28th February 1924
The Iron Ore Industry
Wages And Costs
[By Mr. C. Edmonds.]
In reflecting upon the present condition of the Frizington and Cleator Moor iron ore districts one is apt to recall the pessimistic utterance of Dickie Watson, Frizington's own and only ancient rhymer. Written sometime between 1855 and 1860, the
following verses, if they cannot lay claim to lyric distinction, at least give a very vivid picture of what times were like in the district about that period of the industrial history of the iron mines of West Cumberland.
The Country's Done, They Say!
I must away from Cleator Moor,
I can no longer stay;
For things are getting worse and worse,
The country's done, they say.
The labouring miner now-a-days,
Can scarce exist at all;
Provisions are so very dear,
And wages are so small.
I must away from Cleator Moor,
I can no longer stay;
For things are getting worse and worse,
The country's done they say!
There's Crow Garth pit is now done up,
The mineral is wrought out;
And Stirling's works have fallen in,
They'll not last long, I doubt.
On Bigrigg Moor and round Parkside,
Things are but going slack;
I'll just pack up my clothes at once,
And swing them o'er my back.
And I'll away from Cleator Moor,
I can no longer stay;
For things are getting worse and worse,
The country's done, they say.
There are three more verses, not forgetting the same old chorus at the end of each, but we will return to our fact and figures. As will be seen here and after, the iron ore industry of West Cumberland in particular and iron mining in general, is unique
in this - that the wages of the producers do not form the major portion of the working costs of the industry. But before we enter into details let us take a glance at the evolution of the wage system as it applies to the iron ore mines.
Early Wage Rates.
As everybody who is acquainted with the early history of the iron ore mining of the area is aware, the first attempts at mining were made in open casts or small quarries. From the first - about 1830 - labour had to be imported into the district. The
focus principal sources for the supply of labour were Ireland, Cornwall, the Isle of Man, and Wales. There is very little record of wages in the earliest stages, and one has to rely mainly on verbal statements handed down.
Up to 1860 the average wages of miners appears to have been from 1s 6d to 2s 3d per day. In the sixties wages rose rapidly and attracted the Cornish miners, who asked to the district. With the seventies came higher wages still, until one hears of
£1 per day having been reached. The Cornish miners had been used to a system which they called "putting up for tribute," whereby certain of the workings, or all of them, were put up for auction periodically, and knocked down to the
lowest bidder amongst the men. The man who took the place could choose his rate, and take a boy along with him.
This system formed the nucleus of the present arrangement of grades now incorporated in our own district. Some of the more enterprising of the miners, however, ???? of taking single workings, became more ambitious and as the supply of labour began to
exceed the demand took "bargains," or contracts on whole levels and sometimes took the whole mine under contract.
In many instances, therefore, there was no doubt about the miner getting his £1 per day, if he were a contractor, but if he were not, he had to be content with anything from 2s 6d to 3s 6d.
"The Good Old Times"
Lurid tales are told by the oldest miners of the bribery and corruption attendance on such a system, and although frequent attempts are made by odd mid-Victorian mining employers to revive the systems, such attempts have never hitherto succeeded, nor are
they likely to.
One old Cornish miner used to say to the writer, "Pit he no good now-a-days, boy there be too many clerks and gaffers and timekeepers. In the good old times, thee could go when thee liked, and step down as they liked, and get as much ore as thee
liked and go along home when thee liked.. Thee just came up at pay days and got the money shovelled out to thee by the owner and his son without any bother."
The late eighties were lean years and numerous attempts amongst the miners to form combinations ended in the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' Union being established in 1889. In 1891, the average wage for miners was about 5s 6d per day, although even then
companies of men who could get the ore at a very cheap rate were allowed to make as much as they could so long as they "got the ore at the managers prices." The labourers underground were paid 3s 6d.
Grading The Workers
For those who are unaware of the various grades of workers in these mines it would perhaps be as well to enumerate them. Underground, there are the miners proper, the "full men," as they are termed in local parlances; these are the responsible
men on the workings. They do the drilling, blasting, dressing, and timbering. Next are the leading labourers, who usually fill and trail the ore from the working places to the various stages on the way to the shaft. On the main roads the timbering is
done by shiftsmen. If the workings are on different levels from the shaft, trailers are usually employed, and, in many mines, the trailing is still let by contract. The grades above mentioned form about 85 to 90% of the number of men employed at the
mines. The remainder are surface workers, comprising, winding-engine men, joiners, blacksmiths, fitters, surface labourers, bankers, and officials.
From 1890 to 1905 the miners average wages fluctuated between 5s 3d and 6s 3d, and the leading labourer's wage gradually rose from 3s 6d to 4s 6d. About this time a sliding scale was instituted, and towards the middle of 1907, when pig-iron reached the
high figure of 80s per ton, the average wage rose to 7s 6d per day for miners and 4s 9d for labourers. Toward the end of the same year prices began to decline, and wages dropped to about 5s 6d per day. The three years preceding the war were the best
years for wages in the whole pre-war history of the industry.
The High Level Period.
In 1912 the miners wages rose to 9s 6d per day, with advances in other grades pro rata. During the early days of the war the wages of the whole district were regulated by three conciliation boards, each having its own basic and its own particular
sliding scale. Prices and wages rose rapidly until the government were compelled to stop the upward flight, and consequently the price of pig-iron was fixed at 105s; this figure gave the miners a bargain price of 11s 3d and a minimum wage of 9s 6d. It
was no until after the war, however, that the hey-day of wagedom arrived.
After the miners were de-controlled pig-iron prices went higher and higher, and after the prices followed the wages. The following figures speak for themselves:
1919, ascertainment, Sept./Oct., 207/- ; miners wages , 18/11; 1914, Nov./Dec., 205/-; 18/9; 1920, Jan./Feb., 216/-; 19/8; 1920, Mar./Apr., 240/-; 21/8; 1920, May/June, 268/-; 24/-; 1920, July/Aug., 283/-; 25/5; 1920, Sept./Oct., 286/6; 25/6, 1920,
Nov/Dec., 253/-; 26/1; 1922, Jan./Feb., 265/6; 23/10, 1921, Mar./Apr., 216/-; 19/8; 1921, May/June; 206/-; 18/10, 1921, July/Aug., 164/10; 15/5, 1921, Sept./ Oct., 142/-; 13/5; 1921, Nov. 124/-; 11/11; 1921, Dec., 114/-; 11/2; 1922, Jan. 105/3; 10/6;
1922, Feb., 102/-; 10/2; 1922, Mar., 99/3, 10/-; 1922, Apr., 98/6; 9/11; 1922, Sept., 89/5; 9/1.
In September, 1922, the minimum price of pig-iron was reached, since when there has been a slight upward movement, the figure now standing at 101/- per ton.
As was previously stated the actual wage cost compared with the total cost is far below that of any other industry. Take for comparison the figures of the most profitable of British coalfields as given by the Board of Trade returns, and compare it with
two of the best iron ore mines of this district.
Comparative Working Costs
Coal. Iron Ore.
Wages 11/4 6/3 5/5
St'r's & T'ber 2/1 2/3 2/9
Management
Salaries, Ins'r'ce
Rt's, Taxes, and
Offices, &c., 2/- 1/3 1/6
Coals and Pumping 3/6 3/7
Rail, Rates &
Royalties -/7 Royalties 7/6 7/-
Profit 3/2 2/3 1/3
--- --- ---
Price per Ton 19/2 23/- 21/6
[Decimal fractions omitted.]
When ore was at 12s per ton, the miner's cost worked out at about 3s 6d per ton. Of course, it is impossible to get very accurate figures, as each individual mine has its own peculiar item of excessive cost. One mine had to pay about one-third of its
receipts for the pumping of water alone. Another has a royalty equal to one-sixth of its income. It is obvious that some drastic readjustments will have to be made in the very near future if the industry is to be put on a reasonable competitive footing
with like industries of other countries.
[Next week out contributor in the final article of this interesting series will deal with the future if the industry and suggest some possible improvements.]
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Edmonds, C. | | | |
| Watson, Dickie | | | |