Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

29th August 1918

Serious Accident At Hodbarrow

On Thursday, before Mr. W. T. Lawrence (coroner) an inquest was held at Hodbarrow, touching the death of Samuel Smith, aged 69, residing at 110, Holborn Hill, who had been killed by a fall of roof on the previous Tuesday. Mr. Leck, inspector of mines, was present, and also Mr. Gavan Duffy and Mr. Noble Dawson, representing the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' Association, &c. Mr. S. Wilson was present on behalf of the Hodbarrow Mining Company.

Mr. Thompson was elected foreman of the jury.

The Coroner expressed his sympathy and that of the jury with the family of the deceased. Under the law recently passed he said he was empowered to hold inquests without a jury, except in cases of murder and manslaughter, but in the case of an accident at the mine he did not think he felt called upon to use his discretion, and he thought the public would desire a jury to be called on such occasions.

Wilson Smith, residing at 110, Holborn Hill, identified the body viewed by the jury as that of his father, Samuel Smith, aged 69 years.

William Hudson Stephenson stated that he worked in the same company with the deceased, and had done so for the last nine months, at No. 6 shaft at the Hodbarrow Mines. On Tuesday last he and the deceased and Arthur Stephens were working together putting in a fork, and in about two minutes after they started, the accident took place. This would be about 12.20 p.m. Prior to this they had been cleaning up the metal. For some weeks there had been signs of danger at the place. There had been falls all round, sometimes two or three on a shift, and at times a considerable amount of rock fell. Witness had mentioned this to both the timber men and the captains. On hearing a crack witness ran about 15ft but had to run another 30ft before he got to a safe place. There was a rush and a fall of rock behind, and witness and Arthur Stephens made off. Deceased was behind and was caught by the fall. Had he got three feet further he would have been clear. They shouted for lights, and assistance came and they set to work removing the wood and rock from the deceased, which took about ten minutes. One big piece of rock which one of the men was unable to move was shifted by the deceased. When he was got clear it was found that his trousers were covered with blood and his foot was hanging loose. The deceased was then carried to the hospital and the doctor was telephoned for.

In reply to Mr. Leck, witness stated that John Thomas, a timber man, had been in the working that morning about 8.30, and had inspected the place. There had been no fall that morning, and they did not say anything to Thomas, but had spoken to him about the falls previously. These falls occurred in the break or goaf, which was the worked out place in the mine. There had been several small falls, which they took no notice of. It was only big falls they took any notice of. The officials told them to come out if they thought the place was dangerous. They had put in extra head trees and forks to make the place as safe as possible. That was all they could do. He did not think any more could be done. The fall extended to No. 14 Company, two men from that company being injured. There was not much warning of the accident, the whole place was down in less than three seconds. There was a good deal of wind. The hat of one witness was blown into the roof, so that there must have been a great velocity of wind. Witness had worked four years as a miner, and he understood that the deceased had worked for about 30 years at the mines. There were some ambulance men.

In reply to the Coroner, witness did not think that anything more could have been done to make the place safe, so far as wooding was concerned. There was plenty of wood, and they had only got to ask for what they wanted and they got it. There was nothing to complain about in that line.

In reply to Mr. Duffy, witness stated that they did not consider themselves responsible for ground outside their working. He had reported these falls to the timber men, but nothing had been done, and they were allowed to work in spite of the fact they had made complaints and reported the place dangerous. The deceased was able to get one leg from under the debris. He did not think that there was any bodily injury.

The Coroner: Have you any idea what ought to have been done?

Witness: I consider that the wood in this place should have been shot out to give the wood a chance to come down.

Do you ever make any suggestions to the captains as to what should be done? — We sometimes get into trouble for suggesting things.

Dr. Pratt stated that about 1.30 p.m., on Tuesday, 20th inst., he received a telephone call and asked the nurse to let him know when the patient arrived at the hospital. He came as fast as possible and found that the deceased had received severe injuries to his right leg. The leg was fractured in several places between the ankle and the knee. Both bones were broken in several places and the soft parts were crushed. The man was sensible but the only complaint that he made was that he was in pain. Witness considered that his condition was very grave from the injuries he had received, and decided that it was absolutely necessary to amputate the leg. There was no other course.

The Coroner: Did you think that he would be able to bear the shock?

It had to be done. He was in a serious state from the time he came into the hospital, and he never rallied before he died, which took place about three-quarters of an hour after witness left the hospital. The operation was made under anaesthetics administered by Dr. Todd. He had lost a great deal of blood. He had a tourniquet on his leg, which was acting sufficiently, but he probably lost the blood before the tourniquet could be put on. He died from heart failure caused by the shock of the accident and the operation.

Mr. Leck: Would it have been more effective if first aid had been promptly rendered?

Everything that could be done was done underground.

Mr. Gavan Duffy alluded to the length of time between accident and the doctor attending, but the explanation given to this was that the time elapsed was due to the difficulty in getting the man to the surface. It was also suggested that it might be more advisable for the doctor to go underground to see that the man was scientifically removed, but the difficulties existing through the overworking of doctors was referred to, and it was stated that competent ambulance men could do this work quite as efficiently as if a medical man were present.

Continuing, Dr. Pratt stated that the man had received no injuries except to the right leg. He died about 7.30 in the evening.

Mr. Wilson: In your opinion was everything done to render first aid? — Yes.

John Thomas stated that he was engaged as a timberman at the Hodbarrow mines. He had known the deceased for many years, and considered him an experienced miner. The duty of timbermen was to visit certain sections of the mine, examine the workings, and see that everything was safe. It was very seldom that a miner called attention to any workings, but if he saw any danger he would be doing right to do so. The working would be visited every day, sometimes twice on a shift. On Tuesday morning, about 7.30 witness went into the place where the deceased was working, and as far as it was possible to see, the place was perfectly safe. The place was wooded right into the forebreast. The last headtree, they were working to complete the set of forks to the forebreast. The place was wooded with good sound wood. The men working in the company made no complaint whatever. Witness never received any complaint from the men about the place. There had been no falls at the place. He never heard that Smith had stated that it was dangerous and someone would be killed.

In reply to a juryman, witness stated that the nearest fall to where these men would be working would be about fifteen fathoms away.

Witness stated, in reply to Mr. Leck, that he had worked at Hodbarrow since he was a boy, and had been employed for six years as a timberman. He had not heard of any falls in the break, and no falls had been reported during the last fortnight.

The last fall was when the mine captain about two months previously had the props shot out. The men would be quite correct in reporting to him anything unusual. If a man had reported that the working was rendered dangerous by something from another working, the company would not allow the men to work in that place.

In reply to Mr. Gavan Duffy, witness stated that there had been no complaint by the workmen, and if a man had stated that complaints had been made to him it was not correct. No fall had been reported to him.

In reply to Mr. Wilson, witness stated that if a workman complained of a danger he would not be censured for it. Witness would not find fault with any man for doing so. He would in fact be only too pleased for attention to be called to such. So far as officials were concerned safety was the first thing that they considered.

Arthur Stephens said that he worked with the last witness, and the deceased for about two months. He had been previously a coal miner. The timbermen visited the place on the different shifts. Reports had been made to the timbermen and Thomas told them to come out if there was any danger. Stephens, the last witness, had spoken about bits of falls but nothing particular.

He could not say exactly if complaints were also made to Mr. Weeks.

In reply to Mr. Leck, witness said that there had been bits of falls which they did not think much of. He did not hear anyone saying that their place was dangerous. Little bits of falls took place a long distance away which they did not take notice of. Before this accident he did not remember ever coming out because the place was dangerous.

Mr. Thomas was recalled, and again stated that he never heard the deceased state that the place was dangerous, nor had anyone reported to him that the place was dangerous.

After the Coroner had summed up, the verdict returned by the jury was accidental death.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Dawson, Noble    for Relatives  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Lawrence, W. T.    Coroner  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Pratt, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Smith, Samuel   69 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Smith, Wilson      Son
Stephens, Arthur    Miner  
Stephenson, William Hudson    Miner  
Thomas, John    Timberman  
Thompson, —    Jury Foreman  
Todd, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Wilson, S.    Solicitor  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)  Hodbarrow (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print