Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th July 1917

Fatality At Buckhill Colliery

Strong Rider By The Jury

On Saturday afternoon, at the Workington Infirmary, Mr. E. Atter, Coroner for West Cumberland, and a jury of which Mr. G. Cheeseman was chosen foreman, held an inquest touching the death of Ernest McVay (27), single, which occurred at the institution on Friday night. The deceased resided with his mother at Derwent Row, Broughton Cross. On the 7th inst., while following his employment at the Buckhill Colliery belonging to the Allerdale Coal Company Ltd., as an apprentice coal hewer with a man named John Black, at 12-30 noon there was a fall of roof in the working which injured the deceased's back and legs. Black took deceased on to the trail road from where with assistance he was removed to the surface of the pit. There first aid was rendered by Robert McFarland, undermanager. After being removed to his home where he was attended to by Dr. Syme the deceased was conveyed to the Workington Infirmary.

There were present :— Mr. George Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Whitehaven; Mr. Tom Cape, Miners' Agent; Mr. John Wilson, manager of the Buckhill Colliery.

George McVay, miner, Broughton Cross, brother of the deceased, identified the body. Witness had worked at the Buckhill Pit. His brother had been hewing about twelve months. Witness had been working at the pit four years. He was not working on the 7th. His brother was in good health on the 7th. Witness saw his brother at home after the accident and said it was an accident that could not be helped, and that a big stone had fallen on his back. He blamed no one. Witness had been in the same working, and he considered it was a safe place while he was in it.

His brother had worked in the pit since he was 14 years of age. After the accident he went to the same working where more timber had been put in. This was two days after the accident.

Can you say why the timbering was not done systematically — that is certain distances apart? — No.

Mr. Wilson, manager, submitted a plan of the working. The stone which fell on the deceased was four foot long, 18 inches wide, and 6 inches thick. The weight would be about four cwts, which hit the deceased. The other portion of the stone was broken into small pieces of metal. There was only 2ft 9ins from the floor to the roof, the props were in a semi-circle and not in a straight line as shown on the plan.

By the Inspector: The maximum distance allowed between the props was four feet. Those props were outside the distance.

By the Coroner: There is a good deal of variance. The rule has not been carried out.

Witness: Not in this particular instance they had not done so. The deputy inspected the place.

The Coroner: Someone is to blame. Will you let us know who? It was examined by the deputy.

The Coroner: Who is to blame? — The man who propped the place.

By Mr. Cape: It was a three-quarter roof and slippery.

The Foreman wanted to know if the plan was incorrect in any other respect.

Mr. Wilson said it was not.

The brother of the deceased, recalled by the Inspector, said he could not say why the props were not put in at the proper distance. He was aware of the rules but was not there when the props were set.

Dr. Robinson deposed he saw the deceased last Sunday. He was suffering from fracture of the spine, causing paralysis of the lower limbs and the bladder due to a fall of rock. It was not a hopeless case, but still it was serious.

By the Foreman: The injury would not be much aggravated by his removal. It might have been made worse if he were improperly carried.

John Black, miner, Greysouthen, deposed he had worked over 20 years at the Buckhill Colliery. He had worked odd shifts with the deceased. The accident happened at twelve o'clock, as near as he could tell. There was no warning. The place had been sounded twenty minutes previously. He found the stone on the deceased. It was right on his back. Witness loosened it. Deceased asked him for a sup of water, and he gave it to him. Witness then got the assistance of Ostle, Thompson, and Bone, and they carried the deceased 200 yards before they got a stretcher.

By the Inspector: This was not witness's working place. He was not hewing in the loose side of the place that day. He didn't know if any timber was set in the loose side.

The Inspector: What was the timber like in the loose side? — It was well wooded. The roof was strong.

The Inspector: It is a bad roof generally? — Yes.

Was not there a man with a broken leg in that district a fortnight before? — Yes; they took the man in a metal bogie.

Would it not have been better to have got the stretcher? — Yes.

By Mr. Cape: He thought the place was well propped and safe. The deputy had been through the place that morning and passed it as safe. He didn't know where the stretcher was kept. He saw the deputy, who went for the stretcher, whilst they were carrying the deceased out as well as they could. An hour would elapse after the accident before the deceased was got home.

By Mr. Wilson: They didn't withdraw a single prop from the place. Five feet was a reasonable distance for the props to be from the face.

If there had been more props in this particular place, would it have prevented the fall? — I could not say. It would have been better if he had gone for the deputy at once after the accident instead of acting as they did. He knew the rule about props and their distance apart.

By the Foreman: The deceased was lying on his back in the bogie. It would be two or three miles from the colliery to the deceased's home.

By a Juryman: The bogie was flat and four feet in length.

By the Coroner: The deputy never spoke to him about putting more props in at this place.

Robert McFarland, undermanager, living at Buckhill, said he had held the post for two years. On the 7th he was at the pit top. He heard of it at 1.15, and saw him coming up the pit. The ambulance was ready for the deceased. He told the witness that his back was injured. He examined the place afterwards — on the Monday. Nothing had been removed. He gave instructions to the officials that nothing had to be tampered with. When he saw it on the Monday one prop was loose five feet back from the stone. He last saw the place before the accident on the 29th of June in company with the Inspector. There was no report in the book that it had not been sufficiently timbered.

By the Inspector: On the Monday he considered the place looked bad. More props could have been put in at some points without interfering with the safety of the place. He tried to visit the whole of the working places once a week.

The Inspector: In this case you had not been in for a fortnight? — Yes. The condition of the roof at the present time was only moderate. Previously out of ten places he had had to complain of four in regard to shortage of timber.

Mr. Cape: Do you think you gave that particular place proper supervision? — Yes.

Black is a man of good experience? — Yes, I don't ................................................., Missing section........................................ day of the accident.

By Mr. Wilson: There was no indication of any slip until the roof fell.

Mr. Wilson: As regards the place, could more perhaps have been put in between the last row and the face without interfering with the work? — No.

The Coroner: You gave a different answer to that which you gave the Inspector.

Witness: I said at some points.

Mr. Wilson: What did you really understand Mr. Cook's question to apply to?

Witness: To the whole length of the place.

Mr. Wilson: In that particular place where the other accident occurred was that not very closely timbered? — Yes.

A good deal more closely than the rule requires? — Yes.

And still the accident occurred with the other man? — Yes.

By the Foreman: The deputies reported when a place was insufficiently timbered, but he had not had a report from them.

The Coroner: Why have you not?

Witness: It is the duty of the inspector to make them men put the timber in and then to report them to me.

By the Foreman: If it had been timbered right up to the face the man couldn't have worked at that particular place.

George Webster, Great Broughton, deputy at the colliery, deposed he saw the deceased before the accident. He examined the place and was quite satisfied it was safe. This was just before the accident occurred at a quarter to twelve o'clock.

By the Inspector: The loose side of the place was approaching a fault therefore he had more timber put in it and watched it carefully. He could not put more timber in at the face to allow the work to be done.

More than four foot six inches?

Witness: Yes, I think the timber could have been put nearer. If they'd had a prop under the stone which fell he couldn't see how they'd have got the coal out.

The Coroner: Have you ever reported any places being insufficiently timbered? — No, sir.

By Mr. Cape: Plenty of timber was always provided in that district.

By Mr. Wilson: The district on the day of the accident was not left without a deputy. He had never replied to his questions that places were not sufficiently timbered. This was the first fatal accident from a fall of roof since the pit had worked.

By the Coroner: He didn't take notice that props in the place were outside the regular distance.

Mr. Wilson was then cross-examined by the Inspector, saying he could not explain why four out of the ten places referred to were not propped up. He took the deputy's word for it. The rules at the pithead gave the distance at which the props had to be set and at the working face. He expected these rules were carried out by both the men and the officials; and if they were not carried out that they be reported to him.

Mr. Cape: The deputy ought to see that the props are put in before he came out of the place?

The Inspector: Yes.

The Coroner, in summing up, said what had been disclosed by the inquiry was not altogether satisfactory. It seemed from a good deal of it that some remedy was required. He suggested more attention should be given to the places that required to be wooded. There was also the question whether the accident would have been prevented if the propping had been more systematically done. It was not outside the inquiry for the jury to give any recommendation providing a remedy. If there had been any violation of the rules that was a matter for another place.

The jury returned a verdict of accidental death, and stated. (1) We are strongly of the opinion that the place was insufficiently timbered, and that the supervision generally had been lax. (2) They are also of the opinion that the evidence given at the inquiry, excepting the doctor's, and that of George McVay, was very unsatisfactory. (3) They are further of the opinion that the injured man after having been liberated from the stone should not have been further removed until a stretcher had been brought for the purpose.

Mr. J. Wilson expressed the sympathy of the colliery at the unfortunate loss of this estimable young man with the bereaved family.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Black, John    Miner  
Black, John    Miner  
Bone, —    Miner  
Cape, Tom    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Cheeseman, G.    Jury Foreman  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
McFarland, Robert    Under Manager  Whos Who Page
McKay, George    Miner  Brother
McVay, Ernest   27 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Ostle, —    Miner  
Robinson, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Syme, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Thompson, —    Miner  
Webster, George    Deputy  
Wilson, John    Manager  Whos Who Page



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Buckhill Colliery  Buckhill Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print