|
11th September 1919 The Hodbarrow Mine FatalityThe inquest on the bodies of Richard George Fallows, John Thomas Fallows, and Samuel George Boulton Crisp, the three men who were killed at Hodbarrow Mines, Millom, on Friday last, was resumed yesterday (Wednesday) at the Magistrates' Court House, Millom, before the Coroner (Mr. W. T. Lawrence) and the following jury :— Messrs A. Ripley (foreman), J. Cox, J. Barratt, S. Lamb, W. Doidge, W. Allen, W. Stephens, J. Sherward. Also present were Mr. W. Leck, H.M Inspector of Mines, and Mr. Gavan-Duffy, Miner's Secretary. Captain J. H. Towers, for 21 years underground captain at Hodbarrow, knew the place where the deceased were working. He last visited the place at 7.45 on the morning of the accident. He examined their working place carefully. They were extracting a vein of ore 6 feet wide. It was an old working which, previous to the last three weeks, had not been worked for eight years. He did not know whether the place had been inspected by any authority previous to the working being resumed, and did not know whether any precautions had been taken to render the place safe. The work was stopped eight years ago because of the inferior quality of the ore. When he inspected the place on the morning of the accident the three men were present, and the place appeared safe. He noticed the hanging wall. He spoke about it, the immediate place where they were working, and the men treated the matter lightly. By Mr. Leck: Captain Coade started the places. Part of the wall which was sounded came away. Two of the men sounded the place separately. There was no suggestion that the wall should be sounded further back. The timbering appeared sound. The ore was wedged between the walls, and when the ore was extracted the hanging wall would be expected to cave in, and he gave instructions accordingly. The roadmen were sent to put the roads into this place probably three weeks before the men went to work there. George Fallows was always very careful as regards timber. From what he had since noticed he assumed that they had been sounding the walls after the second round of holes, and the place had caved in. Knowing George Fallows well, he was certain that he would do everything that could be done as regards making the place safe. Three practical miners would not go into a dangerous place together to investigate. By Mr. Duffy: The place he inspected was apparently a "dry working." By the Coroner: The weight of the fall would be approximately between 22 and 25 tons. Mr. Sampson Mitchell, 17 years a miner at Hodbarrow, worked in the same place as deceased, but on a different shift. He was working there on Thursday afternoon, before the accident. It appeared quite safe when he left about 9.30 p.m. Captain Bosanko visited the place on Thursday afternoon, being followed later by Captain Towers. He (witness) sounded the place, and he did not think an accident would occur. There were four headtrees and they appeared good. The height of the working would be about 22 or 23 feet. There was a bit of a hanging wall. Explaining, on being asked, what he meant by "a bit of a hanging wall," witness said there was a good portion of a wall hanging. Captain Samuel Coade, mine captain at Hodbarrow, knew the working perfectly where the men met with the accident. It had not been worked for about eight years previous. In his opinion, before that it was perfectly safe. It was a dry place and he himself visited it about once a week. It was a small place. No special examination was required after the period of disuse, "not in 20 years." By Mr. Leck: In his judgement the accident was due to their taking out the iron which was wedged between the walls. He did not previously know that the wall was of a jointy character. After seven or eight years disuse they would examine and re-wood a place of any size, but this was a very small place, and it was not necessary in this case. Neither himself nor anyone else suggested any extra timber. By Mr. Duffy: The place was so small I did not think new timber necessary. The Coroner, in summing up, said that he thought they had all the material evidence that was necessary. Other witnesses were at hand if required. We could be wise after the event and to his mind it was a pure accident which could not be foreseen. A verdict of "Accidental death" was returned. Captain Coade, on behalf of the Company, expressed sympathy for the relatives and friends of the deceased. The Coroner hoped that such an accident would never occur again.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||