Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

3rd May 1917

Fatal Result Of Accident At Whitehaven

Parton Man's Death

On Monday afternoon, Mr. E. Atter, coroner, held an inquest at the Whitehaven Infirmary upon the death of Michael Joseph Fowler, of Parton, who had died at the Infirmary as the result of injuries sustained in William Pit, Whitehaven, on the 23rd April. Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector, was present. Mr. O. F. Ormrod (of the firm Messrs Brockbank, Helder and Ormrod) represented the Whitehaven Colliery Company Ltd., and Councillor J. Hanlon, C.C., deceased's widow and relatives. Mr. R. Steel (the general works manager) and Mr. G. Emerson (manager of William Pit), were also present. Councillor Wilson was foreman of the jury.

Mrs. Mary Jane Fowler, deceased's widow, stated that she lived at 30, Bank Yard, Parton. Her late husband was a collier, and was 43 years of age. Deceased had worked at this pit for three years, and had always enjoyed good health. On Monday week he left home between 9.30 and a quarter to ten in the morning to go to his work. Deceased had never made any complaint with reference to his work. About a quarter past seven in the evening when witness was passing the pit she heard of the accident. She saw her husband at the Infirmary, but he never made any statement to her. He only said he wished he was better and at home again for the children. She had four children dependant upon her, the eldest being 12 years of age.

The Coroner said he was extremely sorry for witness.

Replying to the Inspector, Mrs. Fowler said her husband had worked in the pits at Durham and also at Asby, for about 16 years.

William Henry Johnston, surveyor, produced a plan of the haulage road. The accident, he explained, was caused by four tubs breaking away, and crushing deceased between a sett of ten tubs.

By the Inspector: He had been told there were ten tubs on the full sett.

By Mr. Hanlon: The gradient was 1 in 28.

By Mr. Ormrod: The distance between the tubs and the side of the haulage road was two feet.

James Robson, hewer, of 51, Main Street, Hensingham, stated that he had worked for the Whitehaven Colliery Co., for 47 years at William Pit. He had known Fowler for about 18 months, and deceased had worked with him for that time. On Monday week they were on the back shift. He descended the pit with deceased, and they commenced work about 12.30 noon, and finished about ten minutes past six at night. They then came outbye, two other men being close behind them. A lad named Albert O'Pray met them, and stated that he was going inbye for some more tubs. Shortly afterwards he heard some tubs coming, and shouted to Fowler to get out of the road; but the latter never spoke. Witness thought deceased heard him shout: he was all right as regards his hearing. The other two men got into a manhole, and witness threw himself into an empty tub. Fowler, who never saw anything, was caught by the tubs. The manhole was about three yards behind deceased. They never heard any one shout as regards runaway tubs, but they heard the tubs coming. Three or four were got to the deceased together, and backed the full sett off him. The tubs were against deceased, who was standing, and when released he fell on his back. The tubs had caught Fowler about the small of the back.

Replying to the Inspector, Robson said four of them were coming out together.

Had you all lights? — No, Fowler had no light.

Whereabouts was he? — First or second? — In front of us.

How long had he been without a light? — Mebbe about three-quarters of an hour.

What had caused him to get in the dark? — I cannot say.

Did he go and seek another lamp at all? — No, when he came in this was the last tub they were fetching in.

That was when he lost his lamp? — Yes.

And he did not go and seek another? — No, we were finished then, and we both came out together with a tub.

Replying further to the Inspector, witness said they first saw O'Pray at the end of the sett going in. Fowler was leading, and in the dark; deceased might have seen the manhole if he had had a light. Fowler was close up against full sett when they heard the tubs coming. Witness threw himself into an empty tub on his back.

The Inspector asked if it would not have been better, deceased having no light, if he had been placed in between them, and witness said deceased left his work first and they caught up with him. They had finished their shift, and were not a bit late in leaving.

Asked if there was any rule stating that men had not to go down there until the road is clear, witness replied that he didn't know that. He had never been kept back behind the full tubs until the road was clear.

Have you ever come out when there has been tubs on both sides of the road? — Yes.

Was the rope running at the time? — Yes, but they generally try to keep the road clear if it is possible. The tub was the best place for him to get into.

By Mr. Hanlon: He remembered how the tubs were standing on that day — on other days the road was generally clear. He had no idea that the haulage hand was going to hang on behind. Asked if Fowler ran up against the full sett expecting the road to be clear, witness said no. They heard the tubs coming amain, and he got into an empty sett, the two men into a manhole, while Fowler went forward. He couldn't say if deceased knew the full sett was there, but witness could see it.

The Inspector: But you had a light.

By Mr. Hanlon: There would have been danger if the tubs had not run away. Deceased did not say anything. He had asked deceased where his light was, and he replied that it had gone out. They then filled the tubs and came away.

By Mr. Ormrod: The tubs would be about 20 yards away when they first heard them. He then shouted.

Did you get into the empty tub yourself before the accident happened to this man?

Witness said a full tub caught his feet and knocked him into the tub.

Then it happened at the same time practically as you got into the tub? — Yes.

Witness said he shouted to Fowler before the tubs came.

By the Foreman: The tubs were not coming so very fast, but deceased was a man who was very slow on foot.

The Coroner inquired if Fowler could not have got another lamp, or had he any means to re-light it?

Witness said they were finished and coming out. The lamp had been out three-quarters of an hour.

The Coroner said it was for their safety that they should have a lamp, and witness said he was shining his lamp as they went along. It was not worth while getting another lamp when they were coming away.

By the Inspector: Deceased could have got another lamp at the lamp station.

By the Foreman: The lamp station was about a quarter of a mile away.

Albert O'Pray, haulage hand, of 6, Dixon's Square, Ginns, Whitehaven, stated that he had been working at William Pit for 12 weeks, and was 17 years of age. On the 23rd April he saw Fowler and his mate, Robson, coming by the full tubs. He also saw William Ross and another man, and he told Ross to get out of the road. Fowler and Robson were in front, and he didn't speak to them. Asked why he didn't give the same advice to the other men, witness said he thought they would give them word to get out of the road. He told Ross to get out of the road, and that he was going to bring the tubs down to make the sett up. All the men had got by when the rope gave a sudden rift and the tubs ran amain. He ran to tell the men, and two of them got into No. 16 manhole, two into tubs, but deceased could not get out of the way.

By the Inspector: Fowler and Robson were in front of witness, and the former was standing at the full tubs at the time he passed him. He was preparing to bring the tubs down. The rope was standing at the time. There would be about ten yards between the full tubs and the empty tubs. He shouted that the tubs were on the run. The men would get outbye eight or nine yards before the rope started. The rope gave a rift and slipped through the clutch. They had instructions to the effect that this road had to be clear when the men were riding.

Did anyone tell you to keep these roads clear? — No.

You have got instructions now, I suppose? — Yes.

You generally left the roads clear? — Yes.

Can you prevent any man — have you authority to prevent any man travelling beyond the tubs when you are bringing them out? — Yes, when I told the first man I thought he would have told the other lot.

It would be just as easy for you to have told the other men, and you did not do that? — No.

By Mr. Hanlon: When he went inbye he did not know the ten tubs were uncoupled. He told Ross because he wanted him to stand by the empties until he got the tubs down. He knew there was no by-pass on this road. He did his best to get the road clear when the men were coming out.

By Mr. Ormrod: He was in charge of the ten tubs but he didn't know they were uncoupled. He was supposed to find this out for himself. He had not got the clutch properly fast when the rope started and the tubs got loose.

By the Inspector: He had to come past the whole of the tubs to go inbye, and didn't see that the tubs were uncoupled.

By Mr. Ormrod: If the tubs had been properly clipped to the rope they would not have run away, and only travelled at the speed of the rope.

The Coroner: Have the orders been altered? — Have you had some orders given to you since this accident happened what you have to do? — Yes.

When did you get these orders? — The day after.

Who gave them to you? — I saw it on the pit top.

Did anyone tell you to see the notice? — No.

The Inspector explained that the notice referred to was put there on his recommendation after the accident.

Matthew Willans, hewer, Peter Street, Whitehaven, stated that when coming out of the pit on the 23rd April, along with Ross, they met O'Pray, who said he was going for some tubs. He heard the tubs coming, and ran and shoved Ross and another young man into a manhole out of the road. The next thing he saw was that Fowler was fast with the tubs. Witness shouted, but he thought Fowler did not hear him.

By the Inspector: He saw Fowler when he was coming out. At first he was walking side by side with them, but when they heard the tubs coming he was about 20 or 30 yards in front. When O'Pray warned him about the tubs, they were following the sett out. Fowler would not hear what O'Pray said. Fowler, who was in front, could see by the light of their lamps.

The Inspector: Yes, but as soon as you got into the side he would be left in the dark. If he had had a light could he have got into the refuge hole?

Witness: No; he would have had to come back.

He was past the refuge hole at the time? — Yes.

Witness added that the roads were generally clear when they came out.

By Mr. Hanlon: He heard the tubs coming and shouted "Look out." They were following the full tubs out. Fowler was near the full tubs at the time.

By Mr. Ormrod: The ten tubs were not in motion when the accident occurred, but they were moving when witness and the other men were coming out, a minute or so before the accident. If they had only four tub lengths all of them could have got out of the way.

By the Foreman: He would have had no chance of escaping if he had been in the same position as Fowler.

Dr. Pratt stated that deceased was brought to the infirmary on Monday the 23rd April, and he saw him about seven o'clock in the evening. He was in an extreme collapsed condition and had a bad compound fracture of the right leg. His collapse was really very profound, and he seemed to have some internal injury. He was conscious in a way — as a matter of fact he never from the time he came in got back to be fully conscious. Deceased died on Saturday, the 28th April, never rallying from the original collapse. It was a very serious accident from the first. The cause of death was internal injury, compound fracture of the right leg, and shock. These injuries were quite consistent with the evidence he had heard. He presumed the tubs must have come into contact with his back.

Harry Bewick, of Kells, a deputy at William Pit for between 2½ and three years, stated that he knew the deceased, whose hearing was all right, and he was also well able to take care of himself. At the time of the accident witness was about 60 or 70 yards away. He had seen the lad O'Pray who was doing his work under witness's orders and direction. When the rope stopped the ten tubs had uncoupled themselves. In consequence of this accident a notice had been put up that all the roads had to be clear. That had always been the rule, and he felt sure that he had told O'Pray. It was an important rule and so far as he knew it had always been obeyed. He had never had to caution anyone. Since the accident he had given instructions to O'Pray and the three other lads. O'Pray was the youngest, but there was little difference in the lads' ages.

The Inspector: Have you at any time before found these roads not clear when men have been travelling in or out? — When there has generally been a road by.

Witness said there would be about two feet between the two sets of rails all the way through when he first went there about twelve months ago. Fowler could have obtained another lamp at the lamp station, which was perhaps a quarter of a mile from where he was working.

By Mr. Hanlon: Any of the lads would have got Fowler a lamp. He had never known a lad to refuse. The road was renewed nearly every week. He had given instructions for the roads to be kept clear. He didn't see the men coming out at the time of the accident.

By Mr. Ormrod: There had been a considerable amount of brushing done during the last 14 months, and they were then engaged widening the road.

Mr. Ormrod: They were engaged improving so to speak this haulage road? — Yes.

Mr. G. Emerson, manager of William Pit, Whitehaven, said after careful inspection by the Inspector and himself on the day following the accident, the Inspector made a recommendation that he should post up a notice at the pit top that the road must be kept clear. He carried out the Inspector's recommendation right away, so that there would not be any time lost. The notice was to the following effect, "In six-quarters seam when men are travelling either the empty side or the full side must be kept clear." This order must be strictly adhered to, and signed by himself as manager. Continuing, Mr. Emerson said it had always been understood ever since they had a double road, and so much "crush" going on which brings the roads together, it had always been understood that one road must be kept clear. There was no rule, but it was understood amongst the officials. There was no drifting. Overmen and deputies had spoken to the lads from time to time as to keeping the roads clear. The only way he could account for the accident was the rope starting in a sudden manner, and this had caused the tubs to become uncoupled. From what he had gathered, this was quite a pure accident.

By the Inspector: Prior to Wednesday the instructions to the boys were verbal. This road during the last two years had been "ripped" through about four times.

By Mr. Hanlon: A bogie behind would have held the tubs. These tubs it appeared had got away very quickly. Lockings were there if the lad had wanted them.

The Coroner having addressed the jury, a verdict that deceased had died from "Internal injury, compound fracture of the right leg, and shock occasioned by his having been accidentally crushed by a set of wagons in William Pit, Whitehaven," was returned, the recommendation of the Inspector being left to the manager to comply with.

Mr. Emerson said he would do his utmost to see the recommendation of the Inspector was carried out. Mr. Ormrod expressed the sympathy of the Company to the widow of deceased and her family at the great loss they had sustained, and asked Mr. Hanlon to convey these expressions to her.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Bewick, Harry    Deputy  
Brockbank, —    Solicitor  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Emmerson, George    Manager  Whos Who Page
Fowler, Mary Jane, Mrs.      Widow
Fowler, Michael Joseph   43 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Hanlon, J., Councillor    For relatives  
Helder, —    Solicitor  
Johnston, William Henry    Surveyor  
O'Pray, Albert    Haulage Hand  
Ormrod, O. F.    Solicitor  
Pratt, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Robson, James    Hewer  
Ross, William    Miner  
Steel, Robert    Works Manager  Whos Who Page
Willans, Matthew    Hewer  
Wilson, —, Councillor    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery
William Colliery  William Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print