Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th October 1917

Fatal Result Of A Mining Accident At Frizington

Definition Of A Shot-Firing "Mis-Fire"

On Saturday afternoon, an inquest was held at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary by Mr. E. Atter (Coroner for West Cumberland), with reference to the death of Matthew Henry Trevaskis, 51 years of age, iron ore miner, 65, Frizington Road, Frizington, who was injured while engaged in shot-firing operations at Lonsdale Mine on August 31st, and who died in the Infirmary on Friday afternoon last. Mr. R. Wilson was foreman of the jury. There were also present: Mr. W. Leck, H. M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, on behalf the relatives; and Mr. J. D. Baxter (Messrs. Chapman and Baxter) for the Lonsdale Mining Company.

George Trevaskis, miner, Frizington Road, identified the body as that of his father. He saw him on several occasions at the Infirmary, but he made no statement to witness about the accident.

Wm. Stewart, 7, Skelsceugh Road, Winder, iron ore miner, in the employ of the Lonsdale Mining Company, said that on August 31st he saw Trevaskis several times during the shift, the last time about nine o'clock, when he was lighting the holes. He lit three fuses and one did not go off. Witness then told him that one had missed and Trevaskis turned back to light it. Witness got out of the road but deceased didn't, and he was coming away when the first shot caught him. A second shot went off while Trevaskis was lying on the ground, and there would be an interval of about a couple of minutes between the two shots. Witness had to go for a light as his was blown out. It was while he was getting another light that the second shot went off. Witness then went to Trevaskis and got him out of the road. He was conscious and complained about his back. Deceased was accustomed to firing shots and was a very careful man.

Thomas William Fell, surveyor, submitted and explained a sketch of the working. Witness said that after deceased was struck he fell about 26 feet down a steep slope.

By Mr. Duffy: Deceased was 22 feet from the shot-hole when the shot went off.

The witness Stewart, in reply to the Inspector, said Trevaskis bored the holes himself and lit the fuse with a small piece of candle. The rule, in the event of a mis-fire, was that miners had not to go back within half-an-hour. The third shot in this case was a mis-fire, and Trevaskis really should not have gone back. Witness said this was not a mis-fire. It could not be a mis-fire if the fuse had not been lit. He admitted that it was a mis-fire in one sense. It did not occur to witness at the time that it was a mis-fire.

By Mr. Duffy: The first shot struck Trevaskis. The deceased should have not gone to light the fuse again, and he did not know what made him go back.

By Mr. Baxter: It was an understood thing that men should not go back within half an hour after a mis-fire.

By the Foreman: Witness would have gone back himself in this case to light the fuse again.

Jonathan Park, Main Street, Frizington, shift deputy at Lonsdale Mine, said deceased was a very careful man in his work. He saw Trevaskis shortly after the accident, and he was then quite conscious and talked to witness for some time. Witness did not think there was any rule with regard to fuses which mis-fired. He would not have gone back if a fuse mis-fired, and he had warned men about doing that sort of thing. He had never warned Trevaskis.

By the Inspector: In the event of an ordinary mis-fire he would tell a man not to go back within half an hour.

By Mr. Duffy: Witness had been a shift deputy for twelve years. He had not seen a printed notice at the bottom of the shaft stating that in a mis-fire a man should not go back within half an hour. He had heard no complaints about the quality of the fuses. Since the outbreak of the war the character of dynamite had entirely changed. He could not say whether this applied to the quality of fuses.

Mr. Duffy, referring to some delay in the removal of the injured man to Whitehaven, said the people had to go about begging to get a little petrol for the motor ambulance, and he hoped the jury would return a rider to their verdict with respect to this. The people of the pit had worked almost expeditiously in getting Trevaskis to the surface, where he was stuck for a long time while people in Whitehaven were trying to get petrol.

Dr. Huddleston, house surgeon at the Infirmary, said the cause of death of blood poisoning, following fracture of the spine.

Thomas Williams, manager of the mine, endorsed the evidence given by other witnesses as to deceased being a careful and reliable man.

Trevaskis told him he had made a mistake by going back to the shots when he should not have done so. He said he used two and a half to three feet of fuse. Rules were posted up two of three years ago saying that men were not to return for a certain time after a shot missed fire, until the other two holes had gone off. In regard to the accident he thought there was no question of the fuse being at fault. They had been using this particular fuse for ten years. It was a cotton fuse with a powder train inside and had been satisfactory. The notice which was posted up was to the effect that in the event of mis-fire or of persons attempting to light a shot and the shot not going off, the men had not to return to the working.

It was just put up as a notice from the Company — Yes.

Asked if Trevaskis made any remark to him about the first fuse going off sooner than he expected, witness said deceased told him he thought the fuse must have lit twice — that being doubled down it must have also lit at the part nearer the neck of the hole.

By Mr. Duffy: Trevaskis was in the Infirmary when he told him he had made a mistake. There was no one else there when this conversation took place. They had no special rules governing the work.

You could get them if you wanted them? — Yes, I daresay we could.

The Inspector: I should like to have this clear. You say you don't think this was a mis-fire, and yet deceased said he had made a mistake? — Witness: He made a mistake in going back to light it the second time. He (the witness) did not call it a mis-fire unless the fuse was lit. He agreed that the notice referred to was put up with a view of preventing cases of that kind.

The Inspector said this class of accident — returning with the object of re-lighting a hole — was one of the commonest forms of explosives accidents in metalliferous mines, although recent years — the last three years especially — showed a decided improvement. It was a standing rule in this district, but only compulsory where special rules were established, although it was well known to every miner that in the case of a mis-fire nobody should return to the working within half an hour. The point was — what was a mis-fire? If the fuse "runs" but fails to explode the explosive it would, of course, be a mis-fire, but in order to secure safety the definition of a mis-fire must go beyond that. Two or three years ago a notice was posted at the iron ore mines in the district, stating that "after an attempt had been made to light a shot, and the men have left the working, if for any reason the shot fails to explode it must be treated as a mis-fire." He should also say that this point had been emphasised at least half a dozen times in the annual reports of the Chief Inspector of Mines for the district, but in this particular case, as no special rules were established at the Lonsdale Mines, the deceased was violating no statutory rules.

Mr. Duffy said the unfortunate thing was that the metalliferous miners today were governed by a worthless and obsolete Act which was passed in 1872, with the result that they could not apply anything or enforce anything. Important changes and regulations were strongly recommended in the report of the Royal Commission which sat in Cumberland some years ago, and a new Metalliferous Mines Bill had been lying in the pigeon holes of the Home Office for four years past. It was high time, therefore, that the Government made a new Act of Parliament, so that these engaged in the iron ore industry would know what to do, instead of working in the chaotic way they were doing today under an old fossilised Act.

The Coroner said valuable suggestions had been made to them by the Inspector and Mr. Gavan Duffy. With regard to the delay in taking the motor ambulance to the pit, to which Mr. Gavan Duffy had drawn attention, he invited the jury to make a recommendation that in future some arrangement should be made in order that there might be no difficulty in obtaining petrol, because it was very important in the case of a serious accident, that the injured person should be removed to the Infirmary with all possible speed. If such a recommendation were made he would see that it was communicated to the proper quarter. A further suggestion was in every way worthy of consideration and adoption was that by Mr. Leck to a rule with respect to a mis-fire. Mr. Gavan Duffy went into an older grievance, but he (the Coroner) was afraid that if he and others associated with him, who were a very strong party in the House of Commons and elsewhere had not been able to obtain redress in regard to the Metalliferous Mines Act, the jury would not be able to do it and it would be useless to offer any suggestion on that. He thought what Mr. Duffy stated was good common-sense, and if he and others concerned kept hammering away it would in all probability have some good effect by and by.

The jury returned a verdict that Trevaskis died from blood poisoning caused by a broken spine, which injury was occasioned by his having been accidentally hit by a shot while engaged at his work in the Lonsdale Mine. The jury also strongly recommended that provision should be made for petrol to be kept on hand for the use of the motor ambulance in case of accident; also that the rule should be made with regard to shot-firing on the lines suggested by the Inspector.

Mr. Baxter, on behalf of the employers expressed their sympathy with the widow and relatives of the deceased and to this Mr. Gavan Duffy replied.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Baxter, J. D.    Solicitor  
Chapman, —    Solicitor  
Fell, Thomas William    Surveyor  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Huddleston, —, Dr.    House Surgeon  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Park, Jonathan    Deputy  
Stewart, William    Miner  
Trevaskis, George    Miner  Son
Trevaskis, Matthew Henry   51 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Williams, Thomas    Manager  
Wilson, R.    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Lonsdale (Iron Ore)  Lonsdale (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print