|
12th February 1920 Tubs Run A-MainBogie Hands Fail To Carry Out Their InstructionsAnother inquest followed with respect to the death of Thomas Edgar (33), of Main-street, Sandwith, who was injured through being knocked down by a tub in Ladysmith Pit on January 19th, and died in Whitehaven Infirmary on Thursday evening. Mary Adelaide Edgar, widow, said the day after the accident she asked her husband if it was any fault of his. He said "No," and that there was no tail rope or burr in the wheels, and the tubs ran a-main. He had not time to get out of the way, and the tubs ran off the road. He also said there were some bad tubs on the siding. By the Inspector: She thought by bad tubs her husband meant that he had not any room to run. Dr. Aronshon stated that when Edgar was admitted to the infirmary he was suffering from fracture of the skull, ruptured ear drum, lacerated face, three fractured ribs, paralysis of right arm, and other injuries. An abscess developed in the buttock and it was decided to perform an operation on Thursday, as that was Edgar's only change of recovery. Unfortunately, while the anaesthetic was being applied the heart stopped. Witness gave him the minutest dose it was possible to give. He used ether, which was considered the safest thing. The cause of death was shock and heart failure, following the injuries. Edward McWilliams, Howgill-street, coal hewer, said fifteen tubs came down just before the accident, and witness and others had warning that nine others were coming down. Edgar, was in a position to hear the warning, which was given by a boy. After the nine tubs came down witness saw Edgar in a sitting position. One tub had been knocked off the way, and witness thought it had caught him. This tub had jumped off the metals. There was a tail rope behind the tubs. Witness and others attended to deceased. By the Inspector: They were surprised that Edgar was where he was. There were no old tubs lying about which would prevent him from getting out of the way. By the Coroner: Witness thought Edgar must have stumbled. By Mr. Evans: It was the first of the fifteen that hit him. John Bates, North Row, Kells, bogie hand, said his fellow worker was letting the tubs over the hitch, and had got most part of the lockings in when the tubs went too fast, and his mate shouted that they were gone. The lockings were in the tub wheels. By the Inspector: He could not attach the tail rope before the tubs were locked. Witness said a burr had been put in since the accident. This would prevent tubs running away into the siding. Mr. Evans pointed out that if the rope and tubs were manipulated as they should be, there should not be any danger or any need for giving warning to the men. Thomas Bethwaite, bogie hand, said he warned the men at the bottom about the second lot of tubs. Witness corroborated the evidence of Bates as to the tubs getting away before all the lockings were in. He tried to put lockings in after the tubs got in motion, but they broke. John Batty, under-manager, explained the methods of dealing with the empty setts. Bethwaite had evidently been too eager to let his sett down. He had taken too many lockings out, and the sett had got over the brow top. The Coroner: Have these young men special instructions from you to attach the tail rope to these setts before starting them? — Witness: The overman gives these instructions, and it is for their own benefit, and easier work for them. By the Inspector: If the tail rope was property attached it did not matter whether there were any lockings in the tubs or not, as they could not then get away, and would come down the brow quite steadily. The Coroner said that, according to the evidence of Mr. Batty, these boys had evidently been letting the tubs down before putting the tail rope on. It was for the jury to say whether they considered there had been negligence, but evidently the boys had not carried out the instructions given to them. The jury returned a verdict in accordance with the medical evidence and added that they thought the boys were to blame for not carrying out their duties according to instructions and ought to be cautioned. Mr. Steel said they would give them definite instructions, and bring it home to them. The Coroner, at the wish of the jury, cautioned the two boys as to carrying out instructions property in future. The Foreman intimated that the jury wished to express their sympathy with Mrs. Edgar. Mr. Helder said he endorsed what the Foreman said. These accidents were very sad, and it seemed to have been particularly so in this case. As the Coroner said, it would appear that if due care had been exercised the accident might have been avoided.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||