|
17th April 1917 Fatal Termination Of Mining AccidentJohn Tutty, 51 years of age, iron ore miner, 123 Bowthorn Road, Cleator Moor, died at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary on Wednesday morning week, as the result of severe injuries received some weeks, ago by a fall of roof where he was working in Mowbray Pit. Inquest Mr. Atter, Coroner, held an inquest at the Infirmary, on Thursday afternoon. Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector; Mr. J. Auld, representing the Workington Iron and Steel Co., the employers of the deceased; and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, representing the relatives of the deceased, were present. James Tutty, son of the deceased, identified the body. His father was 50 years of age and worked at the Mowbray Mine and so did witness. Witness worked in his father's company, but was not present in his working (No. 5) at the time of the accident. Witness was on the dip top and heard moaning and went and saw his father lifted and laid at the dip bottom. Witness did not know how his father was injured. He was brought to the Infirmary by the ambulance in about two hours after the accident. Witness would be about 100 yards away when he heard the moaning. Witness knew nothing about the working. By Mr. Duffy: He saw his father carried half way up the dip without a stretcher. There was no stretcher in the mine at that time. He was quite sure of that. Mr. Duffy said it was remarkable that it should have taken two hours before the man was sent to the Infirmary; and that there should have been no stretcher in the pit. The Company he was sure would desire that every possible appliance should be available in case of accident. Mr. Gill, mining engineer, produced a plan of the mine showing the situation of the working place with regard to the shaft, some 500 yards away; and the working place itself, showing the propping and the metal from which the lump fell. No one was with him at the time. It was assumed from his injury and the position in which he was found with regard to the lump that he was struck on the back and thrown forward and had staggered a few steps. The lump was between 2 cwt. and 3 cwt. of ore. The main roof was 15 ft. 9 in. Nothing came from the roof. The lumps from which the lump fell were not connected with the roof at all. By Mr. Duffy: The lumps could have been timbered so as to prevent them falling; but the men were all experienced men and had the timber if they thought if desirable. There was no appearance of danger. There was supervision to see that the men properly timbered the working place. Mr. Duffy said he did not suggest the slightest negligence, but the object of the inquiry was to prevent similar accidents. By Mr. Auld: He had never heard of metal of that strength being timbered. If it was thought dangerous the lump would have been brought down not timbered. Mr. Gill added as to the ambulance that was at the pit top and was sent down immediately. He did not know any pit in the district that kept a stretcher down the pit. Dr. Tawse, of the Infirmary medical staff, said deceased was under his attention. He had a fracture of the dorsal spine. He was paralysed in the lower part of the body and the legs. There was no operation. He made no improvement. He was conscious, but all he said was that a lump fell and hit him between the shoulders. He blamed no one. He died from exhaustion following shock, having lived for about a fortnight. A motor ambulance would be better than a horse ambulance coming quicker and jolting less, but with the best appliances the man was found to suffer great pain with an accident of that sort. He was kept under morphia from the first and the case was hopeless. Mr. Duffy said he had seen motor ambulances in which vibration was reduced to a minimum. Did not Dr. Tawse think that would be an improvement? Dr. Tawse said he had no doubt it would. Mr. Duffy said he had advocated such an ambulance for years. James Whelan, Victoria Villas, Cleator Moor, said he had worked there for 20 years. Deceased and he were working together on the day of the accident. He did not see anybody examine the working place. The place seemed to be all right; and they were satisfied that the place was as well protected as it could be. Witness was away from the working for about four minutes, and he was returning and was about 20 yards from the working when he heard a moan and ran in and found deceased lying on his back moaning, with a lump lying near that had fallen. Deceased said the lump had hit him between the shoulders. Witness got assistance and took him out, and the ambulance came afterwards. There was plenty of material, and he or Tutty could have protected the place if they thought it had been necessary. By Mr. Leck: If there was anything wrong in the opinion of the deputy he left a chalked message. If there was no chalked message they assumed all was right so far as the deputy was concerned. It was usual for the deputy to inspect the working. The manager came through every day. He had worked with Tutty for nine years, and on this level they had worked together for two years. Deceased was a careful and a competent workman, older than witness. They examined the three lumps when they went in, and they thought all was safe. If they had thought there was anything unsound they would certainly have taken it down dressed it down. It did not occur to them that they should put any more timber in; they thought there was sufficient timber. The lump that fell was about 2 ft. square. Supposing they had thought it desirable to put any timber in there would have been no practical difficulty. It was simply a matter of judgement. They had not mentioned the lumps to the manager, because they were satisfied that they were safe. They carried out to the best of their judgement the special rules which required workmen before beginning their work to satisfy themselves that the place was safe and sufficiently timbered. The time when the stretcher arrived seemed very short — it might be three of four minutes. It would not take anything like two hours. The accident took place after ten o'clock, and they had him up before half-past. No time seemed to be lost. By Mr. Duffy: Witness assumed in the absence of a chalked message that the place had been examined. If the lump had been spiled and packed it would have held it. But if they had thought it was unsafe they would have brought it down and would not have spiled and packed it. They did not think it was unsafe. As to the time when the stretcher arrived witness might be wrong as to the time being so very short, but the stretcher was there by the time the ambulance men were done. By Mr. Auld: As far as witness could judge deceased was up the shaft by half-past ten — within half an hour after the accident. By the Coroner: Witness did not think that deceased had done anything to bring the lump down. It was not necessary to go near it at all. Thos. Richardson, 36, Trumpet-road, Cleator, deputy of Mowbray Mine for 13 years, said he examined the working place before deceased and the last witness went in, and made a careful examination of it. He did not think the place could be any safer, the way they were working it; they were trying to bring it in. If they had thought a further propping was desirable they had plenty of it, and could have done it. Witness was at the working place about a quarter past ten, when he was being carried out. The stretcher came abut five minutes after. The metal came not from the roof, but from the side. It would have been possible to disturb the lump by the way of working. By Mr. Leck: if he had thought there was danger he would have told the men to bring it down, not to timber it up. If he had any message for the men he chalked it on the spade, or if it was very dangerous he stayed for the men. If nothing was wrong he left no message, and the men assumed all was right. It would be possible to leave a chalk message in any case, to show that he had been actually there. Witness complied with the special rules as to inspecting the workings and entering it in the book. Tutty and his companion were of the very best of men on that kind of work on which they were engaged, which was robbery work. By Mr. Duffy: Witness could make an inspection of a working in five minutes. Asked to produce his report book, he did so; and the Coroner read out the entries signed by the witness showing that he had examined the places and found all right. The height of the lump that fell was about 6 ft. 6 in. He sounded with a hammer, and he could easily reach that height. Isaac Walker, manager of the mine for over 30 years under this Company, said he made daily inspection of the mine. Nothing, in his opinion was required to make this working place secure. It was a lump that they were going to take out. They would not have timbered it. It might have been disturbed, he did not know; but it just broke away, and that was all that could be said of it. Their men were steady and reliable and, he had every confidence in them; they had worked with him for years. With regard to a stretcher being kept down the mine it would be rotten in a week. Mr. Duffy: Get another one, then. It would be possible to have one impervious to damp. Witness: I have never seen one. Mr. Duffy: There are plenty of things that you have not seen. The Coroner, addressing the jury, agreed that if a motor ambulance could be provided it would be an improvement. Another point on which he commented was with regard to the practice as to the inspection of workings. He thought it was usual and that it would be better, if a chalked message was left in every case, if it was only the date, showing that the deputy had been there, and not leaving it to be taken for granted that the deputy had been there. The Coroner commented upon the fact that the men were experienced competent workmen, to whose interest of life and limb it was to see that the place was safe. The jury found that the deceased died from exhaustion, following shock, from a fracture of the dorsal spine. They strongly recommended that there should be a chalked message in every case to show that the place had been inspected. Mr. Walker said that would be done. Mr. Auld, on behalf of the Company, expressed their regret at the accident, and asked Mr. Gavan Duffy to convey to the relatives of the deceased their sympathy with them. Mr. Gavan Duffy said the deceased was known to him personally, and he was an extremely good workmen, and always quite content with his work at Mowbray Pit, and always spoke well of his manager. He (Mr. Duffy) hoped that the inquiry they had held would result in reforms as to the stretcher and motor ambulance. In regard to accidents of this character it was the first moments that told. He was not suggesting that anything could have been done that had not been done in this particular case. They all knew Mr. Walker very well, and he was satisfied that Mr. Walker had done all that was humanely possible; but generally speaking they wanted something more done in the future. In regard to Mr. Auld's expression of sympathy on behalf of the Company he would convey that to the family.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||