4th May 1921
Letters to the Editor
Coal, Iron, And Steel
Sir,
The triangular discussion on coal-miners' wages now or recently going on between the employers, the miners, and the Government proceeds on the assumption that given a settlement trade will be well on the way to recover its lost position. It is important
to remember that it is not the settlement but the nature of the settlement which matters.
The members of the Cleveland iron industry, who produce one-third of the total output of the kingdom, are, with their workmen, vitally affected by the negotiations ; and although they now, as heretofore, decline to discuss the merits of the dispute, wish
to enter a strong protest against the payment of any subsidy to owners or men, as this will only put a tax upon other industries equally or more in need of help and postpone the general revival of trade.
We desire that the following facts should be fully known :— The iron and steel industry is the largest coal and coke consumer in the country, and its continued existence depends upon a cheap and plentiful supply of fuel. At present those normally
employed therein are almost wholly idle. If differences in the coal trade were settled to-morrow there could be no resumption of work at the iron and steel works on the old scale without a very drastic reduction in costs.
The chief cost in making iron and steel is the cast of raw material. Pig iron (considered as raw material in this respect) is the chief item in the cost of making steel. Coal or its coke equivalent is the chief item in the cost of making pig iron. At its
pre-strike price the cost of coal and coke used is equal to nearly three-fourths of the present selling price of Cleveland pig iron. This country cannot consume the production of its iron and steel works, and must export about three-fourths of its make
of pig iron and steel, or that proportion of its plant will remain idle and acute unemployment must follow.
The price is largely governed by the prices at which pig iron and steel can be made and sold on the Continent of Europe and in the United States. Although Cleveland pig iron was selling at 225s. per ton at the end of 1920, its to-day's price is 120s.
Good foreign pig iron is now coming into this country at 100s. per ton, so that, assuming that foreign import prices do not further sag (a large assumption), home prices will probably fall heavily unless we cease to be an exporting country and allow
foreign pig iron and steel to replace British in our home industries. The consumption of coal or its equivalent is approximately 2¼ tons in making one ton of Cleveland pig iron, and (including this in the further process of steel making) nearly four tons
in the finished product. Considerable quantities are also used in producing and transporting the raw material used in the processes.
Direct wages in the iron and steel industry have been adjusted from time to time by the operation of sliding scales and negotiations, with a minimum of difficulty and without disturbance of the relations between employers and employed, and there is every
justification for believing these adjustments will continue to be effected by the same means. When direct wages and those in the limestone and ironstone quarries and mines have been reduced to bed-rock, Cleveland pig iron cannot be manufactured
(excluding all questions of profit) at the price at which foreign pig iron is now being delivered into this country, unless coke of good quality can be delivered to the furnaces at about 27s. per ton. At this figure the coal price must not exceed, say,
14s. per ton at the pit, or probably even less, and then without allowing any profit on coke or on the recovery of by-products.
We must be able to make cheap pig iron and steel if our export trade is to be recovered, and without the export trade the prospect of being able to again find full employment in our ironworks, our limestone quarries, and our ironstone mines is very
remote indeed. Cheap iron and steel are equally necessary to the recovery of the prosperity of the shipbuilding, engineering, foundry, and other industries into whose operations these goods so largely enter.
All industries are tremendously handicapped by the enormous increase in the cost of fuel and transport since 1914. Putting it into percentages, the increase has been about 230 for coke and about 140 for railway dues. These charges must come down or the
coke will not be needed, the railway company will have few minerals to carry, and workmen will have little or no employment. The time seems to have come when a broad outlook should be taken by all sections of employers and employed. Sacrifices will have
to be general if work is to be found and trade done.
It is a duty which the iron and steel manufacturers of the North-East coast think they owe to their workmen in all departments of their industry, and also to the general public, that the facts should be stated and fairly faced, so that the consequences
of a continued deadlock on the wages question in the coal trade and the effect of any settlement which does not bring the price of coal down very drastically may be clearly understood.
Yours truly,
Alfred Hutchinson, President, Cleveland Ironmasters' Association.
Hugh Bell, President, Cleveland Mine Owners' Association.
Middlesbrough, May 2.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Bell, Hugh | | | |
| Hutchinson, Alfred | | | |