|
19th July 1917 Fatality At Ladysmith PitOn Friday an inquest was formally opened at Turner's Cafe, Preston Street, Whitehaven, by Mr. Atter (coroner), touching the death of George Ivison Burney, 58, married, 19, Castle Row, Newhouses, colliery shiftsman. Late on Wednesday night, while deceased was following his employment in the pit, a large piece of stone fell upon him, crushed him terribly about the face and body, and killed him apparently instantly. The inquest was adjourned for the presence of H.M. Inspector until Saturday morning. The adjourned inquest was held at the Magistrate's Courthouse, on Saturday by Mr. E. Atter (coroner). Councillor Mr. R. Wilson was foreman of the jury. Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines; Mr. O. F. Ormrod, who appeared for the Whitehaven Colliery Company; and Mr. J. Hanlon, CC, miner's agent, who represented the relatives of the deceased, were also present. Mr. W. H. Johnston, surveyor of the Colliery Company, produced and explained a plan of the locality in the pit where the accident occurred. The stone which fell on the deceased, he said, was 4ft wide at one end and 3ft 6in at the other end; and it was 7ft long, and 6in thick. In reply to the Inspector, witness said no timber was found where the stone was. Bowness Hailes, Sandwith, night deputy at Ladysmith Pit, said Burney was working under his charge, and he gave him directions about 10.30 on Wednesday night. There had been a fall of coal on the main road, and he told deceased to go for two men to put some timber in the place. There was plenty of timber. The accident happened about 20 minutes to twelve. Witness sounded the place with a hammer, at 10.30, and it seemed quite safe and good. When witness arrived at the place after the accident deceased had been got out. Tom Bethwaite and John Sewell, the men he had told to timber, were there. By the Inspector: The fall that he found at 10.30 was top coal. He had the rope stopped. The roof sounded well. About 15cwt of coal had fallen four or five feet. It was a new fall. There was no coal left between the two girders. Coal had fallen there at some other time, but had been cleared away. No timber was put in after the first fall. The place was quiet when witness left, and he started the rope. The rope would be running all the time Burney was there, and if there had been any movement of the roof he could not have heard it, though his hearing was good. Witness was not responsible for examining the roadway. The overman made out the reports with regard to the roads. By Mr. Hanlon: The back shift overman passed on Burney to his work that night. Burney was making ready to work when witness first saw him. Witness examined the place when Burney came out. The ground was very faulty in that district. He had no instructions from the manager that systematic timbering should be carried out there. He told Burney to go for two men, and that they were to assist him, and he was to shift the coal while they were timbering. Burney was a good workman and a reliable man. There was shot-firing in this district, and he agreed that that was always liable to disturb ground of that kind. He had not time to attend to the roads, and that was, therefore, done by the overman. By Mr. Ormrod: Witness signed the report for the workings — for the whole condition of the working places and the road. The Coroner observed that witness had told the Inspector that he did not make the reports; and that he did not think witness's evidence had been very satisfactory. Mr. Ormrod produced a report, signed by the witness, that all was safe except the roof in the Jubilee Engine Plane, where the accident happened; and Mr. Ormrod asked the witness whether he ever made any complaint that he had not time to do his work properly. Witness said he had not. John Sewell, South Row, Kells, said he had been employed at Ladysmith about 20 years. He and Bethwaite were asked to take some timber in. Witness took a shovel and gave it to Burney to clear some coal away. By the Inspector: Witness was inbye when the last witness came to see him about the timbering. There was no fall on the roadway when he went in. After giving the shovel to Burney witness went in for some timber and was about 20 minutes away. When he returned he found that the place had fallen. He had not done any work on the roadway before. Witness saw Burney's light shining underneath the stone which had fallen, and he concluded that Burney was also under the stone. Burney was dead when they got him out. By Mr. Hanlon: They had to go about 50 yards inbye witness's place for the timber. By Mr. Turner (one of the jury): The rope was running when the signal were down. Mr. Turner said that was a dangerous practice, as a man who was working there could not hear if the roof was moving. By the Coroner: Burney's left leg was broken and his face was terribly disfigured; his head was smashed in. Thomas Bethwaite, North Row, Kells, a collier at Ladysmith Pit, who said he worked for the Colliery Co. for 22 years, gave evidence corroborating that of Sewell. William Robson, manager of Ladysmith Pit, said he saw the place before and also after the accident; and he replied to the Coroner that in his opinion it was sufficiently propped and timbered. The roof coal was sufficiently good, but it might have got a little bit shaken. He did not before the accident see any indication of danger. It had been reported safe in their reports every day by the deputies, and the overmen; and the place had been carefully, as far as witness knew. — Is it Hailes' duty to examine and make a report? — He takes charge of the district in beyond the meeting station. — Do you agree with the evidence he has given? — Yes, with the exception of the statement that he has not time to do his work. I have had no complaint from him or from any of the other officials in the same district. The Coroner said it might be a serious matter for the workmen if a man said he had no time to do the work, and the work was neglected. Witness, he understood, said he had had no notification about this? Witness: None whatever, and he has signed his reports all right. I would naturally take it that things are all right when he has signed them, because we take it to be a true report. He would not have been more than eight hours on a shift. Is there more work for him to do in these eight hours than he is capable of doing? — I don't think so. I think he has ample time to do it in. In reply to the Inspector, witness said he had been manager of Ladysmith for five weeks; and he could not say why the timber was left out. He agreed that it would have been better if it had been timbered; it would have saved this. It was timbered on each side. With regard to the rope running while men were working, it could have been stopped; he did not think it would make any difference to the work inbye. No tubs could have gone past. As to the deputy Hailes, saying it was not his duty to make examination, the meeting station is at the pit bottom, and all points beyond the meeting station must be examined by the deputy. By Mr. Hanlon: He had given no instructions to officials since he went to Ladysmith Pit. The duties of the deputies were to examine the district under their charge, and see that there was sufficient timber for safety, and also to attend to shot firing. The overman visited the district every day. When Hailes stopped the rope and examined the roof, witness thought Hailes was quite satisfied that the place was safe and he would accordingly send for the men to put the timber in. You don't know of any arrangement being made to relieve deputies, when they have all this extra work to do? — Witness repeated that he had never had any complaints about deputies having too much work to do. The Coroner, addressing the jury, said the inquiry to his mind was not quite satisfactory, inasmuch as it disclosed something wrong with regard to Hailes. Hailes was either not acquainted with what his duties were, or he was not performing them. It was suggested that he had too much work to do, although he signed the reports; but he had not made any complaints that he had not time to do his work. Surely, if he had not sufficient time he should have said so to the officials, so that the work should be sufficiently and efficiently done, for the protection of the workmen. In such a case it would be most wrongful not to do so. Now that the matter had been mentioned, the question would no doubt be investigated by the management. There did not seem to be any blame attached to anyone for Burney's death. The jury returned a verdict that Burney was killed by a fall of stone, and recommended that in future in such a case, the rope should be stopped. Mr. Ormrod said he would convey the recommendation to the Company, and he asked Mr. Hanlon if he would kindly convey the Colliery Company's sympathy to the relatives of Mr. Burney. Mr. Hanlon said he would be very pleased to do so.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||