1st May 1920
Parliament
Subsidence In Mine Areas
The Plumage Bill
House Of Commons.
Friday, April 30.
The Speaker took the Chair at 12 o'clock.
Compensation For Subsidence.
Mr. Hirst (Wentworth, Lab.), who moved the second reading of the Bill to provide for the payment of compensation for damage to property as the result of subsidence due to underground mining, stated that the measure was identical with the Bill that
was introduced last year by Mr. Brace and read a second time, but failed to get through Committee because it was not founded on a formal financial resolution. In the district from which he came hundreds of acres were under water inconsequence of
subsidence of colliery workings and the land was unfit for cultivation. Many persons had had to be housed in tents until their houses could be rebuilt. Public buildings, such as schools and chapels has also been affected. Those interested in this subject
had from time to time met reasonable owners who were prepared to pay for damage done, but there were many who were not prepared to do so. In his division there were colliery proprietors who welcomed the Bill. Its promoters suggested that it should be
taken up by the Government.
Mr. C. Edwards (Bedwelty, Lab.) reminded the House that when the Bill was under discussion in the House a year ago it was opposed by one member only, the right hon. baronet who represented the City of London. If there were defects in the drafting
of the measure they could be put right in Committee. Miners who applied their small savings to buying their houses frequently had those houses brought about their ears by subsidence. It was also a common thing in mining districts for subsidence to damage
roads and cause leakages in gas and water mains. It was not so much compensation for subsidence as the prevention of subsidence that the promoters of the Bill desired. If the great mountains of rubbish collected at collieries, to the disfigurement of the
mining districts, were used to fill up the workings in the mines, he believed that 90 per cent. of the subsidence would be prevented. But that was not done because it was cheaper to take out this rubbish and tip it than to pay men to pack it into the
workings.
Mr. G. R. Thorne (Wolverhampton, E., L.), who said he lived in a district which suffered considerably from subsidence, urged the Government to give the Bill sympathetic consideration.
The Rejection Moved.
Major Wheler (Faversham, C.U.) moved the rejection of the Bill. He said the Minister of Health, speaking in Committee on last year's Bill, stated that the Bill was based on unsound lines financially, urged its withdrawal, and held out the hope
that the Government would bring in a Bill dealing with the subject themselves. Yet this Bill was in all respects the same as last year's Bill. The Bill imposed a penalty on certain types of people for the action of others for which they were not in the
least responsible. In 99 cases out of 100 there were competent engineers who could show where the responsibility lay. Let the people who were responsible for the subsidence make matters right. The owner of a house which was damaged had a remedy at common
law. This Bill was simply an unfair attack on those who happened to own coal.
Sir F. Banbury (City of London, C.U.) seconded the rejection of the Bill, which, he said, was introduced for the benefit of people who, having obtained a house or a piece of land below its market value, wanted to get something to which they were
not entitled out of the pockets of people who were not responsible for the subsidence. The evils of subsidence were not confined to colliery districts. The first result of this Boll would be to raise the price of coal. The body to be set up under the
Bill could levy any rate they liked, and they knew how extravagant public bodies were. Colonel P. Williams (Middlesbrough, C.L.) supported the second reading, if only for the purpose of forcing the Government to bring forward their own measure for
dealing with a very serious and pressing grievance of people who owned property within mining areas. Mr. Kidd (Linlithgow, C.U.) also defended the principle of the Bill, and said he believed it would be welcomed by the vast majority of landowners
in Scotland. Brigadier-General Hickman (Bilston, C.U.) objected to the Bill because it would lead to wasteful working of the mines and to a great disturbance of the surface in mining areas. It would increase the difficulties of the Ministry of
Health in securing an adequate number of houses, and it made no provision for the representation of coalowners or royalty owners upon the proposed district boards. Mr. J. Guest (Yorks, Hemswortth, Lab.) urged that, as existing contracts had been
put forward as a barrier to the operation of the Bill, and new contracts were being made every month, the measure ought to be passed without delay. Brigadier-General Surtees (Gateshead, C.U.), while sympathizing with occupiers of houses and other
property who could not obtain redress for damage by subsidence, urged that this was a bad Bill and was grossly unfair. Major Morgan (Rhondda, E., Lab.) emphasized the importance of dealing with the question of subsidence in South Wales, where
hundreds of men in the Rhondda Valley were living in houses that were condemned 13 or 14 years ago. The Pontypridd authorities were losing by the breakages of pipes millions of feet of gas every year ; nearly one-third of the amount made had been wasted.
In Rhondda much of what was made was also being lost. One of the chief difficulties in Rhondda was the difficulty of acquiring land for houses. Sometimes the people whose houses had been ruined were compelled to go 15 miles further out.
Sir J. Harmood Banner (Everton, C.U.), who was in sympathy with much that had been said by the supporters of the measure, could not assent to the proposal that contracts and undertakings should be broken. Ho told the House how on one occasion,
being in a colliery district, he was very much alarmed on waking in the morning to find furniture and other articles scattered over the floor. He was not long in dressing that morning. He hoped the Government would devise some means of meeting the
requirements of the miners, but he could not subscribe to the doctrine that where damage had been done through subsidence in one district, some one whose business was far distant ought to pay. While it was right that something should be done, it should
be wider in character. They ought not to penalize this man or that man. Mr. R. McLaren (Lanark, N., C.U.) said it did not matter how far down or near the surface the seam of coal that was being worked might be, there would always be a certain
amount of subsidence. It would be impossible to prevent it by stowing the waste in the workings, as had been suggested. The only sure safeguard against subsidence was to stop mining operations, and that was a cure which could not be applied. In his view,
the Government should bring in a short Bill simply providing that the mineral proprietors or the coalowners should pay compensation directly, and on the spot, where damage was done. Mr. Myers (Spen Valley, Lab.) said public authorities in mining
districts were greatly limited in their choice of sites for the building of houses by the danger of subsidence.
Attitude Of The Government.
Sir R. Horne, President of the Board of Trade (Glasgow, Hillhead, C.U.), said he did not propose to take up an attitude of opposition to the Bill. At the same time, its provisions were of such a character that he could not give it any support. He
dared say he would be responsible for the proposal of some other legislation on this matter, and the discussion had been of the greatest benefit to him in clearing up his mind on various points. He happened personally to know something about colliery
districts and the results of subsidence. It was possible in many cases to conduct the working in such a way that even when carried on in the closest proximity to building property, the subsidence took a regular form which did property no harm. The Bill
only touched one part of the problem. It did nothing to regulate the working of coal so that property should not be let down. It merely provided that when property was let down there should be certain compensation. Indeed, the Bill was a direct incentive
to people to let down property. The coalowner would feel that there was no longer any necessity upon him to keep coal unworked under such or such a village, because compensation for damage would be provided from a fund into which he was obliged to pay.
The Bill proposed district boards, who were to collect funds for compensation in their area. The problem, however, could not be worked out by districts. A Committee which had reported on the matter recently expressed the view that the whole question
ought to be dealt with by a national arrangement under which a definite authority would lay down principles as to the working of coal in certain areas and set up regulations providing that determinations should be arrived at whether it was more in the
public interest in particular areas to work out the coal or preserve the houses. He was endeavouring to approach the whole problem with a desire to find a solution which would meet all the difficulties of the problem.
Mr. Renwick (Newcastle, Central, C.U.) expressed the view that the Government ought to have opposed the Bill, and if it was necessary they should bring in a Bill of their own. The Bill raised enormous issues, which could not, and ought not, to be
dealt with in a private member's measure. Mr. S. Walsh (Ince, Lab.) also complained of the attitude taken up by the Government. (Cheers.) This was a very pressing and urgent question in mining districts, and one which was imposing unfair burdens
on tens of thousands of people. Public authorities were also being called upon to bear burdens in connexion with it which were unfair in their incidence. These were conditions which ought to receive the attention of the Government, and yet they were to
be flouted once again. Major Morrison-Bell (Honiton, C.U.) asked the promoters of the Bill whether they would be willing to allow any particular mine to contract out. As it was, the Bill lumped together all mines, whether they were badly managed
or well managed. This would put a premium on bad management. The two great blots on the Bill were that it penalized a well-managed mine for damage done by a badly managed one, perhaps 10 or 15 miles away, and that it proposed to break contracts.
After some remarks from Lieutenant-Commander C. Williams (Tavistock, C.U.) and Colonel R. Burdon (Durham, Sedgefield, C.U.), who complained that the Government had acted exceedingly badly in view of their pledges in the matter.
Mr. Bridgeman, Parliamentary Secretary, Board of Trade (Oswestry, C.U.), replying to a complaint that the Government did not take a serious view of the hardships and difficulties caused by the lack of administrative powers, said that the
Government were fully alive to the necessity of settling the question to which the Bill referred, and hoped to settle it by a measure, to be introduced as soon as Parliamentary time was available. He agreed that the matter was urgent, and must be faced.
The Prime Minister had promised a Bill to deal with the whole of the machinery of the mining industry, and had foreshadowed the contents of that measure. If administrative machinery were set up, it would be for a Ministry of Mines, or whatever authority
might be set up, to use that machinery. Those who desired to govern should produce a better Bill than that now before the House. To give a second reading to such a measure, which was fundamentally faulty in more than one respect, would not advance a
decision on the points with which the Government intended to deal.
Captain Bowyer (Buckingham, C.L.) complained that hon. members who had no special knowledge of the mining industry were placed in a very difficult position through the failure of the Government to indicate their policy. He felt that the promoters
of the Bill had made out a case for it, and he intended to vote for the second reading.
On a division, the motion for the second reading was defeated by 89 votes against 63.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Banbury, F., Sir | | | |
| Banner, J. Harmood, Sir | | | |
| Bowyer, —, Captain | | | |
| Brace, — | | | |
| Bridgeman, — | | | |
| Burdon, R., Colonel | | | |
| Edwards, C. | | | |
| Guest, J. | | | |
| Hickman, —, Brigadier-General | | | |
| Hirst, — | | | |
| Horne, R., Sir | | | |
| Kidd, — | | | |
| Major, — | | | |
| McLaren, R. | | | |
| Morrison-Bell, —, Major | | | |
| Myers, — | | | |
| Renwick, — | | | |
| Surtees, —, Brigadier-General | | | |
| Thorne, G. R. | | | |
| Walsh, S. | | | |
| Wheler, —, Major | | | |
| Williams, C., Lieutenant-Colonel | | | |
| Williams, P., Colonel | | | |