|
20th May 1920 Fatality At William Pit, WhitehavenAn inquest was held at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland on Friday afternoon by Mr. H. Braithwaite (Deputy Coroner) with reference to the death of Alfred Skelly, coal hewer, Parton, who succumbed that morning to injuries received on Wednesday while working at William Pit, Whitehaven. Mr. R. Wilson was foreman of the jury. There were present: Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. E. H. Evans, on behalf of the relatives; Mr. O. F. Ormrod (Brockbank, Helder and Ormrod), appearing for the Colliery Company; and Mr. R. Steel (agent and works manager). James Dobson Skelly, Drift Yard, Parton, coal-hewer, identified the body as that of his father. They were working together on the same shift in William Pit on Wednesday. They were in the Lowca district of the pit, first going into this particular place on Monday. When they went in on Wednesday they saw the deputy's initials on the timber. A man named Burney was also working there. They did not test the place. During the day witness was working near the face. There were plenty of props in. There had been no shot fired that day or the day previous. The accident happened at 3.55. Witness was only three yards away when the stone fell. They were just about to the top work. His father was stooping down to pick his gear up when the fall took place. The stone struck his father and knocked him on one side. The deputy came in about 3.35 and tested the place with a stick. He could not say whether he touched the part where the stone came away. There was some timbering done that day. Witness had previously noticed nothing wrong. His father had been a full miner for a good many years and worked in the pit since he was a boy. Mr. Johnstone, surveyor for the Colliery Company, produced and explained a plan of the place where the fall occurred. By the Foreman: There were a number of pieces of stone, the largest being perhaps a cwt in weight. At this stage Mr. Evans said he was placed in an unfortunate position as he had not had an opportunity of making the customary examination of the place where the accident happened. Consequently it was very difficult for him to follow the proceedings intelligently. The Coroner: What time did you receive notice of this inquest today? Mr. Evans said he had not up to then actually received official notification. A boy came to his office about a quarter to one and informed him that someone had come from the pit and told his mother that she was to tell him (Mr. Evans) that the man who was injured at the pit had died in the Infirmary that morning. Sergt Clark, in reply to the Coroner, said he did not get to know about the inquest until ten o'clock that morning, and he endeavoured to get a message through to Mr. Evans by telephoning to Haig Pit. There had been very little time owing to the distance to be travelled to notify witnesses, some living at Parton and others at the Arrowthwaite side of Whitehaven. The Coroner said if Mr. Evans desired longer notice he should be only too pleased to arrange accordingly. Mr. Evans said he would waive his objection now if in future steps were taken to let him know in sufficient time to make an inspection. The Coroner: I'll give you longer time in future, certainly. The witness Skelly, in reply to the Inspector, said there was a fault running along the old working where he had previously been engaged. This fault ran through to the new working. There was no timber set underneath the fault. He could not say whether that side of the working was examined or not. By Mr. Ormrod: He was acting as the trailer, and was only in and out of the working. By Mr. Evans: The stone did not fall in the place where they were actually working. James Burney, Low Queen Street, Whitehaven, coal hewer, said he started work at 9.15 on Wednesday morning. Witness tried the roof with a pick, and it appeared all right. Deceased also tried it. The portion where the stone fell was not sounded, because it was about two yards out of the working place. Deceased placed one pick on the top of the fault where the fall occurred. Timber was put in during the shift. There was no warning noise before the fall. Deceased never spoke after being struck. He did not think the deputy examined the place where the fall came from. By the Inspector: Gibson and his son, timbermen, were in until twenty-four to four, and put in two heads of timber. They did not test the roof by the goaf edge, where the fall took place. By Mr. Ormrod: This place was partly timbered up, and they thought it was safe. What he was immediately concerned about was the safety of the place in which they were working. The place referred to had a big side rise and very narrow, and there would be a tendency if a fall took place for the stone to catch deceased. Richard Sim, deputy at William Pit, said he went into the working on Wednesday morning, while the men were in and examined it. He also looked at the loose side. He jowled the place with his stick. He looked at the place where the stone fell. He touched some overhanging stone with his stick. It was all jagged. That was not in the working place. Witness gave instructions to the former as to timbering in the working. Witness returned to the place in the afternoon and examined it again. It appeared to be all right. The place was newly started on Monday. Everything was done to his satisfaction, and he thought everything was all right. By the Inspector: There was fault running through, but he considered the place was sufficiently timbered. He thought everything was as secure as human hands could make it. He still thought so. Asked if he would not put timber in on the loose side now, witness said, "Yes, if it was necessary." He knew there was a rule that the edge of the goaf should be examined, and the place had been examined. By Mr. Ormrod: There was less than eight feet between the timber in this case. Eight feet was mentioned in the rules. Witness did everything possible to make the place safe. By Mr. Evans: He considered the goaf side was secure. After what had happened, however, he would deem it necessary to have props put up in such a place. William Gibson, shift hand, Bank Yard Row, Parton, gave evidence as to putting two sets of wood in the working on Wednesday. He did this work according to the instructions of the deputy (Henry McKee). The place beyond the actual working place, he did not think was safe for anybody to go in, because it was not being worked. Deceased would go near it to pick up some gear. By the Inspector: Witness did not agree that if timber had been put in at the goaf edge it would have protected the face where the men were working. Pressed on the point, witness said long props could be put in. By Mr. Ormrod: Witness simply carried out his instructions. By Mr. Evans: He would have the liberty of making any place secure if he thought it necessary to do so. Dr. Aronson, the house surgeon at the Infirmary, described Skelly's condition when admitted to the institution. He had a fracture of the front portion of the skull, which was completely lacerated. He had a cut over the left eye. There was also a fracture of the right arm. He never regained consciousness, and the cause of death was fracture of the skull. The jury returned a verdict that Skelly died from fracture of the skull occasioned by an accidental fall of stone, and the Foreman added that they agreed with the Inspector that it would have been much better if the goaf had been timbered off. Mr. Ormrod expressed the Colliery Company's great regret at the accident. It seemed to be that always the best of men and the best of workmen were taken in this way, and he was given to understand that Mr. Skelly was certainly one of the best of workmen, as well as the best of fathers and husbands. The Foreman and Mr. Evans joined in the expression of sympathy.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||