|
29th November 1917 William Pit FatalityFall Of A Ten-Ton StoneIn connection with the fatal accident at William Pit, Whitehaven reported last week, the coroner and the jury, the Government Inspector, and Mr. Ormrod attended in the committee room at the Infirmary on Thursday afternoon. The Coroner said he was sorry to call them together that day but he found that in the case of the injured man who was in the Institution, a serious amputation would have to take place tomorrow, under anaesthetic, and therefore it was desirable that they should take his evidence at once; and Dr. Tawse had informed him that he was quite capable, mentally of giving evidence, and that it should be no trouble or inconvenience to him to do so. He had sent word to Mr. Cape, who was unable to come, but the father of Stephenson was present. The Coroner suggested that they should take the evidence at the bedside as shortly as possible. He would just take his own words and scribble it down in pencil. The Foreman (Mr R. Wilson) :— You could not do it yourself, Mr. Coroner, without us coming along with you? The Coroner :— I don't think so. If you do not hear all the evidence your decision is given on evidence you have not heard. Dr. Tawse (coming into the room) :— He is quite willing and able sir, if you will make it as short as possible. The Coroner and jury, the Government Inspector and Mr. Ormond then proceeded to the room where Wilkinson was lying and his evidence was taken down by the Coroner. The injured man stated that he lived at 4, Dobson's Buildings, Albion Terrace, and was a shiftsman at William Pit, where he had worked for three years and nine months. On Monday he was on the night shift and went down the pit at half past five. He and Stephenson were working together, and the place was inspected by a deputy named Kennedy before they started. Kennedy left a mark and the date to show that he had made the inspection. Witness had worked in the Countess district for about 15 months, but had only commenced on Monday in the place where the accident occurred. The deputy gave them their orders. They got one set of timber put in. Then they got a single prop set, and were carrying in their third prop when the stone fell. They got the first set of timber up about eight o'clock, and the accident happened between 11 and 11.30. The fall caught witness. He was fast between two stones and another piece came down on his thigh. Stephenson had hold of one end of the prop, which they were carrying when the fall occurred. Witness did not lose consciousness. By the Inspector :— The deputy was in while they were busy with the timber between nine and half-past nine, as near as he could tell. The place did not alter any after the deputy left. They had got one set of timber and one prop under the stone that fell. By Mr. Ormrod :— They were carrying out what they were told to do by the deputy, William Fitzsimmons. The Coroner expressed the hope that Wilkinson might soon recover, and the jury then retired to the Committee Room, where the coroner intimated that the inquest would stand adjourned until December 5th, as arranged on Wednesday. Mr. Wilkinson died on Friday night. The inquest was therefore resumed on Monday forenoon at the infirmary, when the parties were represented as before. The Coroner said "their worst fears on Thursday, when the deposition of Wilkinson was taken, had been realised, and they would now have to hold an inquest on both the men". The widow of Robert Wilkinson, Dobson's Buildings, identified the body of her husband, who she said was 35 years of age. Richard Starkey, 25, Poter-street, Whitehaven, collier at William Pit, said he had worked there for two years and had known the two deceased men for a good while, and had worked in the same place with them for about eight weeks. On the day of the fatality they were making ready to put the gear in. He saw them while they were doing so. Witness was standing at the brake top, and heard the stone come down without warning. Witness was standing only about three yards away. Witness and others ran to the place. He heard Wilkinson shout, and found the stone on top of his leg. Stephenson was under the stone, about two yards from where Wilkinson was lying. Wilkinson asked for a drink, and kept calling out "Joe" (meaning Stephenson). Witness saw the deputy Fitzsimons examine the place soon after they started work, and he told them to put the timber in. It was new timber the deceased was putting in, and was all good timber. By the Inspector :— There was a bit of noise at the time, from the running of the brake. They went right in to the forehead when they started work. He did not know whether the place was examined before they went in. Deceased had put the first set of gear in early on. Witness described the position of the props. He did not know whether there had been any movement in place before the fall. There was some timber in before the men went in. Witness was present when the men were relieved. He did not see any of the timber used to relieve the men from the stone. Just before the stone fell the men were wedging up a prop. By Mr. Cape :— This was witness's first shift in this place, and he did not know what took place. There were ten tubs running on the brake and with the noise you could not hear any working of the roof that there might have been before the stone fell. The men had not to look for their wood: it was all up. Witness could not tell how long the place had been standing. By Mr. Ormrod :— These men were engaged making the place safe. He thought they were wedging a prop when the stone fell. He did not know about them carrying a prop. Wm. Fitzsimons, deputy overman for ten weeks, and before that a joiner, said he worked at William Pit. He knew the deceased. He saw them at a quarter to seven, and gave them directions to timber this place. A deputy named Kennedy had his mark left when witness was there, showing that the place had been examined. At half-past eight witness made a careful examination of the place and found nothing wrong, but could not say how long it was before the place had been worked before. A bar and three props required, and they were putting them up. He helped them a bit and then left them and came back and found they were in hands with another prop up. He would leave them about twenty minutes to ten. The wood was new and all suitable. Both of the men were experienced men, who knew the work they were doing. Witness was in another district when the accident happened, and when he got to the place Wilkinson had been got out. Stephenson's body was recovered about a quarter past one. Asked what he thought had brought down the fall, witness said he really could not say. By the Inspector :— He did not think that Kennedy's chalk mark meant that the roof was bad. There was nothing to have prevented the hewers getting in except the timber men. The deceased were working about nine feet from the forehead. If they had been sent to timber the face they would have gone further in. When witness examined the roof he found it was a good strong roof. In his opinion it was safe. He did not see anything wrong. The Inspector :— And still you were putting timber in? Witness :— To keep the men employed. There was nothing else for them to do. Witness did not know from examination after the accident how it had occurred. The only conclusion he could come to was the wood must have been driven rather tight and the stone broke off the thin edge. By Mr. Cape :— Before witness was a joiner he was a hewer. Men were filling in loose coal within four or five yards. Was it fair to have men working there at a place that required to be timbered well, it really did not require timbering. There was not a sign of a break in the stone when he sounded it. After the accident the stone did not show signs of an old break. With the noise of the break running it would be difficult to hear working of the roof if there was any. Don't you think in a case of timbering, it would be better that it should be done when all is still and quiet? What's your opinion on that point? Witness did not give his opinion. Mr. Cape pointed out that this was a place that had been standing for many years. By the Foreman :— He stopped there and helped the men showing that in his opinion there was no danger from the roof. Robert Brodie, manager of William Pit for only a week before the accident, said he never saw the place before the accident. He saw it an hour after the accident. He found one prop lying under the stone. There were four men there and they had propped the place further to ensure their safety. In his opinion if this set of gear had been up and the legs that they were supposed to be in the act of putting in, there would have been no danger whatever. It have been — he could not see otherwise — that the setting of that timber had in some way disturbed the stone. From inspection in the short time he had been in William Pit, he found that these stones running to the feather edges were prevalent, and great care and experience was required to detect them, and if the two men were not very careful they might take a wrong step, and set the timber to the feather edge. If the timber had been under the heavy part of the stone the leverage would not have been so great, and the stone would not have had the same chance of falling. The orders that were given to the deceased men were quite correct, and such as he would have given himself. The timber was all quite safe and good timber. By the Inspector :— The evidence as it had been given of these men timbering within four or five yards of where men were working, would tend to show that the place required more timber. Instead of relying upon a featheredge it would certainly be safer to put more timber in. There was greater precaution required. When a new pillar was broken into he thought the necessary precautions were being taken. The timbering had started the same day as the men had started. So that there was no lose of time. By Mr. Cape :— From the side of the brake to where the men were filling coal was 20 yards. In that 20 yards — he did not pay particular attention — he described in the plan what props he thought were set. Practically the only things there were the chock and the legs. He had not had much time to consider the ambulance system, but he had received a letter on the subject, and he would see to it. As long as he was manager he would do all he could for the comfort of the men. The witness added that speaking candidly without fear or favour, he must say that in his opinion it was a pure accident. The Coroner :— That is for the jury to decide. John Kennedy, 61, Front Row, Newhouses, deputy at William Pit for five years, said he knew the deceased men, and Stephenson he knew to be an experienced and reliable man. Witness had examined the place, and there were some men getting loose coal over the way at the time. That was at 5.25. He found all right, and chalked accordingly. Everything was solid, and witness could not see anything that was suspicious. He thought that the timber might have been driven too tightly into the featheredge. He did not think that there was a risk of the men doing the timbering, and it was not necessary for a deputy to be present while the joiners were working if the joiners were practical men. By the Inspector :— He told the incoming deputy that all was ready for timbering. They had a rule that timbering must be done up to a certain distance, and that they must not go more than eight yards from the timber. By Mr. Cape :— He did not think they could have followed up the work by timbering better than they had done. He put up a chalk mark where they had started the timbering. That was no indication that he thought the roof was bad. In his opinion the roof was quite safe, and it would be so for a considerable time. Isaac Graham, Lady Pit Terrace, medallist in the ambulance ten years ago, said he was present shortly after the accident, and saw Wilkinson and examined him. Another ambulance man there said his thigh had been broken. Wilkinson was taken to the infirmary in the ambulance van. By Mr. Cape :— The doctor was sent for, but he did not know whether he was there when Wilkinson reached the top. It was four and a half miles out of this district, and it would be well to have some covering for the injured man while being carried out. Mr Cape said all other appliances were provided, and he felt sure the Colliery Company, if their attention was called to it, would provide blankets. Dr. Tawse described the injuries of the deceased, which were more extensive than they at first supposed. For two days he seemed to improve slightly. The after effects of the injuries, shock, and septic poisoning were sufficient to account for death. The leg was mortified and gangrenous, and had to be amputated on the Thursday evening, and he survived till Friday night. There was no chance of recovery if he had not been operated on. By Mr. Cape :— Wilkinson arrived at the hospital about four o'clock. Witness saw him when he visited in the ordinary way at ten o'clock. He had then already received attention from the house surgeon. The Coroner, in addressing the jury, said he thought the way Mr. Brodie had given his evidence was candid and most satisfactory; and anything at all which could be done to prevent any repetition of accidents of this description he felt certain as long as he was manager would have his best attention. He also considered that the evidence of the other witnesses was satisfactory. If the jury were of that opinion the accident was not due to the fault of anyone. The jury found that the deceased died from the effects of the accident. Mr. Ormrod tendered on the part of the Colliery Company to the relatives through Mr. Cape their deepest sympathy. They had hoped that Wilkinson would have recovered, but it was not to be ; and he could only say that they had lost two servants whom the Company would miss very much indeed. The Foreman of the jury said they wished to be associated with the expressions of sympathy. These were two very fine young men, who might have been useful for many years to come. The Coroner observed that from more than one person he had had a high character of both of them as very much liked by those who knew them.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||