Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

18th September 1919

Fatal Fall At Sir John Walsh Pit, Bigrigg

An inquest at the Whitehaven Infirmary was held by Mr. Atter on Tuesday, on the death of Joseph Sparks, 63, iron ore miner, 17, Trumpet Terrace, Cleator, who was employed in Sir John Walsh Pit, Bigrigg, the property of the Workington Iron and Steel Co., and there came by injuries which shortly afterwards resulted in his death.

He was at work in the pit at 8.20 on Saturday morning, along with others, when there was a large fall of stone and metal from the roof. He was severely crushed about the lower part of the body, and another man, Davy, was also injured. Everything possible was done for the injured man until the arrival of Dr. Reid, of Cleator, about nine, o'clock. The doctor ordered the removal of Sparks to the Infirmary. This was done, but the unfortunate man died from his injuries about four o'clock on Sunday morning. Davy's injuries were attended to, and he was removed home.

Mr. J. Hope Brown was present on behalf of the Company; Mr. Gavan Duffy for the relatives; and Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector.

Jos. S. Sparks, bricklayer, son of the deceased, said his father had worked at the Sir John Walsh pit for a number of years. He was in his usual good health on the day of the accident. Witness heard him say it was rather a dangerous place he was working in then — that was about three weeks ago, — but he had worked in worse. Witness saw his father before he died, at the Infirmary. He was conscious. He said it was their (the men's) own fault.

The Foreman (Councillor R. Wilson) complimented the witness on the straight-forward way in which he had given evidence.

Wm. Sherwen, draughtsman, produced a plan of the place where the fall occurred. When he made his inspection on the following Monday there had been a bigger fall.

George H. Barbour, Cleator Gate, Cleator, iron ore miner at Sir John Walsh pit, said he had known the deceased for a long time as a careful miner. He was working with deceased at the time of the accident. They began work a little after six and all went right till about eight o'clock. Mr. Ratcliffe, an official, came and stopped two men above and told them to get their gear out. Ratcliff thought witness and his companions were safe enough where they were, and they thought so, too, having themselves examined the place before, about three-quarters of an hour after the fall took place. A piece of it caught witness's foot. Deceased was about two yards from him. Witness jumped in the opposite way to Davy and Clark. Witness pulled both of them out. They were both lying together; there was not much of a fall on them — perhaps about 2 cwts. There was another fall after they got deceased and Davy out. No one was hurt by the second fall. Mr. Ratcliff came, and it was about a quarter of an hour before they got the men up.

By Mr. Leck: An inspector comes in every, working shift. Witness, deceased, and Davy all said that they thought they were safe. The fall struck the slope and bounced on to them.

By Mr. Duffy: Witness had been working there for about two months. He could not say that the working had ever been closed. Up above they had been working for two days; but witness and his companions thought they were safe from anything that might come from there.

Daniel Ford, 38, Crossfield Road, Cleator Moor, iron ore miner at the Sir John Walsh pit, said he was working above deceased. Williams and witness examined the working place about half-past six and they had a ladder to do it with a stick about 10ft. long with a spike on it. They thoroughly examined it. They found one place not the same as previous day. Ratcliff, the official, came up and they drew his attention to this, and he told them they had better take their gear out. They thought that deceased, working below was perfectly safe: witness had worked at the place below two days previously. Witness himself would not have hesitated to work there. Witness went after the fall, and both the deceased and Davy were free when he got there.

By Mr. Leck: Spark had worked there for almost forty years and was a capable miner. Witness and his companions had just got their gear out when the fall took place, and they were still above.

By Mr. Duffy: He had worked in or about this same working for about four years. The place might have been moving or working for three or four days before the fall. They had not the ground prepared for more props. They used a carbide lamp because the place was higher than usual, and to give them a better light, so that they could make a better examination.

By Mr. Brown: They had all the timber they would have required if they had wished to use it.

Joseph Williams, Scalegill Place, Moor Row, said he had worked at this pit for twelve years and knew the deceased. Witness was working with the last witness, and gave similar evidence.

By Mr. Leck: The examination they made on Saturday morning suggested to them that there was likely to be a fall, and that it was not safe and the deputy agreed with them; but they thought the men below would be safe.

By Mr. Leck: Witness's working place had been "working" for three or four days. They could not get in any more props, because the ground was not prepared for them.

Edward Ratcliffe, Moor Row, said he was overman at the pit, and knew deceased for an experienced, careful workman. Witness ordered Ford and Williams out for their safety. Witness went down to the low level where deceased, Davey, and Barbour were and warned them of the condition above and that they had to be very careful, and if any pieces came away they were to get round the corner. The roof over them was good, and anything that fell above was at right angles to where they were working and would have to roll down a slope. The fall that caused the accident was just one piece, which had broken up. It was from the roof above settling down. Witness thought it was settling down bodily and that there would not be likely to be separate falls. Witness did not blame the men at all, who were doing what he told them.

By Mr. Leck: They expected the roof to come down, and then they would start afresh and work through again. He knew there would be danger of metal rebounding, but they could hear it coming, and he thought they could have got safely round the corner. A roof would "work" perhaps for some weeks before it would come down. — By Mr. Duffy: The roof had not always been unsafe, or they would not have men working there. — There was a crack in the roof that they were watching, and they saw that it had opened out from Monday to Saturday. If the men below had got round the corner they would be quite safe. They had warning by hearing the fall roll down the slope. — By Mr. Brown: Witness had no report from the night deputy that the roof was unsafe, but was warned by him to examine it carefully as the last shift had reported that the roof had been working. — By Mr. Wandless (a juryman): The distance along the slope was about 30 feet. Witness relied on the chance of the men being able to get round the corner. There was no other reason why he did not bring the men out on the lower level also, than that he thought there, was no direct danger and that they would have plenty of time to get out of the way of falls that might roll down the slope.

John Hutchinson, miner, gave evidence as to the examination of the high level place on the night before the accident. He said he found the roof a little uneasy and left a note to this effect for the men coming in next shift. Joe Rooney, a deputy, was there. They did not report to any official. — The Coroner asked why not? It appeared to him to be a serious matter. — Witness said that they did not think it was very serious, because the roof had settled again before they came away.

The Coroner said that in his opinion it was the undoubted duty of the man to have reported the matter to some official.

Witness examined by Mr. Leck, said he would have thought it was quite safe for him if he had been working at the same place as deceased. The deputy always told them to come out and leave the place if they thought it was not safe.

The Coroner: How are you paid by time or by output? — Witness: We are paid on output.

By Mr. Duffy: Where as in iron ore mines, there are no special rules, the men consider that the responsibility is on themselves, and they leave a note for the next shift. Witness followed that custom in this case.

Witness Ford, recalled, said he got the note that Hutchinson left. It was their custom, when they thought there was danger, to draw the attention of an official to it as soon as they could.

By Mr. Leck: They left a note to make sure, in case they should not see a deputy.

By Mr. Brown: Leaving a note is not done in place of reporting, but in addition to reporting.

Isaac Walker, manager, said there was a general intimation to the workmen that they were to report anything abnormal. There was no special rule. Leaving a note alone would not be safe. The deputy, by writing on a slate fixed in every working, gave information to the men who were coming in.

By Mr. Leck: It was a good safe rule that the men should leave a note for the incoming men; but they should report to an official as well. — By Mr. Brown: There is one deputy on each shift; and at the change of shift there are two to whom reports could be made. But whether or not in this case the men did what they ought to do, the information reached the deputy.

The Coroner remarked on the fair way in which the evident, had been given. The least, he thought, that should be done was that some official should be informed when there was anything wrong, and that it should not be confined to the leaving of a note which might not be found. If the jury thought the men in the lower level should have been taken out as well as those above, that was only an error of judgment on the part of Mr. Ratcliffe.

While the jury retired considering their verdict, a question of the expenses of workmen witnesses cropped up. The Coroner said his list of fees was limited by the County Council. He could not allow more than 7s.

Mr. Gavan Duffy pointed out that the men would lose on that.

The Coroner thought the men ought not to lose, but he could not help it.

Mr. D. Gill (for the Company) said that he was under the impression that the men were paid, but he would look into it.

The jury returned a verdict that the deceased died in consequence of injuries received by a fall of metal. They recommended that in future each company of men on leaving a working should sign on the slate "Good" or "Bad" as the condition of the place might be.

Mr. Brown said the Company would have no objection to adopt that. But to all intents and purposes that is so now. The slate is there for the use of deputies or men. But now you ask the men to put on the slate in writing, "Good" or "Bad." Mr. Brown then expressed the regret of the Company at this sad death of an efficient workman who had been so long at this pit.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Barbour, George H.    Miner  
Brown, J. Hope    Solcitor  
Clark, —    Miner  
Davy, —    Miner  
Ford, Daniel    Miner  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Gill, D.      
Hutchinson, John    Miner  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Ratcliffe, Edward    Overman  
Reid, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Rooney, Joe    Deputy  
Sherwen, William    Draughtsman  
Sparks, Joseph   63 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Sparks, Joseph S.    Bricklayer  
Walker, Isaac    Manager  Whos Who Page
Williams, Joseph    Miner  
Wilson, R., Councillor    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Sir John Walsh (Iron Ore)  Sir John Walsh (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print