|
5th September 1918 St. Bees Miner's DeathFell Down Pit ShaftNo One Saw ItMr. E. Atter, Coroner, on Monday evening, held an inquest at the Whitehaven Infirmary, relative to the circumstances attending the death of Edward Lamb, Main Street, St. Bees, whose death took place in the Infirmary on Saturday last. Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, representing the relatives; Mr. O. F. Ormrod, representing the Ullcoats Mining Co.; and Mr. Miles Richardson, the mine manager, were in attendance. Robert Lamb, 99, Main Street, St. Bees, stated that deceased was his son, 23 years of age, a single man, and worked as an iron ore miner at the Ullcoats Mines, where he had been working for five or six months. He last saw his son alive on Friday night. Deceased had always been healthy, and he was accustomed to his work. He saw deceased on the Wednesday and Friday after the accident, but he made not statement to him. By Mr. Duffy: His son lived with him; he had good health and was of a cheerful disposition, and had not trouble or anxiety of any sort. Dr. Pratt said he first saw the deceased on Wednesday, the 28th August. He was quite unconscious. Deceased had a compound dislocation of his left knee and the leg was very badly injured, the bone being broken practically right up to the hip joint. He also had a fracture of the right ribs, and was suffering from very severe shock, but he could not say that he ever completely regained consciousness. Pneumonia set in, and the cause of death was pneumonia, occasioned by the fracture of the ribs and the fall. Deceased died at 2.45 a.m. on the 31st August. Evidence was given by Peter Gassney, 87, Trumpet Road, Cleator, who with seven others including the deceased travelled down the pit to No. 2 Eye, where they were working. The evidence was as to the movements of the men; for somehow deceased, after getting out, had fallen down the pit and into the sumph, but nobody had seen him fall. The evidence was that there was a good electric light. Thomas Milburn, iron ore miner, 45, Jack-trees Road, Cleator Moor; Isaac Mawson, iron ore miner, 71, Main Street, Cleator, gave similar evidence to Gassney. Henry Mawson, joiner, 71, Main Street, Cleator, stated that he along with Charles Wilson, another joiner, went down the pit on the 28th August. Between ten and a quarter past two they were together when they heard a noise as if something heavy had fallen. The noise came from the sumph. Wilson turned round and asked witness if he had heard the noise, and he replied "Yes." Wilson then went to the bottom of the shaft and found a man's clog on the flat-sheets, and then he saw the deceased. Deceased shouted, "Come quick, Harry, and bring a light." From No. 2 Eye to the sumph would be 139 feet 9 inches. When witness got to where Wilson was the cage was at the bottom and he "knocked," and it lifted up. He then dropped on to the flat-sheets and saw the deceased, whose head was out of the water. He caught hold of deceased's jacket, and dragged him out. The water was about two feet below the flat-sheets. He thought deceased was a kind of semi-conscious, but he was quite helpless. The cage was "knocked" for, and in the meantime an electrician came and assisted to get deceased into the cage. At the top there was plenty of assistance, and deceased was carried into the engine-house. Replying to the Foreman as to witness's theory as to what had happened, witness replied that he thought deceased had turned to the wrong hand. William Jeffery, on-setter, 36, Bridge End, Egremont, stated that on the 28th August he went down the pit in the cage following that in which deceased descended. This cage went down about 12 minutes past two. He noticed that both gates at the Eye were open about 18 inches at the back side of the shaft. By the Inspector: The gates were open at the opposite side to that where Lamb worked. Witness got off the cage at the back side of the shaft and walked round by the road. He closed the gate as there were men on the cage for No. 3 Eye. There was room for a horse and cart on the road. He walked round the shaft, and there was a good light. By Mr. Ormrod: It was a bit strange to see both the gates open, but it never struck him in the least that anything had happened. He had not often seen them like that. If the gates had not been properly closed the wind of the cage might drive them open. Mr. Miles Richardson, manager of the mine for over 20 years, said deceased was a careful and reliable man and very quiet. Witness called the seven men together, and they gave rather conflicting evidence as to who had got off the cage. Witness came to the conclusion that deceased had got off the cage at the back side. Deceased could not have fallen from the cage. His theory was that deceased had turned the wrong way round and had walked into the space (pointed out on the plan) instead of coming round this way (also pointing to the plan) to pass round the end. The gate must have been partly open. The place was well lighted with two lamps of 32 candle-power each. The most unfortunate part of it was that none saw the accident. He thought the man had got off the cage and walked into the space where there was no cage or anything, and fell from there to the bottom 140 feet. This was only theory on his part. The gate should not have been open, and it was the duty of the last man to leave the cage to close it. It was a difficult matter to know who got off the cage. By Mr. Leck: There was no possibility of the man falling off the cage as it was going down. The cage is only nine inches less than the shaft. The Coroner, addressing the jury, first referred to the new Juries Act, which gave him the power to dispense with jurymen at inquests. When he first became aware of the Act he made a very strong pronouncement that he should not dispense with the assistance of jurymen. He put great reliance in trial by jury, not only for inquests but for all other purposes; and speaking for himself, he thought there was a tendency too much to lessen the power of trial by jury. He entirely disagreed with the statement that the Grand Jury was no use. In an inquest of this description he should not hesitate so long as he had the power to have the assistance of jury, and he would go further and say that in no case would he do away with the assistance of the jury. One thing which would have commended itself both to coroners and jurymen was that instead of dispensing with the jury, the viewing of the body should have been dispensed with. This was often a very painful thing for the relatives when the body was at their house, and to his mind the doing away with viewing the body would have been much more sensible than dispensing with the jury. As regards the present inquiry Mr. Duffy appeared for the relatives, and none of his questions implied any suggestion of negligence on the part of the Company or any of the officials. There was a mystery in this case, and as Mr. Richardson had said, the unfortunate part of it was that none saw the accident. He congratulated Mr. Richardson on the way he had given his evidence, which did very much to elucidate how the accident had happened. He (the Coroner) thought deceased had got of the cage and mistaken his road, but it was of the mystery which they could not unravel. The jury returned a verdict that deceased had died from pneumonia, caused by fractured ribs, occasioned by a accidental fall at the Ullcoats Mine on the 28th August, and they considered that there was no blame attached to anyone. Mr. Ormrod expressed the Company's great regret at the accident, and extended to Mr. Lamb their sympathy.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||