|
26th June 1924 Alleged "Tub Sticking"Wellington Pit Miners ChargedAt Whitehaven Police Court, on Monday, Robert Stewart, coal hewer, 34, New Arrowthwaite, Whitehaven, and Robert Dodds, coal hewer, 70, Church Street, Whitehaven, were summoned for obtaining by false pretence 4s 7d from the Whitehaven Colliery Co. Ltd, on 7th June. The pits not being working, the Court was filled to its utmost capacity. After a long address, Mr. Chapman (prosecuting) said there must be strong feeling amongst the Wellington Pit men against the men who would rob their comrades. Edward Rudd, Pottery House, Ginns, Whitehaven, said he went down the pit with Joseph Lilley on Sunday evening, 25th May, starting at eleven and coming out at 6 a.m. Lilley and himself would have ten tubs, and when they would leave on Monday morning two would be left at the siding. Their number was 53. Cross-examined by Mr. Sumner (defending): It was only recently that they claimed these tubs — within the last week. It was after re-constructing everything with the check-weighman. The only way, witness admitted, of getting to know how many tubs they filled was when they got the pay checks. The two defendants had reported that they had filled two tubs for which they had not worked. Joseph Henry Lilley, 31, Senhouse Street, Whitehaven, said he was the last witness's working mate. They worked ten tubs and he was sure of two being left. The following night they found that they were two tubs short. Replying to Mr. Sumner: They did not put the two tubs there, but they knew that they were there, as they had arranged with other workers filling the tubs. Witness himself did not see the tubs there, but he knew there was one for he put it there himself. In answer to the Clerk, witness said that his mate and himself only got credit for eight tubs. James Harrison, 46, Front Row, Newhouses, stated that he went down the pit with James Irving. They were with the two defendants. All proceeded to take empty tubs. Irving suggested that witness and he should fill the tubs with loose coal. Twenty-five yards away witness saw a light and shouted, "Is that you, Dick?" (meaning Stewart), but he received no answer. Witness then took the empty tub down and proceeded to fill. Irving joined him. Witness saw Stewart come down with two empty tubs about ten minutes after he had seen the light. Witness helped defendant to side-track the tubs, as the tubs that were standing blocked the way. Witness said that having lost so many tubs they had been chalking their tubs. Witness looked at the tubs standing and found that there were two numbered 52. He thought this remarkable as no one had been working in number 52. Witness sent for Quayle (the delegate), and things were explained to him. Quayle said, "This is a d----- case; if you took these tubs Stewart I would admit it." Stewart would not admit "sticking" tubs, but said he was willing to give them back. James Irving, 47, Front Row, Newhouses, Whitehaven, corroborated the evidence of the last witness. Witness asked Dodds when the tubs were filled, and Dodds said, "This morning." Witness said, "He must be an electric man or an aeroplane." Cross-examined by Mr. Sumner: Witness said he would make a fuss about any man's tub being "stuck." Dodds was never near the tubs. Thomas Allan Quayle, delegate, stated that he took steps to bring these men together. Witness asked Stewart what he had been doing that morning. He said he had been "sliping" two tubs. Witness told him that it was an utter impossibility for a man to "slipe" in those particular places which were inspected. Witness then asked Stewart to give the tubs back to the men whom he had taken the tubs from. Defendants agreed to give the tubs back again. Stewart was then called, and in reply to Mr. Sumner, stated that he worked for the Colliery Company 16 or 17 years and the only thing he received from the Colliery Company was a testimonial in regard to the Wellington Pit Disaster. He agreed he was working in the pit on this date and was at the siding between 7 and 7.30. They all went in together. His token number was 52. Witness described what he did when he got down the pit, and said it was the joiner's duty to report him if he had been "sliping." Witness told Dodds he had filled two tubs, and had not time to fill a third as the joiner was about. He admitted having "sliped" two tubs of coal, but he did not change any tokens. Quayle came in a bullying attitude, and defendant agreed to give the tubs up saying that Harrison and Irving could have them to save a "row." Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: If he had "stuck" he would have had number 52. Mr. Chapman: About someone bullying you. Who is the bully? — Quayle. Defendant added that Quayle was appointed by the Union. In further reply to Mr. Chapman, defendant agreed that he never heard of a man giving tubs up which he had worked. He did not deny that two tubs were missed. By Mr. Sumner: A week previous he had reported to the Colliery Company with others that they had been credited with nine tubs which they had not worked for. Confusion arose at times. Robert Dodds, 70, George Street, Whitehaven, stated that Harrison and Irving did not accuse him of "sticking" the tubs. He was working 150 yards away. Cross-examined by Mr. Chapman: All the coal in their working was loose. It had fallen ever since the time of the explosion. Quayle was their servant, and if there had been any marks he would have found them. When Stewart said he would give the tubs up, he (witness) could not speak he was so nervous. Mr. Sumner then addressed the Bench. He said there was no direct evidence against Stewart: it was circumstantial evidence which had to be examined closely. Dodds had made no pretence whatever. The prosecution had not proved that these men had received any money at all. Mr. Chapman said it would be the best point in defendants' favour to deny that they did not get the money, but they could not do it. After a lengthy retirement the Chairman (Mr. W. McGowan) said that on the prosecution having failed to produce any evidence that any money had been paid to these men they had no other course but to dismiss the summons.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||