|
13th January 1921 The Fatality To Mr. J. W. MackayThe Adjourned InquestAt Bigrigg Reading-room, on Tuesday afternoon, Mr. W. T. Highet, deputy coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, held an inquiry into the death of Jos. Walker Mackey, aged 44, winding engineman, who met with his death as recorded in our last issue. Present at the inquest: Mr. W. Leck, Inspector of Mines; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy on behalf of the relatives; and Mr. J. Hope Brown, representing the United Steel Companies. Mr. Robert Holmes was foreman of the jury. Before the inquest opened Mr. Gavan Duffy asked if it was being held under the Metaliferous Mines Act rather than the Factory and Workshops Act. The engine-house at the mine, he said, where deceased was working at the time of his death was a workshop in reality. It was not under the surface, and should not be classified as part of a mine. He did not regret the presence of the Mining Inspector rather than the Factory Inspector. He did not think they could have a better man than Mr. Leck in going thoroughly and fairly into the inquiry, but it affected some of the questions he had prepared. Mr. Highet stated that it was being held under the Metalliferous Mines Act. John Joseph Ennor, 41, East Road, Egremont, engineman at Parkhouse Mine, Bigrigg, of the United Steel Co., Ltd., stated he was on the previous shift to deceased, being relieved at two o'clock on the Monday by Mr. Mackey. Everything was all right and the engine was running when he left, and he had had no trouble with it. The engine was used for driving a dynamo with which it was connected by a driving belt. There was no difficulty in controlling the engine. He was last at it at 1-15 oiling round, and it was in perfect order then. When deceased was in charge he was under no load, that is, he was using no power for pumping, only for lighting. By Mr. Leck: He had been driving the engine for ten years. The engine was a steam engine, which drove the generator which produced the electricity for lighting and pumping purposes. The engine was running continuously, with the exception of twice in every 24 hours, when it was stopped for oiling. The object of the governor on the engine was to regulate the speed of the engine. The driving belt was about a foot broad and about 50 to 60 feet long, running from the fly-wheel of the engine to the pulley wheel of the generator. The belt had only come off once in his knowledge, and that was some time ago, but it was on the shift of Mr. Jas. Turnbull when it occurred. When the load was suddenly lightened the governors always came into work right away, unless something came into contact with the governor belt and stopped it from going round. The driving belt was broken when he saw it on returning again. He had never detected any flow in it, and had never had occasion to report any defect in the belt or the fly-wheel. He was called back after the accident, an hour after he had left work and had been released by deceased. By Mr. Duffy: When he ceased his duty he left the fly-wheel securely fenced with cast-iron columns and inch piping all round the fly-wheel and at either side of the belt. There was nothing to prevent the belt slipping off. There was a handrail all round the engine 4 ft. 6 in. high. There was nothing to prevent the fly-wheel, if it broke, from scattering all over the place. It was the engineman's duty, apart from taking charge of the engine, to be a handyman in the way of a mechanic. He was not supposed to leave the engine-house under any circumstances. There was an unwritten law that he must not leave the engine-house or no one must come in. But it was customary for them to take charge of the boilers, because there were only "bits of lads" there. It was part of the engineman's duty to go out of the engine-house to examine the electrical part. If the belt came off when he was in the place he could soon stop the engine. The ordinary life of a belt down there would last twenty years with care and attention. He could not account for this belt breaking, and could not see how it could break after slipping off. It did not break last time it slipped off. By Mr. Brown: The governor was not broke to pieces, and the governor valve was burst. The fly-wheel burst into several pieces, and one piece went as far as 300 yards away. The fly-wheel weighed nothing less than three tons. Mr. Kendall Williamson submitted plans of the engine-house, which showed the usual position of the engineman, in a building apart from the electric-house room. He showed the route the engineman would take to the stop-valve if the steam had to be shut off when anything went wrong with the steam supply, but stated that the governor normally conducted the engine itself, and automatically shut off steam if anything went wrong. Albert John Skillicorn, Guard's Villa, Cleator Moor, fireman, employed at Parkhouse Mine, said he commenced work at two o'clock on Monday — the same time as deceased. His duty was looking after the boilers. He was in the engine-house with deceased about 2-10, and everything was all right then. His attention was attracted to the lights going out just as he got to the boiler-room after leaving deceased. He shouted and asked deceased if his circuit-breaker was out, and deceased went into the electric-house to see what was the matter. He came running out and said "The belt's off," and asked what he should do. Deceased was an experienced engineman, and it was part of his duty to know what to do in emergencies, and witness expected him to know what he should do. Witness could not say why he should appeal to him. Witness suggested shutting a valve off. Witness ran for a ladder, the valve being about 7 ft. high some distance away from the electric-house. As he was taking the ladder he heard a report when he got within a yard or two of the place. He next noticed that steam was not off. He later found that the fly-wheel had broken, and the engine-house was full of steam. The engine was racing. Witness went to the valve and shut off the steam. He could not see the engineman anywhere, and he raised the alarm. Deceased was found right at the further end of the boiler-house on the brickwork, quite dead. Witness could not give any explanation as to how the thing had happened. Near the outside valve there was a construction on which one could stand to turn off the steam. This was completely demolished by a piece of the fly-wheel. It was to this place that deceased might have gone to turn off the steam. By Mr. Leck: When witness asked deceased if the circuit-breaker was out the latter went to the electric-house, and was away about a minute. If deceased had not stated that the belt was off witness would have known by the noise of the engine that something was wrong. It was not usual for the engineman to ask the fireman's advice. Mr. Mackey was an exceptionally steady man and a good workman. During the five years he had worked there, no such thing had previously occurred. By Mr. Duffy: It would have been possible for deceased to turn off the steam inside the electric-house by means of the governor. Witness was never inside the electric-house. Deceased did not say the belt was broken, but just that it was off. Witness was 5 ft. 10 in. in height, and he could reach 7 ft. The engine was not racing more than three minutes. He knew Mr. Mackay to be a careful, experienced, and skilled workman. By Mr. Brown: It was quicker for deceased to go into the electric-house to shut off steam rather than to go to the valve outside. Thos. Armstrong, 15, Springfield Road, Bigrigg, blacksmith, said he found the body. He first found the leg on the top of the boiler, and further on found the body. He did not see any metal or anything near. Jas. Turnbull, 122, Main Street, Frizington, engineman, stated that the belt came off about six to nine months ago on his shift. There was a heavy load, the big pump being on at the time. A belt would come off if it was too slack. By Mr. Leck: When the belt came off the engine slowed down, and he went to the throttle valve connected with the governor in the electric-house and shut off the steam. He was in the place at the time, oiling at the end of his shift. The engine did not race on this occasion, the governor doing its work properly of keeping the engine at the regular pace. By the Coroner: If the engine had been racing through the governor failing to act he would not hesitate to go to the throttle valve to shut off steam rather than go to the valve outside. By Mr. Duffy: If Mackay had been on the spot at the time the belt came off he could have shut off steam and averted an accident just as easily as witness had done in his case. Wm. Glenn Hughes, engineer for the United Steel Company, said the belt was a seven ply velatta belt. Each ply was made of canvas, with an easing matter between each ply. The belt was 12 in. wide, and an endless one, with no rivets and no mechanical joint. The belt was issued to the dynamo-house in May, 1914, and would be put on about that time. The average life of such a belt was more than six years. It was easy to detect flaws on the surface of the belt, although there might be hidden weaknesses. They had a new spare belt at the place, and if there was a weakness in the belt being used, it could be immediately changed. The previous belt was on four years, but was a "Gaudy" belt, an American type, and inferior to the one which was on at the time of the accident. By Mr. Duffy: When the belt came off on the previous occasion it was not subjected to any examination before being put back. They had no regular system of changing the belts. By Mr. Leck: The main driving belt was a very heavy belt, and if it came off without breaking it might catch the governor belt, or if the belt broke it might knock off the governor belt or damage the governor in some other way so that the governor would not act. By the Coroner: The fly-wheel was a cast iron wheel, and if the belt was off and the governor out of order the fly-wheel might have been going twice its usual speed, which would tend to cause the run to come from the spokes. The Coroner stated that Mr. Mackay, he understood, was very well-known and respected in that district. It was quite clear he met his death by accident, and that no one was to blame. They could only theorise as to what prevented the governor from working and the engine thus set working. If the deceased had gone to the inside valve instead of to that outside he might have saved time and the accident might have been averted, but deceased might have thought it safer to go to that outside. Mr. J. Hope Brown expressed the regret of the Company that Mr. Mackay had met his death in such a manner. They always regretted the death of any of their workmen, but Mr. Mackay was in a class of very skilled workmen, and was very much respected, and the Company very much regretted the occurrence. Mr. Duffy said the community had lost a valuable citizen, and his Association a worthy member. The widow had lost a husband of a practically incomparable type. He would convey Mr. Brown's kind words to the relatives. The jury's verdict was that Mr. Mackay met his death through being struck whilst at work by a piece from a broken fly-wheel.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||