Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

15th May 1919

Workmen's Compensation Case

Millom County Court.

Several Hours Sitting.

Thursday, May 8th.

(Before His Honour Judge Gawan Taylor.)

Hannah Casson, widow of James Casson, applied for compensation in respect of her husband, who met with a fatal accident at the Hodbarrow Mines, on December 2nd, 1918. Applicant was represented by Capt. Wood (of Wood and Lord, Manchester), and the respondents by Mr. W. Garencieres Pearson (instructed by the Solicitors to the Treasury).

His Honour decided that £200 be paid out to the widow, the remaining £100 to be invested in 5 per cent. War Bonds.

Capt. Wood applied for costs on the ground that there had been unreasonable delay between the date of accident, 2nd December, 1918, and the time the money was paid into Court, 16th April, 1919.

The Judge, however would not allow costs.

Another Hodbarrow Case.

Several hours were occupied in the hearing of this case. Harriet Dockeray, 8, Egremont Street, Millom, applied for compensation in respect of her late husband, Robt. Dockeray, who died after an accident which occurred while employed at the Hodbarrow Mines, Millom.

Mr. J. H. Thorpe (instructed by Messrs. Wood and Lord) appeared for the applicant, and Mr. M. Barnett (instructed by the Solicitors to the Treasury) for the respondents.

Mr. Thorpe said Dockeray was 60 years of age, and a particularly strong and healthy man. After the accident in July he declined. He returned to work in September, and in December he dropped dead at work.

Harriet Dockeray, widow of deceased, said her husband had been employed 40 years at Hodbarrow, and was very healthy during that period. He was a good built man, with fresh fair complexion; and slept well before the accident. He never complained of any pains before that time. After the accident he came home in a trap, his head and foot being bandaged. He was then home on compensation pay, about 12 weeks. During that time he always seemed nervous, being attended by Dr. Pratt, and was about two weeks confined to bed, after which he laid on a couch until about a week before re-commencing work on October 7th. He was not the same man after the accident. He was a temperate man. After the accident, he said many times that he was finished, and after returning to work seemed to be very nervous about going back to work at the place, which he thought very dangerous. He had no such fear or nervousness before July. After the accident, when he returned from his daily work he seemed "done up." Before the accident he slept well, but afterwards he was very restless, and had had horrible dreams, shouting in his sleep. He had other changed symptoms also. He was by nature a very cheerful, jovial man, but after July he seemed to become more dull.

By Mr. Barnett: He remained in bed by reason largely of his injured ankle. The injury above the eye healed nicely. It had four stitches. She did not understand why his average earnings before the injury were £4 5s 10d weekly and after the accident £5 0s 1d per week, and £6 16s 6d per week the last two weeks before his death. Probably his mates helped him. After being injured, he complained of pain in his head and in his side. She advised him to consult a doctor, but he did not go as his own medical man was away. He passed a lot of blood the day before his death. On Tuesday morning, the day of his death, he was very dull.

By Mr. Thorpe: She did not know the system of sharing wages. The pain in the side was recurrent. Her husband did not like going on the club. His energy had all left him after the accident.

Mr. Robinson Tyson, iron ore miner, residing at 54 Newton Street, said he was working on July 9th, 1918, next to Robert Dockeray when there was a fall which knocked Dockeray down and caused a nasty cut about the eye. Deceased was dazed. His wound was dressed, and he was taken to the shaft. He was generally a strong, healthy, and cheerful man. When he returned to work in October he was not physically the same, and was more nervous. As regards the higher wages received by Dockeray just before he died, they helped him out, which was not necessary before the accident, as Dockeray could then earn his own. There were nine in their shift. If there were several away they could not help them to the same extent.

Mr. Wm. Riley, miner, Haverigg, said he was an ambulance man and rendered first aid to Dockeray. The man was dazed, trembling, and wounded about the eye. Nothing was said about the leg wounds. Dockeray was usually in good health. He supposed the wound would be to the bone.

Mr. Wm. Myers, 89, Market Street, miner, after the accident saw Dockeray lying, and picked him up stunned and dazed. Before the accident Dockeray was a strong, healthy, cheerful man.

John Hill, 49, Mainsgate, was in the "dry" the day Dockeray died. He (witness) gave him some instructions regarding some wood. Dockeray said, "All right," and went to hang up his hat. The hat hooks were about six feet high, and Dockeray put his foot on a step to hang up his hat, and as he raised his arm he fell. He was lifted and stretched on the locker, and he died without speaking.

By Mr. Barnett: He gave evidence at the inquest, and was not asked then about Dockeray reaching his cap. He first heard about this when he was subpoenaed.

Mr. E. Jenkins, miner, 4, Main St., Haverigg, stated he was the deceased's brother-in-law. Deceased, prior to the accident, was a model of a man to look at. After the accident he went a sallow complexion and seemed to go melancholy, also stating that he could not do the work he did before, and complained of pains.

Thomas Wall, 31, Devonshire Road, had known the deceased about 20 years as a strong, healthy man. After the accident he appeared very worried about his work. He was not the same man, and was not in the same spirits.

Agnes Ann Wall, married daughter of deceased, said her father was naturally a very "jokey" man. After the accident he was very quiet and laid on the sofa a great deal.

By Mr. Barnett: Her father's ankle would cause him to lay on the sofa. She gave evidence at the inquest to the effect that on the Sunday before he died he appeared well and joked. This evidence was correct.

Dr. Wm. Sankey said the immediate cause of death, he should say, was due either to the bursting of a blood vessel or insufficiency of blood vessels feeding the general arterial system, due to degeneration changes in the blood vessels. A severe shock would undoubtedly tend to increase that degeneracy. The injuries he received would accelerate that degeneracy. Worrying has a strong bearing on the progress of arterial degeneration. All the symptoms (described as before mentioned) lesson the power of resistance. Any slight effort, as reaching for his hat, would tend to accelerate death. Any slight accident such as the wound on the head would tend to accelerate the conditions mentioned. The degenerative process would have been going on for a long time, and sudden death might occur without an accident. The effects of the shock from such an accident as this might last many months. He thought the death was indirectly attributable to the accident.

Dr. John F. Ward said he drew the inference that arterial degeneration was the cause of death. The shock would call out latent diseases earlier than they would otherwise appear. Hard work, especially after an injury, would accelerate the conditions.

Dr. John Pratt saw deceased on the 11th July and found a lacerated wound about the eyelid and eyebrow; the ankle was sprained. The injuries were not deemed sufficiently serious for deceased to be detained in hospital. He certified also at a later date that deceased was able to resume work. He (witness) left Millom after deceased returned to work. The evidence was in his opinion inadequate to form a conclusion as to the cause of death. He could see no connection between the accident and his death whatever. His eye was healed, and he looked all right when he certified him as fit to resume work. He did not think he would have asked for a post-mortem. It would be useless, in his opinion, in this district. There had not been one for about 10 years. He visited the deceased on nine occasions after the accident and had opportunities for personal observations.

His Honour, in summing up, said the onus of proof in these cases, was with the applicants, and in this instance they had not succeeded in proving their case. He therefore, gave judgment for respondents, the Hodbarrow Mining Co., Ltd.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Barnett, M.      
Casson, Hannah      Widow
Casson, James   68 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Dockeray, Harriet      Widow
Dockeray, Robert   60 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hill, John    Miner  
Jenkins, E.    Miner  
Lord, —      
Myers, William    Miner  
Pearson, W. Garencieres      
Pratt, John, Dr.    Doctor  
Riley, William    Miner  
Sankey, William, Dr.    Doctor  
Taylor, Gawan    Judge  
Thorpe, J. H.      
Tyson, Robinson    Miner  
Wall, Agnes Ann      Daughter
Wall, Thomas      
Ward, John F., Dr.    Doctor  
Wood, —, Captain      



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print