|
31st August 1922 The Accident On Ladysmith BrakeAdjourned InquestThe adjourned inquest with regard to the death of George Williamson Mackreth (27), colliery labourer, who was injured while working on the new brake at Ladysmith Pit on 18th August, was held at the Police Station, Whitehaven, on Tuesday afternoon by Mr. R. W. Marley (deputy coroner), and a jury, of which Mr. W. T. Lucas was foreman. There were also present: Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. L. T. Helder, representing the Whitehaven Colliery Company; Mr. E. H. Evans, on behalf of the relatives of Mackreth, and Mr. R Steel, the Colliery Co's works manager. Medical evidence was first given, Dr. Harris stating that when Mackreth was admitted to Whitehaven Infirmary he was suffering from concussion of the brain, fractured right thigh, and fracture of the left shoulder blade, and severe bruising on the left side from the shoulder to the hip. The primary cause of death — which took place on 23rd August — was concussion of the brain. In reply to the Inspector and Mr. Evans witness said there were some slight abrasions between the legs. It was quite possible he might have been lifted up by a rope and yet no mark had been shown on his legs, especially if he had clothing on. William Henry Johnson, mining engineer for the Colliery Company, put in and explained a plan of the brake. At the brake top there was a drum on which were wire ropes, which were used in connection with the wagons. The weight of full wagons on one side of the brake pulled up the empty wagons on the other side. When two wagons were going over the brake top on 18th August, one broke away and ran down the brake. There was a collision with some empty wagons about 500 yards down the brake, and the sudden tension on the empty rope lifted it from the ground and caught Mackreth, throwing him up in the air. Witness produced the draw bar, the snapping of which had caused the wagon to break away. The wagon, he said, belonged to the North British Railway Company. By the Deputy Coroner: It was very doubtful if anyone would have been able to detect the flaw in the draw bar, which the snapping of the bar had disclosed. There was a flaw through half its thickness. It had crystallised. The Deputy Coroner: I understand that after prolonged use metal of that character does crystallise? Witness: Yes, if it is exposed to repeated jerks and shocks. In reply to further questions witness said it was quite possible that the flaw might have existed for months, and still not be detected. By Mr. Evans: The wagons were supposed to be examined by the railway people. The colliery employees would not systematically test for a flaw like that. It was not part of their duty. It was possible to detect such a flaw by striking the metal with a hammer. Henry Lister, East Row, Kells, brakesman at new brake top, described how the wagon broke away. Mackreth afterwards went to look down the incline and was standing astride the rope when it caught him and threw him in the air. He fell face downwards on the ground. Before the wagons were put on at the top they always looked round to see if they were properly coupled. All appeared to be right before the accident. By the Inspector: They did not look to see if there was a fault in the coupling or draw bar, but just gave a slight glance round. When they let the wagons over, they saw that they were properly tight on the rope. There had not been any jerk on the rope. By Mr. Helder: It was no part of his duty to examine these wagons for flaws. That was done by the railway men at the bottom of the brake. By Mr. Evans: What they had to do was to see that the wagons were properly coupled. The effect of the collision was to cause the standing rope to fly up and strike Mackreth between the legs. He was flung into the air 15 feet or more. By a juror (Mr. Ewing): The wagon got away at the runaway point. Mr. Ewing, after asking several further questions, suggested that the jury should visit the place, but the Deputy Coroner pointed out that it was rather late in the day for that. Asked by Mr. Ewing if he did not think it would be advisable to have another hand at the brake top, witness, said two were quite plenty. John Joseph Gaitskell, Newtown, brakesman, employed at the brake bottom, also gave evidence. By the Inspector: The railway men always examined the couplings on the siding. Every truck that went up the brake was examined. The man who examined the wagons tapped the wheels and looked at the draw bar. He could not say he had ever seen him strike the draw bar with a hammer. There might be a flaw in the draw bar that could not be detected. Witness was satisfied with the examination made. By Mr. Helder: What they thought necessary they examined with a hammer. The wagons were examined both when they went on and came off the brake. In reply to Mr. Evans, witness said he had never seen them take a hammer to the draw bar, if the manager was satisfied with the examination he (witness) was. By Mr. Ewing: If a railway inspector examined a wagon and did not put a ticket on it when it was not satisfactory witness would use his own judgement as to whether he sent it up the brake or not. By another juror (Mr. Martin): He has seen two draw bars break since he had been on the job. The Deputy Coroner said the evidence seemed to show that the examination of the couplings was not what it might be, and he thought it was a pity that the Railway Co. were not represented at the inquest. He wrote to them and told them when the adjourned inquest would be held, and he had a reply in which they said they did not consider it necessary to send anybody, which, to his mind, perhaps was unfortunate. The presence of a railway official might have thrown more light on the matter. The jury retired, and after several minutes' absence, the Foreman announced that their verdict was that Mackreth met his death by an accident during the course of his employment. The jury thought the Railway Co. should have been represented and they also recommended to the Colliery Co. the use of bridle chains in future on the brake. The Deputy Coroner said he would convey the jury's expression of opinion to the Railway Company. Mr. Helder said he would convey the jury's rider to the Colliery Company, who would consider whether it was feasible or not. On behalf of the Company he wished to express their sincere sympathy that this accident had happened, causing the loss of a valuable life, and to tender to the relatives their sympathy. The Deputy Coroner said the jury associated themselves with the expression of sympathy.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||