Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

19th June 1924

£300 For Widow

Cleator Moor Compensation Case

Echo Of Brain Removal

In a case at Whitehaven County Court, on Saturday, before Judge Gawan Taylor, that presented several unusual legal features, and involved much medical evidence of a technical nature.

Mrs. Elizabeth Aston, of 49, Bowthorn Road, Cleator Moor, widow of the late Mr. Albert Moore Aston, was awarded £300 compensation for her husband's death. Mrs. Aston applied under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1906, alleging that her husband's death was due to injury from an accident arriving out of his employment at the mine of the respondents, the Bigrigg Mining Co. Ltd.

Among those who listened to the proceedings, which occupied several hours, was Mr. Gavan Duffy M.P, who, it will be remembered, attended the inquest at Cleator Moor several weeks ago, and protested against the removal and production at the inquest of the man's brain, afterwards raising the question in Parliament.

Dr. Crerar, giving evidence for the respondents, replying to Mr. J. Hope Brown, of Messrs Brown, Auld, and Brown, representing the respondents, said he did not see Aston before or after his death, so that his evidence was based on what he had been told of the case.

After discussion between the Judge, Mr. Brown, and Mr. Gorman (a Manchester barrister instructed by Messrs Wood, Lord, and Sumner, for the applicant. Dr. Crerar left the box.

Dr. Harper was next called, and said on 19th April a post-mortem examination on the body of Mr. Aston was made by Dr. Clark, at which he (witness) was present. On opening the skull, a tumour about the size of a hen's egg was found in the frontal lobe of the left half of the brain. That part of the brain was much softened. The body showed no other sign of disease or external sign of injury. Mrs. Aston told him her husband had a fit on returning from work one day. There was no evidence of inflammation of the brain.

Dr. Crerar was recalled, and said the outstanding features revealed by the post-mortem examination were the presence of a large tumour, considerable thickening of the coverings of the brain, complete absence of evidence of injury to bone, absence of bleeding in or about the brain, the fact that the left half of the brain was very soft, and the absence of inflammation.

His Honour: I am instructed that the absence of oerebutis is neither here nor there.

Dr. Crerar said that brain softening was not indicative of inflammation, but was due to interference with the blood supply. The presence of a tumour in the position described probably would lead to obstruction of the blood supply to the left half of the brain. Unless it were a very soft tumour, it must have taken much more than seven months to grow.

Replying to the Judge, witness said no one could say a blow on the head would or would not accelerate the growth of a tumour.

Mr. Gorman, stating his case, said Aston was 33 years of age, and prior to the accident had not been attended by a doctor for anything except bronchitis. On the day in question Aston was engaged in pushing trucks from the pit down to the hopper. The passage down which he had to go varied from five to four feet in height, being only four feet at the place where the metal was tipped into the hopper. He was working with a man named Myers all the morning, and had to push the truck a distance of 80 or 90 yards to the hopper. The roof was very rough, and after taking a truck down Aston was found lying on his back in a space between the wagon and the wall. The man at that time was unconscious.

His Honour asked if the respondents said there was no accident.

Mr. Brown said the respondents' contention was that Aston died simply and solely because he had a tumour on the brain; that while he was at work the disease reached a certain stage, in consequence of which he fell without receiving any injury from the fall. Under those circumstances he submitted there was no liability on the part of the respondents.

His Honour asked if the man was perfect health five minutes before and then was found lying there unconscious, was not that an accident "arising out of and in the course of his employment."

Mr. Brown held that there was no evidence upon which his Honour could infer that.

Mr. Gorman proceeding, said the inference was that the man had caught his head on the roof.

Mrs. Aston said her husband died on 16th April. He had worked in the mines six years, and had never complained of any pain in his head before the accident. On the morning of the accident he left home apparently well. When he returned his face was white, and he was drowsy. She noticed a mark on the right side and a bruise above the left eye. He put his hand on the left side and said, "Oh, my head!" She put some cold water bandages above the left eye. Later, he had a fit, and she sent for Dr. Eaton. He stayed in bed about three days, and continued to complain about his head. He then went back to work for a fortnight and a day, and then had to give up.

Cross-examined by Mr. Brown, she said that she ought not to have gone to the inquest, as she was not in a fit state of mind. Mr. Brown asked whether certain statements she had made at the inquest were correct, she said she did not remember what she had said.

The Judge: I should have thought a wife would have remembered.

William Myers, iron ore miner, of 21, Penzance Street, Moor Row, said he had known Mr. Aston for a number of years, and Mr. Aston had seemed to be in good health. On the day of the accident he saw Aston lying on his back, with a mark on the left side of his head. He thought Aston had had a "bat" on his head, and Aston said he had.

Replying to Mr. Brown, witness said that at the inquest he said he noticed nothing but a little mark above the left eye. He did not say the right eye. The roof was very ragged, but he did not notice any blood on Aston's head. He was in a dazed condition, and at first did not answer witness's first question as to whether he had had a "bat."

The Judge asked if he had known Aston to fall before or to have an accident, and witness said no.

Tom Whitehead, St Bees, who works at the Bigrigg mine, described the position of Aston when he was found. Previously, Aston had always appeared to be all right. He heard Aston say he had struck his head.

Answering Mr. Brown, witness said he did not notice a mark on Aston's head.

Dr. Eaton, of Cleator Moor, said he attended the post-mortem examination. All they found was consistent with the story he had told when he was alive. Witness knew the man for years, and he was an altered man after the accident. He used to visit witness for bronchitis. If his change of health was due to the tumour, it was a very strange coincidence that it happened after the accident. A blow would have aggravated the condition of the tumour, if it had been there before the accident. Or, as a result of a blow, there might have been an effusion of blood into the frontal lobe, and organisation set up by which nature had produced the tumour mass to heal the trouble.

Mr. Brown: You do not know what the nature of this tumour was? — No.

Witness continued that there was a possibility of a blood tumour in this case as the result of an accident. As a matter of fact it was well forward in the frontal lobe, and the softening of the brain was due to it.

Mr. Brown: But you agree with Dr. Crerar that the softening must have been set up by obstruction of the blood supply? — Yes.

Further questioned, witness said a severe blow might set up inflammation.

Dr. Robertson said he thought possibly the man had a tumour before the accident, but the clinical history of the case showed that the injury might have accentuated a growth. The accident might have caused the tumour.

Mr. Brown submitted that applicant had not discharged the onus of proving that an accident happened and Aston suffered injury which caused or contributed to his death.

Isaac Walker, manager of the pit, said that for the past three years Aston had been in indifferent health.

Mr. Gorman dealt with the legal position, and in conclusion suggested that there were two contributory causes to be considered. Either the man's death was due entirely to the blow or to the effects of the tumour accelerated or intensified by the effect of the blow.

His Honour retired with Dr. Maclaren (who sat with him as medical referee), and on returning, said the medical referee had given very careful attention to the case, and advised that the man had suffered before the date of the accident from tumour of the brain, but was clearly of opinion that the severe blow which the man received contributed to or intensified the brain trouble. After his experience of the medical referee, his Honour said he had full confidence in adopting his advice that the blow had contributed to the man's death, and he gave his award for the applicant for £300.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Aston, Albert Moore   33 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Aston, Elizabeth, Mrs.      Widow
Auld, —    Solicitor  
Brown, J. Hope    Solicitor  
Clark, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Crerar, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Eaton, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    M.P.  Whos Who Page
Gorman, —    Barrister  
Harper, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Lord, —    Solicitor  
Maclaren, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Myers, William    Miner  
Robertson, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Sumner, —    Solicitor  
Taylor, Gawan    Judge  
Walker, Isaac    Manager  Whos Who Page
Whitehead, Tom    Miner  
Wood, —    Solicitor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Sir John Walsh (Iron Ore)  Sir John Walsh (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print