Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd January 1918

Engineman's Sudden Death At William Pit

The inquest formally opened on Thursday at the Coffee House, Tangier Street, on the body of Thomas Quayle, Engineman, George Street, Whitehaven, when the brother of the deceased identified the body, was resumed on Friday at the Magistrates Court House.

Mr. W. Carlton, Colliery Enginemen's Association agent, Workington appeared for the widow.

Mr. R. Steel, general works manager of the Whitehaven Colliery, was present. Mr. Ormrod appeared for the Colliery Company.

The Coroner intimated that he had conveyed to the Inspector of Mines that the medical evidence was that death was not occasioned by accident or collision with machinery, and the Inspector replied that in that case he thought he need not attend.

Wm. Cannon, 35, Irish-street, Whitehaven, Watchman at William Pit

By Mr. Carlton: Nothing seemed to be troubling deceased, either in himself or his work.

By the Coroner; I should think he was a staunch teetotaller.

Mr. Johnston, surveyor for the Colliery Co., produced a plan of the fan engine-house, in which deceased worked. The fan usually resolved always at the same speed and the same temperature prevailed. The machinery was fenced all round to a height of three feet from the passage ways. No machinery could touch deceased unless he got over the rail.

By Mr. Ormrod: If deceased had by any means come in contact with the fly wheel, the tendency would have been to throw him in opposite direction to where deceased was found.

Charles Clare, Fan Engineman, working with the deceased, said he had known deceased for seven years. Deceased was a man who enjoyed good health. The engine-room was warm, but he had no complaint of that, nor had he ever heard deceased complain about it. Witness went to relieve deceased about five minutes to ten, and found him lying dead on the floor. He was lying on his side. The door was open. There a little blood on the floor near his head. Witness did not at the time think deceased was dead, and ran for assistance, and they lifted him end placed him outside. Witness could not see any sign that there had been any struggle or accident. Christmas Day was an exceptional day, for there was nobody about the pit. Witness never knew deceased to have any fainting fits. The floor was dry and not slippery, and the woodwork was good.

By Mr. Carlton: The bearing of the fly wheel was very hot. The fan runs at 50 a minute. Sometime times the bearing gets hot. That is not often. If it happens, you cool it with water. Witness had heard of slackening nuts, but he had never done it. Witness examined the engine after he found deceased dead, and found all right. He did not think deceased had been doing that, because he was cold, and in the time it would have taken him to get cold the engine would have stopped, if they were moving the nuts they used a hammer sometimes, and sometimes a spanner. You would have to get inside the handrail to do that. If that was done the wheel might catch the hammer. He did not know where deceased could have been to have been caught.

By Mr. Ormrod: If he had been caught by the wheel he would have been carried round and flung out, and his body would have been probably mangled. The want of oil for two and a half to three hours will cause the bearings to heat. The oil casks were empty when witness examined and found the bearing hot. There would be no reason why deceased should go inside the railing. There was nothing significant in the fact that witness found the engine room door open. The usually kept one or both doors open.

By the Coroner: There was a board in the floor, near the fan wheel, that was splintered when he found deceased, that was not splintered when witness last saw it, two shifts previously. Witness could not say what splintered the board: it must have been something that came in contact with it, but witness could not say what it was.

By Mr. Carlton: The hammer was in the crank hole. Deceased would not have put it there. If the hammer had been carried round by the wheel it might have splintered the floor.

Wm. Stabler, boilerman, said he had known deceased for three of four years as a healthy man. The last witness came to him and informed him how he had found deceased, and witness went back with him. There was a slight discharge of blood from the right ear and nostril. Witness thought from the feeling of the temperature of the body that deceased must have been dead for some time. Deceased Clothes were all right, except that his right foot clog was rather twisted round. The bearing was hot — so much so that the place was full of smoke, so that they could hardly see.

By Mr. Carlton: On one side of his face there was a cut and a great deal of grease, and his hands were very dirty with grease. Witness thought he must have had a blow.

By Mr. Ormrod: There was no grease about the floor that could account for the grease on deceased's face.

Mr. T. Burns, surface manager at William Pit, said he knew the deceased very well. He attended to his work constantly. Witness had never had any complaint about the condition of the engine room. Witness was in the engine room on the morning of Christmas Day, and everything was in perfect order. The splintering of the board was not done at twelve o'clock noon. After deceased was found witness found the engine almost in a state of collapse, owing to the overheating of the bearing, and it was a question whether the engine would run again. One of the witnesses said that there was nobody about. That was absolutely wrong. There were half a dozen men working within fifty yards.

By Mr. Carlton: It would have been impossible that deceased could have been caught by the wheel and thrown where he was found. If he was using the hammer it might have been caught by the wheel and thrown into the crank hole.

By Mr. Ormrod: Witness thought that the last time deceased had oiled the engine was at half-past seven. Oiling was required about every two hours, and that was all the deceased had to do, and generally to watch the engine. The fence was put up for their protection. Witness had no idea what was the cause of death. Whatever it was, witness thought that the engine was all right when deceased died.

Robt. Brodie, manager at William Pit, said he was in the engine room on Christmas morning, and all was right then. He could not see how it could have been possible that deceased came in contact with any part of the machinery.

Albert Winthorp, 115, Queen Street, Whitehaven, engineman with the Colliery Company, said he had known Quayle for eight or ten years, and had worked with him. Deceased enjoyed good health, and witness never heard any complaint from him. Deceased relieved witness on Christmas Day, at two o'clock. The flooring was not splintered when witness left, it must have been done while Quayle was there. Witness could not form any opinion how it was done. They were in good condition, and not slippery. The machinery was all fenced. Witness identified the writing of deceased in the enginemen's report book, as having reported at eight o'clock, when all was right; but witness pointed out that there was a mistake in deceased figures, which could not be explained.

By Mr. Carlton: Witness saw nothing about the engine that might have caused an accident; everything was safe so far as witness could see. If deceased had fallen on the steps he would probably roll. If deceased was using a hammer which was caught by the wheel, it might be thrown out, and, it was possible that it might hit the man.

By Mr. Ormrod: In putting down his figures deceased would be guided by looking at a meter. The mistake was in the amperage, of the electric output in two cases, and in the totalling of the two.

Reginald Lawrence, assistant to Mr. Harris, said he was in attendance at the post mortem, made by Dr. Harris. The deceased was a perfectly healthy man. The organs were all free from disease. There were three cuts on the top of the scalp, a fracture at the base of the skull, a very large-bruise on the side of the head, the right ear was torn, and the right thigh was broken in the middle. There was a large bruise where the thigh was broken, and he had two injuries on the right ankle.

In reply to the Coroner, witness said there was nothing that would predispose to unconsciousness by fainting or anything of that kind. The injuries were the cause of death, and could all be accounted for by an accident. The fracture at the base of the skull would be the cause of death.

By Mr. Carlton: There was a bruise about the size of the palm of the hand corresponding to where the thigh was broken. A heavy fall of the body might occasion the bruise and the fracture. It must have been a very severe blow. Something must have struck him, or he must have struck something.

By Mr. Ormrod: He could not imagine any natural cause of death that would leave no trace in a post-mortem. The injuries might have been caused by a fall down the steps at the door, but he did not like to offer any opinion on it.

The Coroner, addressing the jury, said all the parties had been represented. For the relatives there was Mr. Carlton, a gentlemen whom he had not had the pleasure of meeting before; and he must compliment him upon the expert and skilful manner in which he had questioned the witnesses. The questions put by Mr. Carlton had been of material assistance in the inquiry. The witnesses appeared to have given their evidence very fairly, and without being invidious, he might mention the name of Mr. Stabler, who answered Mr. Carlton vary candidly, and gave great assistance. The jury had given a greet deal of time to this inquiry, and had visited and inspected the engine House. The deceased was the only one in the engine house, and it must be a matter of conjecture, in great measure, how he came by his death. They could dismiss any idea of assault and foul play; also that of any natural cause, such as heart failure. They could find an open verdict, "Found dead", or they could find that he died from a fractured skull, haemorrhage, and shock, without saying how these were occasioned; which were the result of an accident, it they had any theory as to what happened.

The jury retired for short time and considered their verdict. On their return, the Foreman (Mr. R. Wilson) said they found that the cause of death was fracture of the skull, haemorrhage, and shock, and that deceased after signing his name in the report book and coming back into the engine room, fell on the steps and his head came against the rail of the engine-room, and so he fractured his skull.

Mr. Ormrod, on behalf of the Colliery Company, asked Mr. Carlton to convey to the relatives their keen sympathy with them in the loss they had sustained. The deceased was a most steady and reliable man, and he understood that in addition to that he had been a most faithful husband, who devoted all his spare time to his wife. It was with great reluctance that he had to ask for a post-mortem yesterday; but he found it necessary , to do so, having regard to the indefinite character of the evidence; and it had proved to be worth while, because it disposed of any suggestion of natural causes.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Brodie, Robert Graham    Manager  Whos Who Page
Burns, T.    Surface Manager  
Cannon, William    Watchman  
Carlton, W.    Colliery Enginemen's Association  
Clare, Charles    Fan Engineman  
Harris, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Johnston, —    Surveyor  
Lawrence, Reginald    Doctor  
Ormrod, —    Solicitor  
Quayle, Thomas    Engineman  Deceased, Individual Page
Stabler, William    Boilerman  
Steel, Robert    General Manager  Whos Who Page
Wilson, R.    Jury Foreman  
Winthorp, Albert    Engineman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print