Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

20th July 1922

Fire Damp

Inquest On Two Whitehaven Miners

Coroner And Carelessness

The adjourned inquest on John Rogan (47), shot-firer, and Patrick Kilbane (30), chargeman, who so tragically lost their lives through an explosion in the Delaval district of William Pit, Whitehaven, on the night of July 11th, was held by Mr. D. J. Mason (coroner) at Whitehaven Police Court yesterday. Others present were: Mr. Wilson, H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines; Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector, Whitehaven; Mr. O. F. Ormrod, for the Whitehaven Colliery Co.; Mr. H. Braithwaite, representing the widow of John Rogan and the Cumberland Colliery Officials' Association; and Mr. E. H. Evans, for the relatives of Patrick Kilbane and the Whitehaven miners.

Mr. E. Partington was elected foreman of the jury, and there was a fairly large attendance of the public.

The Coroner called the names of the witnesses whose evidence was afterwards elicited by Mr. Cook.

Albert Atherton, drifter, 8, Low Road, Whitehaven, said he was employed filling metal between 15 and 20 yards from the face of the same drift as Rogan and Kilbane. Only the two deceased miners were at the face during the shift. About 10 o'clock witness came out to leave Rogan and Kilbane the shots. He had got out as far as the air compressor when he heard the normal report of a shot being fired. Five minutes later witness was still standing near the compressor when the explosion occurred. He heard no report of any shot. They were all knocked down. Witness came out 150 yards and met the men coming in and then they turned and went back to the drift. Rogan examined the drift with an oil lamp before they went up at 4-30 p.m. Rogan also examined it before he came out to fire the first shot. He then went down the drift again with the lamp. Witness did not see what sort of a lamp Rogan had when he went to fire the shot. He did not think Rogan would have time to go down the drift, get the lamp (assuming he had left it there), examine the place, and prepare the second shot between the first shot and the explosion. Out of the seven or eight minutes between the two reports five minutes would be taken up by Rogan making his examination if he did it in the ordinary way, and that would only leave him three minutes to travel down the drift to couple up the other shot.

By Mr. Wilson: He did not observe any holes in the brattice (a canvas and wooden screen for air purposes) before the shots were fired. There seemed to be good air in the drift. Compressed air was also playing into the drift during the whole of the shift. Kilbane was drilling holes at the face from the commencement of the shift until 8-30 p.m. and never complained about the place being warm or stuffy. They all used electric lamps except the shot-firer.

Mr. Wilson then asked witness if he had worked in gas, to which the reply was made that he had worked in small quantities and would be warned of gas by the smell.

Mr. Wilson: Pure fire-damp has not any smell. Therefore, you might be working in it and never know it. As long as it does not get you down you can't tell how much there is in the place unless you have a flame safety lamp.

By Mr. Evans: They had never found any difficulty in the drift in getting the holes fired.

By the Coroner: The other men in the drift had gone with the exception of the deceased and himself. Witness remained behind to put the gear away.

Thos. Tunstall, drifter, Distington, described the explosion as sounding like a "fizz."

By the Coroner: All Rogan's work consisted of was keeping the brattice right, looking for gas, and looking after the firing of shots.

James McLaughlin, coal hewer and Jas. Bigrigg, overman, members of the rescue party, told how the fumes of the explosion first drove them back from entering the drift. At the entrance to the place they found Regan's oil lamp undamaged. The latter witness said the drift was 93 yards long.

Thos. Cannon, deputy and shot-firer, 8, Bransty Road, Whitehaven, who worked in the drift on the previous shift, said the place was examined about four o'clock. It was then all right, and he told Rogan to finish some work on the brattice that he (witness) had started. He fired 10 shots on his shift. He had only found gas in the place at the week-ends when they had the brattice broken.

In answer to Mr. Cook, witness said it was obvious that gas had been in the place on this occasion.

It looks as if some of the brattice had been broken to allow the gas to accumulate? — Possibly. Witness added that the brattice was intact when he left.

Can you account for the gas filling that drift as it did between four p.m. and ten p.m.? — I can't account for it.

There must have been some brattice down between four p.m. and ten p.m. to make that drift foul? — Yes.

By Mr. Evans: The whole system of safety was in the hands of the deputy.

It was quite possible for a lump of material to come down and disconnect the ventilation.

Dr. J. McKay, medical practitioner, at Whitehaven, said he examined the bodies and certified death was due to extensive burning and shock.

Robert Brodie, manager at William Pit, said he was in the drift the previous day and everything was all right then. Witness recovered the bodies, and in close proximity to the men he found two electric lamps. No oil lamp was found in the drift. No other oil lamp beyond that found at the entrance to the drift was afterwards brought out. If the brattice was damaged by shot-firing gas would quickly come down the drift. One of the shots marked on the plan (produced) gave the impression of being a blown-out shot. He thought it had had no little to do. If the two shots marked on the plan had been fired together he would have seen some sense in it.

By Mr. Wilson: He had no doubt in his own mind that the shot had acted as a blown-out shot and ignited, the fire-damp.

And fire-damp could only get there if the brattice was imperfect? — Yes.

And if fire-damp had been looked for by a careful man with a flame safety-lamp he would have found it? — There would have been no explosion.

Mr. Evans: Do you not think the brick partition method preferable to the brattice method? — Yes and no. You can have it both ways.

Do you think it conducive for safety to have so many holes bored in a place like this at the same time? — I would have liked to see less bored and charged than I have seen in the face of this drift.

What is your opinion in regard to leaving the whole of the shot-firing work until the last three quarters-of-an-hour of the shift? — Nonsense, they have plenty of time to fire shots during the shift.

By the Coroner: He was afraid the calibre of shot-firers at the present day was not up to the old standard. By that he did not mean to cast any reflection upon Rogan. The wrong men went in for their certificates.

In summing up the Coroner said, Kilbane had nothing whatever to do with the firing of the shots. In so far as a man was not usually so reckless that he did not care what happened to himself he thought the jury might be justified in saying that there was no criminal negligence on the part of Rogan, and there was no suggestion of any negligence on the part of anyone else. This seemed to him a rather alarming accident because it was the second similar accident within the last 12 months that had occurred in Whitehaven. Personally he had no doubt whatever that the cause of these accidents was solely due to the fact that proper examination had not been made otherwise gas would have been discovered. He thought this matter should be spoken plainly about. Men did not do these things wilfully, but by carelessly neglecting to do certain things they entirely forgot that it was not merely themselves who might lose their lives but that they were endangering the lives of hundreds and possibly thousands of other men. Should accidents of this kind arise again he thought the matter should be given serious consideration as to what could be done.

The jury returned a verdict that the deceased were killed in an accidental explosion of gas, and were also of opinion that sufficiently careful examination was not always made.

Mr. Ormrod expressed the Company's sympathy with the relatives and said Rogan was regarded as a particularly experienced and satisfactory man. The Company were very grateful to the Coroner for the remarks made, and hoped that they might bring to the notice of everyone working in coal mines the necessity to take care in everything they did however small and trivial it might be.

The jury associated themselves with the sentiments expressed, and Mr. Braithwaite and Mr. Evans replied.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atherton, Albert    Drifter  
Bigrigg, James    Overman  
Braithwaite, H.    Solicitor  
Brodie, Robert Graham    Manager  Whos Who Page
Cannon, Thomas    Deputy  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Evans, E. H.    Solicitor  
Kilbane, Patrick   30 Chargeman  Deceased, Individual Page
Mason, D. J.    Coroner  Whos Who Page
McKay, J., Dr.    Doctor  
McLaughlin, James    Hewer  
Ormrod, O. F.    Solicitor  
Partington, E.    Jury Foreman  
Rogan, John   47 Shot Firer  Deceased, Individual Page
Tunstall, Thomas    Drifter  
Wilson, John Robert Robinson    H.M. Chief Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery



Related Articles

Pub.
Date
Article (Newspaper)
13 Jul 1922  Explosion In Whitehaven Pit, Tragic Death Of Two Workers (Whitehaven News)
20 Jul 1922  Fire Damp, Inquest On Two Whitehaven Miners, Coroner And Carelessness (Whitehaven News)

Links to related pages

 

Colliery Page  Main page for William Pit, Whitehaven
Disaster Page  Accident/Disaster Page

 

 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print