Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd January 1918

Frizington Miner's Death

As the result of an accident at and in the course of his employment, on the 28th December, Mr. David Rudd, 33 years of age, miner 11, Frizington Road. Frizington, died at the Infirmary, Whitehaven; on Monday last. Mr. Rudd was a married man, and worked in the employment of the Lonsdale Mining Company, at Lonsdale Pit, Frizington. About eight a.m., on Friday last he was at work on a ladder boring a hole with the object of letting down a large lump of metal. He came off the ladder to change his drill, and after returning up the ladder when the lump came away. It smashed the ladder and crushed his left arm and shoulder. Mr. William John Murphy, another miner, was working at the same place and saw the accident occur, but was unable to prevent it or avert injury to Mr. Rudd. The lump gave no warning of its fall. Two other men were working in the same place, but some distance away. All assistance that was possible was rendered to Mr. Rudd, who was brought to the surface where Dr. Quine was in attendance and ordered his removal to the Infirmary considerable delay, however, was experienced before the arrival of the ambulance.

The Inquest

Inspector — Report Book — And Ambulance

The inquest was held on New Years Day at the Infirmary, by Mr. E. Atter, Coroner. Mr. R. Wilson foreman of the jury. Mr. T. Williams, manager of the Lonsdale Pit; Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector; and Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy represented the relatives.

Mr. Anthony Rudd, 59, Mill Street, Frizington, miner, brother of the deceased, identified the body. He saw his brother after he was brought up the pit after the accident. His brother was conscious; and he saw him twice at the Infirmary but his brother did not mention to him anything about the accident.

Mr. William John Murphy, Winder, miner, said he was working with the deceased on Friday. Witness had known Mr. Rudd as a miner for the last 15 or 16 years. Mr. Rudd had been in the Army. On Friday they were dressing the roof down. Mr. Jonathan Park, deputy, came in while they were at work, and spoke with them about ten minutes and told them to be careful. Witness and Mr. Rudd had examined the roof before they began work. The lump they were trying to get down is standing yet. It was a false lump that came down. Witness was boring a hole two yards away, but was not on a ladder. The concussion of boring might have brought the false lump away. There would be about six bogies of metal in the lump that came away. The ladder was smashed to pieces. Witness released Mr. Rudd, with assistance. Mr. Rudd was taken out of the mine about nine o'clock. The doctor met him at the top.

By Mr. Leck: The experience of an experienced man in a working was deferred to, and Mr. Rudd was in every respect fit for his work. But witness understood that no miner had more responsibility than another. Witness did not understand the remark of the deputy that they should be careful meant that there was any special danger. No special attention was directed to the particular lump that came away. The height from the sole of the roof where the fall took place would be about 12 feet or 13 feet. The lump that came away had sounded sound as a bell and yet it came way of itself. It was ore and stone, both. Mr. Park while in with them for ten minutes had a look round. He gave no special instructions except that they were to take care. They had all the morning been dressing the roof to make it safe. It was a solid stone roof. There was a sill parting at the top of the lump that fell, and of the side. Mr. Rudd was a very careful man. He had been eight months back from the Front. It was an hour and a half or two hours after they got Mr. Rudd up that the ambulance came.

By Mr. Gavin Duffy: The lump that came down was not touched at all except by the vibration of Mr. Rudd's hammer. Witness said he did not know the cause of the delay in the arrival of the ambulance.

Mr. Duffy said that it was a scandalous thing that a man who had met with an accident should be left for an hour and fifty minutes. He supposed the people, resident in the district would recognise that a motor ambulance is necessary.

Dr. Muriel said deceased had a compound dislocation of one of the joints of his left elbow and a fracture of the humorous. He was considerably bruised and damaged about the body and had a fracture of the jaw. He was in a state of collapse when brought to the Infirmary, and there seemed to be considerable probability that there was some internal injury. He was not in a fit condition to be operated upon at once, and they decided to postpone it. The cause of death was haemorrhage from internal injuries — to the chest, probably.

By Mr. Duffy: In all cases it is important that there should be no delay in moving the patient, but in this particular case he did not think it would make any difference if there was delays the delay would not account for the collapsed condition.

Mr. Jonathan Park, Main Street, Frizington, deputy about 13 years, said he saw Mr. Rudd with Mr. Murphy at twenty minutes to eight. Mr. Rudd was on a ladder and they talked for about five minutes, and told him to be very careful. Witness was some distance away when the accident occurred. Witness had not examined the place that morning before. He examined it on the day before about half-past ten on the Thursday. He did not examine it on the Friday before eight' o'clock because he had not reached that place. He thought it would be his duty to have examined the place on the Friday before the men begin work. When he did examine the pit in their presence he did so with the lamp, not by sounding. He did not think special precautions were necessary when he told them to be careful. That a usual remark. Witness thought that the boring brought the lump down. Witness did not think Mr. Rudd's judgement was in fault.

By Mr. Leck: He made the same inspection on the Friday as he did on Thursday, that on the Friday was when they in at twenty minutes to eight. Witness examined the roof with his lamp, and Murphy explained that they had, had some bad ground and had been taking it down, but they had got it all right, and witness though it was all right. Witness had an acetylene lamp, with which looking up he could see very well. The advice to be careful was phase that he used to the men generally. He did not think that the lump that fell would ever fall; but he could not see that it had a sill parting, and he though the concussion had set it away.

Mr. Leck said it must have been pretty ready to come away already before the concussion of the hammer would bring it.

Witness said Mr. Rudd was kept in the changing house until the ambulance came.

By Mr. Duffy: It was witness duty to have examined the place before the men started. The places were not always examined before the men started work. There was only one shift working and the men knew what the place was like. Witness when he did examine the place sounded several spots with a pick. The roof was a slate roof. He did not sound the roof, but examined what had come down from it. Witness though ten minutes was ling enough to examine the place.

By the Coroner: They had report books but owing to a fire they were burnt. It was witness duty to make a report of his examination, but there was no book.

Mr. Williams, the Mine Manager, said the fire took place seven weeks ago, and the report books had been on order since, but they had not received them.

Mr. Leck said these books were not coming.

The Coroner said that it seemed to him unsatisfactory they did not use some temporary books.

Mr. Leck said it was not compulsory under the Act, and he could not insist on it or he would have done so. They had been waiting for an Act of Parliament for 20 years, but they had not go it yet.

Mr. Williams said the deputy when he went through should examine the working and see if this roof was right, and if it was bad they had been accustomed to enter it in a report book. It might be considered evidence of negligence that there was at present no report book, but he had ordered them at the Whitehaven Office and they had waited it from the printer, and they were waiting for it. He might say that when he went to the Lonsdale Pit, there had never been a report book. Where he had worked previously they had always had one, and he got a copy and had it printed and they had always used it at the Lonsdale Pit since.

The Coroner: Ought they not to make report in the report book that they make a examination before the workmen start.

The Coroner: But what would you expect.

Mr. Williams: If every place had to be examined before the men started work the men would have to have a man specially. He did not think it was possible for one man to go through the place.

The Coroner: Then I don't think there is much security for the workmen.

Mr. Williams: Yes, there is security. We have not gas. It is customary for the men themselves to examine the working.

The-Coroner: What is the duty of the deputy?

Mr. Williams: His chief business is to see that the men do examine their places themselves — to look after the safety of the men.

The Coroner: Not to look after production?

Mr. Williams: No; I am there to look after that, sir. Before I sit down I don't know whether I will be in order, but I would like to express the regret of the Lonsdale Company at this sad accident. This was one of our best men — a man I had every confidence in — a careful and capable miner; and we feel all the more about it seeing that we got him from the Front after he had been two years fighting in France; and I am sure the Company desire to express their sorrow to the widow and the bereaved.

Mr. Leck repeated with regard to inspection that seeing it was not a statutory requirement he could not enforce it. He could only suggest, and his powers ended there.

Mr. Williams: I may say that on former occasions Mr. Leck has asked to see the report book and he has seen it.

Mr. Leck said that was so.

Mr. Gavin Duffy said the action of the Company had been somewhat contemptible. There was no examination, because it was not compulsory; no report book, because it was not compulsory; there was no plan produced here because it was not compulsory; they had no professional representatives here because it was not compulsory; and no plan. There was not much time, and it is the holiday season. They got along very well with a sketch plan by Mr. Leck: and without any words of flattery he thought Mr. Williams, who attended in the interests of the Company, made a very good representative. But as regards the question of inspection, and the report book, while there was no criminal or wrongful neglect, he thought it was very unfortunate, to use a mild word, that they did not have the report book that they did have before the accident. He hoped the manager would now see that it was supplied. As regards inspection, as Mr. Duffy said it is not compulsory. He did not know whether the jury agreed with him, but he certainly had felt some dissatisfaction with the way Mr. Park gave his evidence as to how and when he made his inspection. As regards the delay in the arrival of the ambulance, there is a difficulty just now in getting a motor ambulance, and the prices are very high. It had been considered at the Infirmary, and they would have to keep a motor driver; it was a question of expense, and, whether it was wise or not, it was deferred until after the war, when it was expected a great many motors would be liberated, and the would be cheaper. As to the cause of death, there had been nothing in the evidence given that showed wrongful neglect on the part of anyone deserving censure, but it was open to the jury to make any recommendation.

The jury returned the verdict the deceased died from internal haemorrhage caused by the accident, and they agreed with the remarks the Coroner had made about the ambulance, inspection and report book.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Muriel, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Murphy, William John    Miner  
Park, Jonathan    Deputy  
Quine, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Rudd, Anthony    Miner  Brother
Rudd, David   33 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Williams, T.    Manager  
Wilson, R.    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Lonsdale (Iron Ore)  Lonsdale (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print