the fan over the weekend. The only reason that it was not used was that it was deemed to be unnecessary. He could not see that the prosecution had a leg on which to stand.

Solicitor v Clerk

John Frederick Foggo said he had been agent for the colliery since May. He took full responsibility for the ventilation of the pit, along with the manager, Mr. Wilson.

William Lamont, shot-firer, said there was nothing wrong with the pipes on the Saturday.

The Bench retired to consider their verdict, and on their return the chairman said: "The Bench is unanimous in finding the case proved, and the Company will be fined £10, the agent £10, and the manager £10."

Mr. Lightfoot: I think you have fined the Company £10. What evidence is there that the Company should be fined? — There is no dispute about that.

Mr. Skerry: Doesn't the Act say so?

Mr. Lightfoot: You cannot possibly fine the Company. They have proved what is necessary in the proviso, and it has not been disputed. It is not at issue between the parties.

Mr. Skerry quoted a recent case, and said he did not agree.

Mr. Lightfoot: I submit that that is not the construction, whatever you advise the Bench. How on earth any conviction can be recorded under the circumstances I do not know.

Mr. Skerry: I don't know that it has been accepted. I don't know what Mr. Curwen has to say. What you suggest is that under the section the owner is not liable to any penalty if he has complied with the three things specified.

Mr. Lightfoot: It is quite obvious that no decision in any case can upset the wording of the statute. We will have to consider the question of ridding ourselves of the conviction against the Company.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Bowerbank, —      
Curwen, J. N. St. G.    Solicitor  
Davies, Thomas Greenland    H.M. Divisional Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Foggo, John Frederick    Managing Director  Whos Who Page
Foster, Harold Taylor    H.M. Assistant Divisional Mines Inspector  Whos Who Page
Lamb, Richard   38 Deputy  Deceased, Individual Page
Lamont, William    Shot Firer  
Lightfoot, G. A.    Solicitor  
Loudon, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
McFarland, Robert    Under Manager  Whos Who Page
Metcalf, —    Miner  
Moffat, —    Miner  
Smith, Walter    Pumpsman  
Tuke, Norman    Stone Drifter  
Wilson, John    Manager  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Clifton Colliery  Clifton Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print