|
20th December 1917 Fatal Accident At The Hodbarrow MinesMiner Crushed To Death By Fall Of RoofOn Friday evening an inquest was held at the Hodbarrow Hospital, touching the death of Thomas Chadwick, a miner residing at 214, Holborn Hill, aged 39 years. Along with another Millom miner named Williams, and a Scotchman, Colin Duff, the deceased was engaged in boring operations when without any warning there was a sudden fall of rubbish, which partially covered deceased, pinning him to the ground, and a second fall immediately after covered him up. When removed about two and a half hours afterwards he was quite dead. Colin Duff was also slightly injured, being knocked down, but the third man (Williams), who was further away from the forebreast, escaped without injury. The inquest was held before Mr. W. T. Lawrence, Coroner, and a jury, of which Mr. E. E. Atkinson was elected foreman, Mr. W. Leck, Inspector of Mines, was present, and the relatives were represented by Mr. Gavan Duffy. Mr. S. Wilson was also in attendance representing the Hodbarrow Mining Company. Sidney Chadwick, 31, Lonsdale Road, miner, identified the body viewed by the jury, as that of his brother, Thomas Chadwick, who resided at 214, Holborn Hill. He was in the employment of the Ministry of Munitions, at the Hodbarrow mines as a miner, he was 39 years of age. Herbert Williams, iron ore miner at Hodbarrow, residing at 19, Lonsdale Road, said he knew the deceased, Thomas Chadwick. On the 12th inst., Wednesday evening, he was at work with the deceased, together with a Scotchman named Colin Duff. Witness had been a miner eight years. The deceased was an experienced miner, and would be at that occupation, 15 years. Duff had been only nine days as an iron miner. Witness stated that about 7-30 on the evening of the 12th inst., they were engaged in boring operations near the centre of the mine. They had been doing this work the previous two hours. The first thing that attracted his attention was a crush by a lump that came from the roof. He could not say whether it was rock or metal. The fall knocked his two mates down, the deceased (Chadwick) and Colin Duff. They were not buried by the first fall, immediately another fall of roof took place, about seven seconds after the first. This fall was of rubbish, and it covered up the deceased, but none of it fall on witness. Acting on instructions from his other mates (who were older men) he went for help to what he thought was the nearest gang. The help was readily rendered. A great body of stuff fell from the roof. Witness did not see the deceased removed. Prior to the accident witness and his mates were boring a lifting hole and spading over the hopper, which was the ordinary process of mining. So far as witness could see there was no danger in the working which they were engaged in. Witness considered the part they were working was dangerous owing to the bad roof. This was generally known by the workmen as well as those who were in charge of the workmen as far as he knew. Every precaution was taken, against danger. Witness had been at this ground between three weeks or a month. Mr. Boardley, an official, had inspected this place the same afternoon between four and five. Witness, in reply to a question, said he could not account for the accident, unless some of the wood had shrunk or the roofing had become rotten. Colin Duff stated he had worked at the Hodbarrow Mines nine days, being one of a batch of the men who came recently to work there. He was not an iron ore miner, but a coal miner. There was not a great deal of difference, beyond the fact that iron mines required more timbering. On Wednesday he was working with the deceased and last witness. The accident happened about 7-30, as far as he could judge. Witness and Thomas Chadwick were boring with a double-handled hammer, and Williams was about two yards away putting metal down the hoppers. The roof came away without any warning. This consisted of old timber, rock, and rubbish. It caught witness by the foot. The second fall covered up deceased. The second fall only covered him partially. The second fall took place about seven seconds after the first, and entirely covered him up. The fall would be thirty or forty tons. Witness was aware that the place was a dangerous place. Both Mr. Leck and Mr. Duffy questioned the witness without eliciting any further material evidence. Richard Boardley, 6, Castle Terrace, timber man, said in the course of his duty he had to inspected the place where Thomas Chadwick and his mates were working. He did so about 3-15 p.m. on Wednesday, and in his opinion the place was quite safe. He stated that he inspected the mines once a day, and this place was inspected the same day as the accident. He saw the fall about half an hour after the accident. He could not tell what happened. He saw the deceased got out. It took about two and a half hours to get him out, and he was then quite dead. Captain Towers, underground mining captain at the Hodbarrow Mines, a position which he had occupied for the last 19 years, said it was his duty to see to the timbering of the workings, he knew the deceased, and also the place where he was killed. He inspected the timbering of the place on the Monday prior to the accident. The last witness, R. Boardley, was his subordinate. He saw the place where the fall occurred immediately after the accident. Witness considered that the accident was due to a slight movement of the rock above, which broke through the spiles and caused the headtrees to move. Witness did not consider that the place was more dangerous than any other. In cross-examination, Captain Towers admitted that there might be a small undetected cavity over the roof. The deceased had a long experience at Hodbarrow. His estimate of the stuff that fell was about twenty tons. Two and a half hours had elapsed before the man was extricated. He was dead, but the man spoke a few words some time before. In reply to Mr. Duffy, witness stated that verbal reports were made where more timbering was required. Above the place of the accident two heads had been worked out. There would be about out twenty feet taken out. He considered that the spiles had slipped, letting a mass of small stones down. The deceased was a very careful man. In summing up, the Coroner said it would be for the jury to decide what verdict they brought in. It seemed to him that it was a pure accident, and that every care possible had been taken, but such accidents occurred in the best regulated mines, not withstanding the fact that every care was taken to prevent them. He did not see that they could do anything else than bring in a Verdict of accidental death. The jury then returned their verdict accordingly.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||