|
12th October 1922 The Whitehaven ExplosionManager's TheoryEvidence as to the cause of the explosion at Haig pit, Whitehaven, on September 5, when thirty-nine lives were lost, was given at yesterday's inquiry by Mr. Alexander Kilpatrick, manager of the pit. He said the deputies had instructions to report the presence of gas immediately they found any trace of it, and there was to be no shot firing. He admitted that two of the deputies had worked extra long shifts with his sanction, because one of the deputies was absent on holiday. He preferred to do this rather than appoint another man with no previous experience. A match was found in one man's pocket after the accident, while another man had a cigarette. He expressed the opinion that the explosion started with fire damp. There had probably been a large outburst of gas, and the gas had a carried on the explosion. Mr. Wilson, Inspector of Mines, pointed out that to carry the explosion throughout the district affected meant that there was an explosive mixture in the whole area. The witness concurred. Mr. Wilson. — Does not that mean a lot of fire damp? The witness. — Yes. He expressed the opinion that the explosion began in a level where a cable had been laid out and connected to a battery, showing that a shot had been fired. Mr. Wilson. — If the district was naturally wet throughout you would not say coal dust did not play any part in the explosion? The witness. — In my opinion it did not. Mr. Herbert Smith (president of the Miners' Federation) questioned the witness regarding the qualifications of Brewster, the shot-firer. He put it that Brewster had not five years practical experience, as required by the mining regulations. The witness said Brewster told him he had three years' experience at another colliery, and he had been employed at Whitehaven since April, 1920. He also had experience in Canada and South Africa, and in some of the iron ore mines. Mr. MacQuisten, K.C., for the colliery company, said he was advised there was nothing in the Act as to the qualifications of a shot firer. The Coroner pointed out that the Act specified "a competent person." Mr. Smith said it was left to the management to judge whether he was competent or not. Mr. Smith alleged that the witness refused to engage men who had worked at Whitehaven. This the witness denied, saying that no bar was put on Whitehaven men, but they did not want to take them from other pits. When Mr. Smith pressed him on the question of shot-firing the witness protested that they were not going to continue with it. Mr. Smith. — I know thirty-nine men have paid the price. "Tampering with ventilation is tampering with lives," he declared later, when he expressed his dissatisfaction with the system adopted at the colliery. Before the Court adjourned, the Coroner read a certificate showing that Brewster was appointed deputy and shot firer in July last, with charge of detonators and safety lamps.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||