|
19th February 1920 Millom Mine InquestAs reported in our last issue another sad fatality occurred on Tuesday week at the Hodbarrow Mines, Millom. An inquest was held on the body of Mr. John Morgan Riley, of Kingsland Cottage, Millom, an experienced miner of exemplary character, who had been 34 years in the employ of the local Company. He was 50 years of age, and had worked at Hodbarrow Mines since he was 16. The inquest was held at the Hodbarrow Hospital, on Thursday, before Mr. W. T. Lawrence (coroner) and the following jury :– Messrs. H. Deacon (foreman), J. Cocks, L. Park, T. Mandall, H. Wall, and J. Atkinson. There were also present :— Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Metalliferous Mines; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, miners' secretary; and, representing the Company, Mr. S. P. Wilson and Capt. Coade. The Coroner, in opening, referred to the frequency of these inquests, and pointed out that it was the duty of the jury to ascertain if all proper precautions had been taken to secure safety. John Towers, Barrow-in-Furness, stepson of the deceased, identified the body as that of John Morgan Riley, who was an iron ore miner, employed at the Hodbarrow Mines, Millom, and residing at 80, Main-street, Holborn Hill. Deceased left a widow, two daughters, one son, and four step-children. He was 50 years of age. James Wilson Richardson, miner, 64, Main-street, Holborn Hill, employed at Hodbarrow Mines, Millom, had worked one week and two days with deceased up to the time of the accident. He had previously worked with deceased, who was an experienced miner. Witness knew deceased had been a miner at least for more than 15 years. On Tuesday, the 10th inst., he and Timothy Long were working with deceased close to No. 5 rope road. They were shooting down metal. About 5-15 o'clock there was a fall. Previous to that they had been shooting down the metal, and they covered over all. When they had just put the last spile in the roof broke away and about a ton of stone fell. The stone fell upon deceased, knocked him down, and partially buried John Riley. The lights were extinguished by the fall. Witness was about two yards away. He and Long were untouched by the fall. Witness got a light and shouted. Deceased, whose head was partly covered, answered, "I'm here, Wilce." Further help was procured, and Riley was extricated. Witness was standing back when Riley was extricated — dead. Three ambulance men were in attendance, and artificial respiration was applied, but without effect. By Mr. Leck: About 15 to 20 minutes would be taken to extricate deceased. The fall extinguished all their lights. Samuel Langhorn, timberman, had visited the place when the last shot was fired, and stayed five minutes. Langhorn instructed Long to take down a piece of metal. This was done. They told Langhorn they were going to put in a pole 10 ft. x 6 in. Just as they got the pole in the break came. Deceased was held in a crouching position by the fall. When they were nearing the end of a stump, he agreed with Inspector Leck that that was where the greatest danger arose. There was a visit to each working by either a Captain or a timberman every shift. The same man did not usually visit them on two succeeding days. Witness was satisfied that they were taking every precaution. The place looked safe enough, and they thought it was all right. By the Coroner: The place seemed no more dangerous than any other of the miners' usual work. The place of the working was produced. Mr. Duffy: Is this a cartoon and a plan? Explaining his meaning, Mr. Duffy continued: Really I think it's a very unfair thing for this to be put in like this. Witness had been examined on a plan which had not been proved. Really, this plan goes to the Home Office, and is a guidance to the Home Office as to the accident, and I think we should know whether it has been drawn by an expert, or someone who has been playing with coloured ink. Having ascertained that the plan had been drawn by a surveyor in the employ of the Company and that he was in the offices adjacent, the Coroner said they would have the plan proved. In the meantime Mr. Duffy questioned witness as to the extent of a vacant place about the scene of the accident. Witness thought the space would be about a foot. Mr. Duffy asked if it was usual to pack a place like that. Witness said that it was usual. Mr. Duffy: Why was the usual custom not observed? — Witness: We were going to pack it from the other side. Alfred Alexander Jones, mine surveyor, in the employ of the Hodbarrow Mines, was acquainted with the plan. He drew the plan to scale; it was correct (of the scene of the accident) that is the essential details were accurate, but he could not speak to portions which he had not seen, but which he had drawn to help the understanding of the situation. Timothy Long, iron ore miner at Hodbarrow, was working with deceased at the time of the accident. On the morning "set" their mates had put in a pole to "catch the top up." Witness prepared a hole for another pole. Wilson and Riley were filling ore. They then fired a shot and went outside while the shot was being fired, and while there Samuel Langhorn, timberman, came in. He stayed perhaps ten minutes and made careful inspection. He told Long to be careful of a lump. Langhorn approved of their manner of working. A ten foot pole was obtained, fixed and covered in. While they were putting in the last spile, something came on to their wood, a fall of stone, he thought. The fall put out their lights. He got another light and they found that Riley had been knocked down and partly covered. There seemed to be a piece of stone on his neck and one on his back. Witness was present while deceased was extricated, witness helping. He appeared to be dead. Artificial respiration was applied for about 40 minutes. Witness had been seven or eight years a practical miner. He did not think the place dangerous. By Mr. Leck: Deceased was the oldest of the three, and witness had great confidence in him. Witness was not struck at all by the fall. About a ton of material came away in the fall. Deceased seemed to be held by a spile on his neck (a board about 5ft. long by 2in. thick). Witness thought two or three heights had gone out above them. There was from about 1ft. to 18in. space above them. It was usual to pack this up. They had not packed it on this occasion, and Riley did not suggest that it be then packed. A member of their company habitually brought their wood for them. The span between two headtrees across this working would be about 8ft. 3in. By Mr. Duffy: There were 13 men in that company. The oldest man would be deceased, about 50 years of age. Witness was not positive that deceased was the oldest one. They returned to their working in about ten minutes after the shot had been fired. Langhorn came and made a careful inspection. The height of the working was about 10ft. There was from 12 to 18 inches above. It was usual to pack this. Riley was covering in, and he could have had anything he required. Both poles were down, but he did not know whether they were broken or not. Samuel Langhorn, timberman overseer, had been 22 years in the employ of the Hodbarrow Company and about 16 years a timberman. On Tuesday he inspected the place of the accident, about 4-30 on the Tuesday afternoon. The three men working were going to put a piece of timber in position. Witness then thought the place was perfectly safe. He observed a piece of ore and warned them not to let it fall on them. They said they would. Witness would be perhaps ten minutes in the place, and made a careful examination. He had made an examination on the previous day. He could hardly believe that a fall had occurred there. Witness had no fault to find. By Mr. Leck: Their chief duty was to go round to examine. They had authority to stop a place if they thought it unsafe to work in. He took a certain district for a number of days. This was the custom. They did not change districts daily. The three miners at the place of the accident were all fine men. By Mr. Duffy: He didn't know if any of the miners went out of the working for timber. They were expected to keep their working good, but he did not know how far out of their working they were expected to keep the road good. He thought it was a piece of stone off the old boundary wall which had fallen and killed the man. Mr. Duffy agreed. After the Coroner had briefly summed matters up, the jury without retiring returned a verdict of "Accidental death." Sympathy was expressed with the bereaved relatives.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||