|
31st January 1918 Fatality At Clintz Quarry EgremontThe death took place at the Infirmary, Whitehaven, on Saturday midnight, of Mr. Isaac Benn, 48 years of age, a shot firer and assistant foreman at Clintz Quarry, near Egremont, the property of the Workington Iron and Steel Co. On the 22nd Mr. Benn was engaged at the quarry face. He was charging a hole the fourth and last time, when a piece of shale 22in x 12in x 9in, fell from the face above and caused him to fall to the bottom of the quarry about 25ft. He sustained serious injury to his head and shoulder, and was removed to the Infirmary. Insensible from the first, he remained so until he died, his principal injury being fracture of the skull. He resided at No. 1 Market Place, Egremont, was a married man, and was held in high esteem. An inquest was held by Mr. E. Atter, coroner and a jury, of whom Mr. R. Wilson was chosen as foreman at the Infirmary on Monday evening. Mr. D. F. Gill was present, representing the Workington Iron and Steel Company; also Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector, and Mr. W. Cowen, representing the relatives of the deceased. Mr. John Trohear, shot firer at Clintz, said he had worked there about five years and knew the deceased well. Deceased was a married man. Witness identified the body. Witness was shot firing on the day of the accident, and deceased was with him. The Company supplied all ammunition. They both started about half-past ten to fire this hole. They had fired it three times and they then put in a charge that would sufficient to bring it down. Deceased was two or three yards from witness, and witness momentarily stooping and so losing sight of him, heard a thud and looking up saw the deceased had disappeared. Jumping to the place where the deceased had been he just saw him drop at the bottom of the quarry. Witness did not know how he got down to deceased, but he was down in a few seconds. Deceased was lying there quite helpless. Witness thought what caused the accident was the frost, which had just broken. The place had all been examined previously, and all appeared to be safe. Deceased was a safe worker, and whatever risks deceased ran witness shared. By Mr. Lees: They were standing on a ledge. Where deceased was standing would be about 9ft. 6in. in breadth and about 26ft long. They had no rope tied round them. There was no need. There was plenty of breadth to stand. The manager marked the holes out. They fired the first hole three times: first with 4lb. of power, then with 6lbs., and the third time with 9lbs. No ground above was taken down by any if the three shots, and witness did not notice any change whatever. As far as witness could say the piece that fell was about 12in x 19in x 9in. It broke into two pieces. It was the duty of Mr. Benn and witness to see that not only that part of the quarry was safe, but that every other place was safe when the manager was away. He would say that Mr. Benn had had experience into twenty years. He was there when witness went to Clintz. Witness was experienced in shot firing before he went there. By Mr. Cowan: The ledge would be perhaps 35ft. from the top of the quarry. There was no loose stone whatever. By Mr. Leck: The stone fell from about 25ft. above. The stone stuck deceased at the back of the head. Mr. Gill put in a sketch of the quarry, showing the ledges and the place from which the stone fell. In reply to the Coroner he said it was a limestone quarry. The witness was quite right that the frost would affect the place a great deal. Mr. Birkby Key, breaker and filler at the quarry said he was 25 or 30ft below and heard the three shots and saw the shot firer go up again. Deceased then dropped at witness's mate's feet. He came head first. Witness did not see the stone strike the deceased. Dr. Braithwaite saw the deceased shortly afterwards. By Mr. Leck: He did not notice where the stone fell. It did not hit anyone below. Witness was an ambulance man, and had been in one of the teams at the competition. They had ambulance appliances at the quarry, provided by the Company, for anything that might be wanted; and witness was satisfied that all was done that could be done, and that they had plenty of material to work with. Witness had worked at Rowrah Hall Quarry before he was at Clintz, and had been a quarryman for eight or nine years. By Mr. Cowan: He had no reason to think that the men were running any unnecessary risk, and there was no delay in getting assistance for the deceased. By the Coroner: He could not suggest anything that might be done by the employers to decrease the risk. All was carried on in the most experienced manner, and it just seemed as if the accident had to be. Mr. Wm. Benn, miner, brother of the deceased said that deceased when he saw him was in the best of health. Witness had noting to put to the jury. By Mr. Cowan: His brother was a strong, healthy working man. Mr. George Philips, quarryman at Clintz, living at Rowrah, said he had known the deceased for the 15 or 16 months witness had been at Clintz. He was a very able man. He saw deceased going down the quarry face. He fell on his left shoulder. By Mr. Leck: He did not fall on stone, but on the "muck" on top of the stone. The fall over the ledge in itself would not do him any harm. By Mr. Cowan: Witness had no reason to think that there was danger of stone falling. Dr. Huddleston, house surgeon at the Infirmary, said deceased was brought in on the Tuesday. He was unconscious, bleeding from the nose and ears. There were injuries on the skull. No operation was performed. It was a hopeless case from the first. The skull was fractured, and that was the cause of death. The Coroner said the whole of the evidence had been given very satisfactorily, especially by the first two witnesses, who had given their evidence very intelligently. The jury found that deceased died from a fractured skull by being stuck by the stone. Mr. Gill expressed on behalf of the Company their sympathy with the relations of the deceased. He might say confidently that the deceased was a very good working, one of the best types he had known for a long time. His death would be a sever loss to the Company, but would be a far greater loss for the friends of the deceased. Mr. Cowan on behalf of the workmen said that they had lost a very able, obliging, and genial workman. He had often been struck by his ability and his geniality; nothing seemed to be a difficulty to him. He was one of the most capable men he had ever known. He was sure the workmen were all very sorry, and had the deepest sympathy with the widow and family of the deceased. The Foreman associated the jury with the expressions of regret.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||