|
19th June 1924 Loss Of A FingerCleator Moor Miner's CompensationFour miners, each of whom had lost a finger, were among witnesses in a compensation case at Whitehaven Police Court, on Saturday. The Wyndham Mining Co Ltd made an application against the weekly compensation to Edward Eldon, of 14, Bungalows, Cleator Moor, under the Workmen's Compensation Act, in respect of injury received by the respondent on 24th August 1922. It was explained by Mr. J. Hope Brown (for the applicants) that respondent was working in the mine when fingers of his left hand were crushed with a bogie. Two joints of the middle finger were amputated. In January 1923, an agreement for 19s a week and an additional sum of 14s 3d weekly in respect of war additions was made. About July, 1923, applicants medical advisors reported him fit for work, and respondent worked for four hours. He complained of pain in his hand and arm. Last January he was reported again fit for work. It was maintained that to all intents and purposes he was as fit for work as an ordinary miner. Dr. Crerar, of Maryport, gave evidence of examining Mr. Eldon on 6th June. Mr. Eldon complained of pain in the hand, extending to the elbow; inability to sleep and giddiness. Dr. Crerar, cross-examined by Mr. Brown, said there were scars on the ring finger, but Mr. Eldon agreed that it was all right. The hand generally was in excellent condition. There was no evidence of atrophy of muscular groups, and all movements of the hand were correct. He thought the general health of Mr. Eldon good, and apart from the loss of a finger he had completely recovered. Answering Mr. Gorman, barrister, who appeared on behalf of Mr. Eldon, witness said very rarely was the grip of a left hand so strong as that of the right hand. There must be a diminution of power following the loss of a finger. The pain had no anatomical relationship with the hand — there was no thickening of the nerves, and no muscular wastage. Dr. R. B. Eadie said he examined Eldon, who did not complain of pain in the hand itself, or of weakness in the hand. He could find nothing to account for pain of which Eldon complained in his arm. In witness's opinion he was capable of doing his work. Cross-examined by Mr. Gorman, witness said Eldon, although he could do the work of a miner, couldn't do many other kinds of work. Witness agreed that in a case of this kind, although there might be no objective evidence of pain, there might be pain. Charles Booth, underground manager of the Beckermet mines, said the greater part of the work consisted of filling, tipping, and other operations in connection with bogies. His Honour (Judge Gawan Taylor): Can he do that as well without his middle finger? — Every day. The Judge: Nature seems to have given us too many fingers. (Laughter.) Witness also said there were several miners and other workers at the mines at Beckermet who were working without one or more fingers. The Judge: Are you inclined to take this man on? — If we wanted a man I would think him as good as any. Four miners who had lost a finger or part of a finger gave evidence of being able to work in spite of their disability; and further medical evidence was called, the effect of which was that subsequent to the first operation it was satisfactorily proved that Eldon's complaints were justified, and that a man might have neuritis without any outward symptoms. The Judge found that justice would be met by awarding 12s 6d a week. Mr. Gorman applied for costs. Mr. Brown: I think I have substantially succeeded, and I ask for costs. The Judge: Then the measure of success is somewhat reduced. Mr. Gorman submitted that as Mr. Brown had not applied for a reduction, his application for costs did not apply. The intention had been to stop compensation, and by failure to obtain more than revision he (Mr. Gorman) had satisfactorily met the applicants case. The Judge settled the dispute by ordering the parties to pay their own costs.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||