Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th October 1917

The Fatality At William Pit, Whitehaven

The Inquest

The Observance Of Safety Rules

The Coroner (Mr. E. Atter) held an inquest on the body of William Telford, coalminer, at the Whitehaven Police court, on Thursday afternoon. Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector: Mr. J. Hanlon (for the relatives of deceased), Mr. G. F. Ormrod (who represented the Whitehaven Colliery Co.), and Mr. R. Steel (General Manager of the collieries) were present. Councillor P. Wilson was foreman of the jury.

John Telford, 27, Queen-street, son of the deceased, said his father worked at William Pit, and he had heard him say that he had worked at the pits since he was 13 years of age. Deceased had been through the Boer War, and twice took part in battles during the present war. He was a National Reservist, and had been wounded. Witness had also had two years and 27 days' service and had been invalided home with bad feet.

The Coroner said the witness's father and those connected with him had done every service they possibly could for their country.

Witness said he himself was a collier and had worked at William Pit since he was 14 years of age. On Tuesday last he had been working all the shift with his father and John Dockwray. They were working in No. 7 South Countess district, and Dockwray and witness were taking out the twentieth tub. Thomas Casson, the deputy, passed them into the place. His father drew the deputy's attention to the place, and the deputy sounded the roof. All went right up to the time witness and Dockwray took a full tub to the siding, and when coming back they met Casson, who said, "The stone has fallen." Witness did not hear the fall. He asked Casson if his father was clear, and Casson said, "No; that was the worst of it." The accident happened about half-past ten, and he thought the place would be tested between eight or shortly after eight o'clock. Witness did not see the stone that fell.

By the Inspector: His father draw the attention of the deputy to the stone. He told the deputy that there was some stone hanging bad above the coal, and the deputy tested the roof. His father also inquired about the joiners coming in to put the timber in. Casson said he had only one joiner, and he could not manage to put the timber in. Casson did not tell witness to put any in; nor did he tell Dockwray or witness's father, in witness's presence. His father thought the stone jowled heavy; but he didn't know whether it was that stone which fell or not. They did not attempt to put any timber in. There was timber, in the place up to within a yard or two from the back. His father was the leading hand in the place.

The Coroner: Do you know if any timber was put in after your father had spoken about it? — No timber was put in after eight o'clock.

By Mr. Ormrod: Do I understand you to say that you and your father considered this working unsafe? — At one part a piece of stone did no jowl good.

W. H. Johnston, surveyor for the Colliery Company, produced a plan of the working place. The stone which fell was broken in two places, and he estimated that it would weigh about ten tons.

In answer to Mr. Ormrod, the witness John Telford, said the deputy said the stone was bad. We inferred from that it was dangerous. — Then why did you not come out? — Witness said he was not in charge of the working, and they were behind the stone, where he thought it was safe. — You know if you consider a place dangerous there is nothing to prevent you coming out? — Witness said his father had told him if they got nothing, if they got no tubs, they would work safe. The deputy who passed them in was Hugh McKenzie.

In reply to Mr. Ormrod, the witness Johnston said this was robbery work. The roof was of sandstone.

John Dockwray, 5, Bransty Row, coal hewer, said the place was tested by Casson, and witness also tested and examined it. The place needed timber. Deceased told witness that the roof was bad, and he also told Casson to jowl it for himself. He saw Casson do so and then he said it was bad. There was nothing done. Casson informed them that he had only one joiner, and he could not manage it. Witness had been a coal hewer for about twelve months. He did not hear the fall. When he got to the working he could only see the deceased's head and shoulders. He did not stop until deceased was released. It was about 200 yards to the siding.

Witness did not see any timber lying in the place. Witness and his mates did not put any timber. It was not their place to do so. — The Inspector said it was. They must make the place safe or come out of it. — Witness said the deputy should have seen to this. — Did you put any timber up? No, sir. — Did you come out of the working? Not at the time. — Why did you continue to work in it if you thought the roof was bad? We thought we would get some timber in the place. — Yes, and the more you worked the worse the place would become. The rule stated that they had to make the place safe or leave it? — Yes. — And you did not do either? No. — Did the deputy say the place was too bad to work in or not? He said the place was bad and needed timber. It was to the right hand side of the working that the deputy's attention was drawn, and when he went out Telford was working on the right hand side.

By Mr. Hanlon: No coal hewer set timber unless they were asked to do so. If they had been told to get some timber or assist anyone they would have done so. He considered that there should always be two joiners on a shift.

By Mr. Ormrod: Witness did not see timber lying 16 yards away. He could not read a great deal, but he knew that there were rules posted at the pit top. — Isn't it a fact that if he thought this place was unsafe that he, the deputy, had only to ask you to help him to put this timber in? — Witness said it was not their duty. — Mr. Ormrod said Mr. Steel had told him that it was, and said they were paid extra for this work.

The Coroner asked witness if he had ever taken the trouble to read the rules.

Witness said he could not read sufficiently.

The Coroner read the rules, to the effect that if a sufficient supply of materials for supporting the roof and sides of any working place is not available at the place appointed by the Act the workmen shall withdraw from the working place and report the circumstances to the fireman, the examiner, deputy, or any other official; and that if there is any dangerous defect in any part of the roof or sides, or any other source of danger, the workman shall, if it falls within the scope of his duties to remedy such defects, immediately proceed to take the steps necessary for the purpose, and, if it does not, he shall immediately inform the manager, under-manager, fireman, deputy or any other official and shall cease working in the place. You are perfectly free if you are in danger, to withdraw from the place, added the Coroner. Will you remember that for the future if you didn't know it?

Witness: Yes, sir.

Witness could not set timber and the only thing for him to do was to withdraw from the place.

The Coroner: You would have been out of danger if you had done so.

Thomas Casson, 27, Pipehouse Lane, pit joiner, said he was acting deputy on the day of the fall. He saw Telford, his son, and Dockwray at eight o'clock in the morning. Telford told him there was a bit of bad stone and drew his attention to it. Witness sounded it with a pick and told Telford not to touch any of the sides. He thought it was quite safe to finish the shift. It seemed to be sufficiently propped. Telford said it would be better to have a prop there; and witness told him he was to get the benk and spar off, and he would get it done. Witness jowled the roof in three places. He told deceased to get the loose coal so that the props could be put in. The stone was so thick that it could not be jowled. He thought the place was perfectly safe to work in. They had to get the coal filled and they could not set the props until this was done.

By the Inspector: They could not get the timber in because the coal was in the way. When Telford drew his attention to the condition of the place he did not tell the men to come out, because he did not consider it was unsafe. He had power to order the men to put timber in if it was necessary.

By Mr. Hanlon: There was no complaints from the previous day. He did not think the stone which Telford drew his attention to came down. The stone which fell was seven or eight feet across and was not practically bad at all. It did not jowl bad. A stone like that would come without any warning. There was no coal near the place where deceased was lying, and he might have been coming out when caught.

By Mr. Ormrod: He had had 25 years' experience of pit work and a fair experience of deputy's work. In exercising his judgement about this place he came to the conclusion that it was safe.

James Telford, shiftsman, 42, High Church-street, who gave evidence, said in reply to the Coroner that he had been a soldier in this war and was invalided home and discharged. He was three years and one month in the Army.

Hugh McKenzie, deputy, said he knew the place where deceased was working, and he examined it at three o'clock on Tuesday morning, using an ordinary bar. It seemed all right, and he reported it as all right.

By the Inspector: Have you at any time asked men to put timber up? — Yes sir; I have. — Have they done it? — Yes sir. — There is a question as to whether they are paid for putting the timber up? — They would be paid for it.

By Mr. Hanlon: He did not find any marks in the place as if the hewers had been trying to get the stone down. This place was sufficiently timbered in witness's judgment.

John Cassidy, 34, Charles-street, coal hewer at William Pit for 30 years, said he was there on Monday on the back shift, and James Blaney set him away. William Doran and David Phillips were working with him. He examined this place, and found the stone very bad, and he sent out for the deputy or the joiners. Doran came back and said the deputy had gone down the cross-cut or another district.

Mr. Ormrod, here interposing, said they were going back to Monday, and it was unfortunate that witnesses should be called and allegations made of which they had had no notice.

The Coroner said the police report was the only evidence he had.

Mr. Ormrod said they could go back for a month or a year.

The Coroner said they must have this evidence.

Mr. Ormrod said it was rather unfortunate to take one side of the story and not the other. He had made his protest — a most emphatic protest against this evidence, and he cold not do more than that.

The Coroner repeated that he was going to take the evidence.

Mr. Ormrod said the Coroner could do what he liked, but it was very unfair to the Colliery Company.

Witness, continuing, said they had attempted to bring this stone down, but as this was the first day after cavilling they had no gear. The stone was practically three yards in front of witness.

By the Inspector: He had not seen the place since the accident. — Then you will not know what stone has come down. You were complaining about a stone that has not come down. If I tell you that the man was at the end of the place, will you be inclined to disagree with me? No, I will not. I have not been in the place. He was aware of the rule that they had to withdraw from a place if it was unsafe, but they did not do so.

The Inspector: So that it could not be so bad when you thought you would not bother? — It would have been a fault if we had done so.

The Inspector: Oh, no, no; the rule is there for your safety, and you do not take advantage of it.

By Mr. Hanlon: As an ordinary coal hewer he had nothing to do with timbering unless they were asked, and they got the gear to do the work. No hewers were given joiner's gear unless they took the place by contract.

By Mr. Ormrod: Do you say that the deputy Blaney says the roof was bad? — Yes. Are you blaming the deputy Blaney? — No, he reported it to the other.

Marmaduke Waddington, Scotch Street, coal miner, said he was working in the same place as the deceased on Monday. He examined the roof, and found that this stone was "heavy," and he sent out for the joiner, who came and put two props in on the left-hand side. This would be about seven o'clock. He thought it was safe to work in, and that it was safe at the time he left the working.

By the Inspector: So that what the last witness has said about the place being unsafe does not count now. You say it was safe when you left it; you left after him? — Yes, there were two props in.

The Coroner said this was a very pathetic case. Here they had a man who had been fortunate enough not to be killed in the war, but the misfortune was that his death had been occasioned by what must be a less hazardous employment, that of a collier, to that of the war. They were not investigating the question as regards compensation. His own opinion was that Casson had given his evidence in a very candid and fair manner.

The jury found that the deceased met his death from injuries received by an accidental fall of stone; and the Foreman said that they thought that when anyone told a deputy that props were required, he should see that the work was carried out, and this might prevent many of these accidents.

The Inspector said it was the deputy's duty to see the place was safe.

Mr. Ormrod said he should like to offer the Company's deep sympathy with all the relatives — not only with the deceased's large family, but also with his brothers, in the great loss they had sustained. Deceased was an excellent workman, and he had seen long service in the Army, and it was sad that he should have met his death as he had, in civil employment.

The Coroner conveyed these expressions to the deceased's son, observing that the Company appreciated his father's services as a workman and also his bravery as a soldier.

The Foreman also associated himself and jury with the vote of sympathy, and said deceased was one of the men they called British heroes.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Blaney, James    Miner  
Cassidy, John    Hewer  
Casson, Thomas    Deputy  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Dockwray, John    Hewer  
Doran, William    Miner  
Hanlon, J.    Miners' Agent  
Johnston, William Henry    Surveyor  
McKenzie, Hugh    Deputy  
Ormrod, G. F.    Solicitor  
Phillips, David    Miner  
Steel, R.    Manager  
Telford, James    Shiftsman  
Telford, John    Miner  Son
Telford, William   41 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Waddington, Marmaduke    Miner  
Wilson, P., Councillor    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print