20th September 1917
The Iron Ore Miners' Dispute
(To The Editor Of The Whitehaven News.)
Sir, — Without in any way interfering with the internal affairs of the Cumberland Iron Ore Miners' and Kindred Trades' Association (that very able and energetic body being quite capable of digesting its own war bread), I think it would be doing
only bare justice to the public to re-inform them upon certain points, which have of late been misrepresented to them by master and man. Here let me point out that there are ways and means within the Union itself of airing grievances and remedying any
real or fancied breach of rules, without bringing oneself within the searchlight of the D.O.R.A., or endangering the reputation a respectable newspaper. [Thanks. — Ed., W.N.]
So, it is to the outside public I address myself. The public has been led to believe that the Union has done nothing for the surface workers. Here are the facts: —
Some six months ago many of the non-Union surface hands, seeing; the advantages which the C.I.O.M. and K T.A. had acquired for the miners, decided to overcome their natural timidity in connection with such matters, and joined the Union. There was no
risk in doing so; in fact; many of them had been advised to do so by the "bosses" themselves. Their average rate of pay before the war was less than 5s 4d per shift.
An analysis of the lodge books of my own lodge reveals the following equations: —
The average contribution of the surface workers amounts to less than 10s per man.
Contributions refunded through loss of work during strike averages 24s per man, which is double the amount paid in.
A war bonus of 6s per week for 32 weeks — £8 per man — and 1s per day, with a minimum of 10d per day in two months from now, makes an in-crease of 2s 8d, or 50 per cent. "on the pre-war average of 5s 4d per shift.
In other words the Union has paid back in contributions 14s more than they, the surface workers, ever paid into the funds of the Union, and secured them a minimum advance of 16s per week.
The Council did not ask these men to remain content with such increases — (although they are considerably in advance of demands submitted on their behalf from the body of the hall at a mass meeting of surface workers held at Moor Row). But
immediately with the approval of the Government, set up machinery whereby there individual grievances could be inquired into and remedied.
Let me remind the surface workers that it was their low, miserable, non-Union pre-war — standard which stood in the way of a further wage increase. With all due respect to your estimable paper Mr. Editor, whose forte is agriculture and not mining,
I venture the tip that if the surface worker back the "Whitehaven News" and does not put his shilling on the Union, he is backing the wrong dog, [Very good. mdash; Ed., W.N.]
Saying harsh things of one another will advance neither side, but let remind the surface workers that those now in. authority in the Union are men who have had long years of experience in the cause of the iron ore workers, who have suffered many
privations on their behalf, and have endured endless persecutions, some petty, some tragic, in defence of their principles, and who are now willing to leave the old antiquated methods industrial warfare, and are prepared to consider the relations of the
higher Trade Unionism to the economic advancement of the community. Therefore, we should like to warn our raw recruits the eleventh-hour ones, the rearguard of the advance, that if they resort to unconstitutional attacks and anonymous scurrility, they,
being the weaker body, will be worsted; in the words of Shelley —
"They will be pursuing O blind and willing slave, their own obscure undoing."
The other thing, Mr. Editor, to which I wish to draw public attention, is contained in the speech of Sir John Randles<.b>, the head of the "Combine," at the annual meeting of the shareholders held at Workington, wherein he suggests that the
Government was responsible for the recent strike of iron ore workers.
I cannot think that Sir John wilfully mislead the public in this matter, and I am forced to the alternative supposition, that he as been totally misinformed upon the whole subject. To go thoroughly into the divers deliberations between the
C.I.O.M., the owners, and the Government, would fill up two or three editions of the "Whitehaven News," so I will relate only the main issue. [Again, Thanks. — Ed., W.N.]
In my evidence before the Royal Commission on Metalliferous Mines, which. sat at Egremont, I commented upon the unsatisfactory working: of the present haphazard and partial manner in which labourers were put in full and I there suggested a service
.period as a remedy. Mr. Jones; a member of that Commission, who was strongly in favour of the appeal, promised to me his heartiest support to its inclusion into the recommendations of the Commission.
This proposal was made the subject of a demand by the men which was to be submitted to the "Combine Board" of which Sir John himself is the head War broke out, I think, the day before the meeting, so the whole matter was, by mutual consent,
shelved until a more, opportune time.
The conditions consequent of the war, however, further aggravated the position of the labourers (some of whom, by the way had already "laboured" for five to ten years). "Full men" returned to the mines from the counter, farm, and
beer-shop, while on the other hand" the supply of young labour coming into the mines was restrict by the recruiting officer.
The agitation at last became; so strong that the Council was compelled to take action, and a further demand for a fixed period of labouring was made.
According to the rules of the" Conciliation Boards which both the owners and ourselves pledged, these demands ought to have been discussed with the owners in full Board, and failing an agreement the matter to be left in the hands of the Neutral
Chairman whose decision would be final.
But instead of acting in this constitutional manner, the owners immediately threw themselves into the arms of the Ministry of Munitions to receive and embrace which is fast becoming a bear hug. We did not want to meet the Ministry, we do not want to
meet the Ministry now, we would rather meet our own owners in a square, stand up, fight and be beaten, than to get unworkable conditions from the Ministry over their heads. Some of us, at least, are not idle agitators or sedition mongers; we desire to
see set up in the iron ore trade and industrial pence resting upon the sure foundation or a working class contentment born of equitable remuneration for honest endeavour, and righteous reward for individual effort.
We submitted the fairly reasonable proposal of for a time service for "Labours"; no argument was used against such a proposal but the prehistoric argument of "You won't get it." Many of the advocates of the terms contained in the
proposals could have made out some case against them, but the absence of such a case, appears to support the conclusion that there was no brief because there was no lawyer.
The Ministry received the proposals with sympathetic consideration, but I had the personal testimony of at least two prominent gentlemen in the Ministry that they were entirely in sympathy with our suggestions; but it was evident that the Ministry had
taken control of the mines with their hands tied. This was the opinion of the majority of the Council, and this goaded them into the advocacy of a strike.
I am afraid, Mr. Editor, through having to condense the subject, that I may not have represented the position of our Council at all adequately but I hope I have written enough to show that Sir John's suggestion that the Government was responsible for the
strike is an entire misrepresentation of the whole position.
Far from being the cause of the strike they have proved themselves to be fairly successful mediators, and it only remains for the owners to re-establish the old feeling of friendly rivalry which characterised our dealings with one another in the last
seven years of industrial peace, and eliminate the chaff from the wheat of the last agreement by a careful and unprejudicial consideration of time service for Labourers, that we may work together, masters and men, to give our industry a sure footing in
the new and strange economic world which will come to us after the war.
We hear vague rumours of the terrible clash of interests which is going to happen after the war. Let the masters and men of the iron ore industry circumvent any such disaster by manfully facing many of the difficulties beforehand, and let "give and
take" leave us strong for the storm. — Yours, &c.,
Charles Edmonds.
President. C.I.O.M. and K.T.A.
Dalzell-Street, Moor Row, Sept. 23rd, 1917.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.
 |
 |
|
Names mentioned in this article
|
 |
 |
| Name | Age | Occupation | Notes |
| Edmonds, Charles | | President | |
| Jones, — | | | |