Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

(Unknown)

Article from the (Unknown), November 1921


A Blaydon Miner's Death

Killed Whilst Bringing Out Last Tub Of Shift

The Coroner And Ambulance Training

Mr. John Graham, Coroner, held an inquest on Friday into the death of John Barrett, aged 40, of 39 Polmaise Street, Blaydon, a coal hewer employed at the Bessie Pit, Blaydon Burn.

Mrs. Mary Ann Robson, of Burnley Street, Blaydon, gave evidence of identification and stated that the deceased was her son-in-law. He went to work at the Bessie Pit about 9 o'clock on Tuesday morning. His body was brought home at 6.30 in the evening.

The Coroner said he was sure it was very sad for Mrs. Robson.

Joseph Stonehouse, a deputy residing in Mary Street, Blaydon Burn, stated that about 3.30 p.m. on Tuesday Nov. 1st, he was checking the men under his charge who had come out-bye as it was the end of the shift. He checked all out but the deceased, whose working place was 29, West Brokens, Three-Quarter Seam, which was part of the Blaydon Burn Colliery.

The Coroner: How far is that from the drift?

Mr. Ridpath, colliery manager, said "it would be a mile or a mile and a quarter."

The Witness, Stonehouse, said he was at the meeting station at the flat when he missed Barrett. That would be about 180 yards away.

The Coroner: Then he would be tolerably near.

Proceeding, the witness said he went in-bye to look for Barrett. When he got to the bottom of 29 he found a full tub slightly hoisted on the flat sheets. He went into the face, but could not find the deceased, so assuming that he had hoisted his tub on the flat sheets in order to get past it, witness went to the check cabin at the drift mouth, about a mile or a mile and a quarter away. Witness enquired about Barrett's check as to whether it had been put in, and found that it had not. Witness went in-bye and met another deputy, named Archer, and they made a search. On witness putting his lamp over the top of the tub he saw the deceased lying at the other side of the tub. Witness tried to move the tub, but was unable to do so. He obtained help from Archer and four other men, Ellis, Taylor, Hurst and Sharp. They set to work to remove the tub, a full one, in order to get to the deceased and found him bleeding from the ears and nose.

The Coroner remarked that the deceased must have received a fracture of the base of the skull.

The witness said he thought Barrett was not dead, said he tried artificial respiration for about fifteen minutes. Archer, the deputy, also tried artificial respiration.

The Coroner: I suppose you both had ambulance training had you?

Witness: Yes

The Coroner: Had the stonemen had any ambulance training?

Witness: Not that I am aware of.

The Coroner: May I take it as correct that the stonemen had no ambulance training?

Witness: Not that I am aware of.

The Coroner: It is the old story of officials having ambulance training, and the men just leaving it alone.

Mr. Ridpath stated that an ambulance class had been started specially for night shift men and was being well attended.

The Coroner: But why restrict this to night shift men? Men get injured and killed.

Mr. Foster, H.M. Inspector of Mines remarked that night shift men did not attend the ordinary classes.

The witness Stonehouse, continuing his evidence, said that when they found the deceased a message was sent for a doctor. After trying artificial respiration for about fifteen minutes they formed the opinion that Barrett was dead.

The Coroner: I should think you would have a pretty good idea that a man with a fractured base of the skull could not live long. It is a different thing altogether to an ordinary smashed limb or anything of that kind.

The witness stated that a stretcher was obtained and the deceased brought to bank. The last time witness saw deceased alive was at 1 o'clock. He was then in his working place. Having found the deceased's cap on the front end of the tub, witness formed the opinion that deceased had been coming down the board and had jammed his head between the top of the tub and the brow of a two feet hitch in the roof.

Mr. Foster pointed out that there was only a two inch clearance between the top of the tub and the hitch. It was stated that the deceased's head would be jammed between the rub and the hitch. He would then fall to one side and the tub would run onto the flat sheets. Deceased must have had his hands against the tub and walking backwards in front of the tub, and would therefore not see where he was going.

The Coroner: If he had his hands on the tub to keep it from running amain he might have struck his head.

Mr. Foster: He is coming on backwards and he is caught by this low plank.

The Coroner asked what was the gradient.

Mr. Foster: That brings in another point.

The Coroner: Whether he should have had a sprag.

Mr. Foster: Not exactly that. There was a general regulation that no one was allowed to come down in front of a tub if the gradient exceeded three inches to the yard. The gradient in this case, except for just a short distance, perhaps three feet, was all under three inches.

It was stated that the deceased's tub had got off the way. A plate was found out of its place six yards from the flat sheet.

The Coroner read the report of the men's inspectors, Messrs Lewis and Jeavons, which stated that as far as they were able to judge they thought that the tub had got off the way about six yards from the flat sheet, as they found a plate out of position. The deceased had then evidently come to the front end of the tub to lift it on, after which he brought the tub into the headways, walking in front of it.

The Coroner: Although he is in front of it, he would be walking backwards and he would not be able to see the drop in the roof, and therefore could not see the plank across the board where the roof ......................(unable to read this piece).

The deceased would be caught between the top of the tub and the plank which supported the brow of the hitch - this was consistent with the position in which the deceased was found. The plank was in good condition according to practice.

The Coroner remarked that he was pleased to be able to say that the report gave a very good description of the occurrence because lately he had had to take the opposite course; and it was an unpleasant thing to have to find. It was much more agreeable to him to be satisfied.

William Archer of Ruth Avenue, Blaydon, a deputy, said he was with ?..... when the body was found. He corroborated that witness.

The Coroner remarked that both Stonehouse and Archer did the very best they could. Unfortunately it was a case in which artificial respiration was not of the slightest service, because the man was too far gone. It was not an injury from which the deceased could recover.

The Coroner asked if there were any grievances to redress because he so many times found was the case. He did not want anybody to leave the Court having a grievance.

The miners' secretary said there was only one thing he would like to ask in regard to the deceased having to come down in front of the tub, holding it with his hands. In this particular case he thought the man would have no other option. When the tub got off the way the place would be so narrow and low that when he had to go to the front, he would not be able to get back after he got the tub on the way again.

The Coroner said that was rather a matter for the men's inspectors.

Mr. Foster stated that the deceased could have got over the top of the tub. He would like to point out that it was not safe to come down in front of a tub.

The Coroner: Of course, it is not.

Mr. Foster: It was not a breach of the Act in this case. It was very near, but it was not one.

The Coroner: The man thought he could do it quite safely. There was another thing that had occurred to his mind. It was the end of the shift and the deceased would be in a hurry. He supposed the deceased would have been in the place many a time before.

It was stated that that was the first day the deceased had been in the place. As it was the last tub, he brought it out himself.

Mr. Jeavons said they considered that on the men's part, everything was done that could be done.

The Coroner: That is very straight forward .....................................................................you and I'm glad to hear you say it.

There was another thing, remarked the Coroner, he should like to refer to. He thought that the system of checking men out was a most excellent one and that in this particular case it had been carried out most efficiently. He thought a great deal of credit was due to the deputy Joseph Stonehouse, who took all the trouble. He hoped that in all other pits if anything of the kind happened that those who were charged with the duty of seeing the men out would take the same trouble as Stonehouse did. That was one point he wishes to emphasise.

Then again, he would to give full credit to Joseph Stonehouse and William Archer, the deputy, for first of all having taken the trouble to qualify themselves to render first aid by attending ambulance classes and getting the certificates. In the present case, unfortunately, no amount of aid could have saved the man's life. He hoped their example would be following by the men in .......... and that during the coming winter would take the opportunity of getting ambulance instruction, so that when an accident happened the men were confident that all the help they were to get was from officials. It was ........... crowd of men going at great risk to get a man out, if they did not know what to do with the man when they got to him. If the rank and file would take initiative to join an ambulance class it would help very considerably in reducing the amount of agony and pain on the part of those who got injured.

The Coroner added that it was clear how the deceased had met his death and should like to hear what his record was.

Mr. Ridpath stated that the deceased started work in 1917. He had been a good workman and they had nothing against him. On behalf of the owners and officials, Mr. Ridpath expressed deep sympathy with the family of the deceased, remarking the he believed the deceased had a delicate wife and three children.

The Coroner said it was most regretted that a good man had lost his life and leaving a widow and children who were dependent upon him and that he felt great sympathy with those who were left, but as far as the case was concerned it was as pure an accident as could happen. He was thankful that he had not had occasion to find fault with anybody.

The Coroner returned a verdict that the deceased died from a fracture at the base of the skull accidentally caused by his head coming in contact with a plank supporting the roof and a board, and the top of the coal tub he was taking in-bye at the end of his shift in the three quarter seam, Bessie Pit, Blaydon Burn Colliery.

 

[Thanks to Harry Barrett and Margaret Madden for the article]


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Archer, William    Deputy  
Barrett, John   41 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ellis, —    Miner  
Foster, Harold Taylor    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Graham, John    Coroner  
Hurst, —    Miner  
Jeavons, —    Miner  
Lewis, —    Miner  
Ridpath, Thomas Rossiter    Colliery Manager  Whos Who Page
Robson, Mary Ann, Mrs.    Mother-in-law  
Sharp, —    Miner  
Stonehouse, Joseph    Deputy  
Taylor, —    Miner  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Blaydon Burn Colliery  Blaydon Burn Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 22 Dec 2023

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print