Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

11th January 1917

Shot-Firing Fatality At Ladysmith Pit

On Monday afternoon, Mr. E. Atter, coroner, held an inquest at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland. It was on the death of a shiftman who worked at Ladysmith Pit, Whitehaven, through being struck in the chest by a piece of coal on a shot fired from which he had not taken cover.

The deceased was Thomas Hutchinson, 63, single, who lived with his sister-in-law, Ann McMillan, at 20, Mid Street, Kells.

About 2.30 on the morning of the 6th January, Solomon Tunstall, shot-firer, was working the place where deceased was. Tunstall had shouted the usual warning to me in the neighbourhood; but after firing a shot at this time he heard deceased shout and ascertained that he had been hit. He was bleeding from a wound below the heart. Tunstall called for assistance and was joined by a number of other workmen. Deceased was made as comfortable as possible and conveyed to the surface, where Dr. Carno (locum tenens for Dr. C. J. Harris) saw him and sent him on to the Whitehaven Infirmary. Hutchinson died before he reached the Infirmary.

At the inquest, which, on behalf of the police, was in charge of Inspector Rae, Mr. Councillor R. Wilson was chosen foreman of the jury. Mr. G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines, was present; Mr. O. F. Ormrod appeared on behalf of the Whitehaven Colliery Company; Mr. Fryer, manager of Ladysmith Pit, was in attendance; and Mr. Councillor J. Hanlon, miner's agent, represented the relatives of the deceased.

Dr. Carno said he attended to Hutchinson at the pit top. He was conscious. There was a lacerated wound on the front of the chest. The place was too dark to attend to him there, and witness ordered him to be taken to the Infirmary. Witness afterwards saw the body at the Infirmary. The cause of death was shock, from the nature of the wound.

The Coroner asked if the clothing was pierced in the place where the wound was.

Dr. Carno said there seemed to be no clothing in front of the wound. He had only his pit clothing on.

By Mr. Hanlon: There was no appearance of his having received any ambulance treatment. No ambulance treatment, in witnesses' opinion, would have been of any use. It was hopeless from the beginning.

William McMillan, 20, Mid Street, Kells, said the deceased was brother-in-law of witness's wife, and had lived with them for two years. Witness and he left house together to go to work, working in adjoining workings; but witness was not there at the time of the accident. When he went back there would be nine or ten men there, and he saw that deceased's left breast had been injured. Deceased was in witness's working a few minutes before the accident taking brattice out of witness's working and putting it in the others.

William Henry Johnston, surveyor of the Whitehaven Colliery, produced a plan showing the part of the pit where the accident happened. From the place where the shot was fired to where the men were working was 36 yards and two feet.

Solomon Tunstall, 17, Albion Street, Whitehaven, collier for 38 years, said he had known deceased for a good many years. He was working on the same shift with deceased. Witness was shot-firer, and had been so twelve months on this job. He fired a shot between two o'clock and a quarter past. Thomas Connor was in the working when he fired it. Witness went to the nearest two workings and warned the men not to come out. After he had fired the shot he heard somebody shouting and saw Hutchinson. Witness said, "Didn't you hear me shout?" He said, "No." "O dear me," witness said, "you could not miss hearing me." The distance to where deceased was would be about 36 yards. When witness came down he shouted, "Hey up," and in a few minutes he shouted "Fire." If witness had known deceased was there he would have had deceased moved further away. Men working in both workings heard witness shout, and they said so. Witness had Hutchinson conveyed down the district and sent to inform the management. Witness had never known such an accident before. He thought the method was safe. If he had known the deceased was where he was witness would have gone to him and sent him out of there.

By the Inspector: Witness had sent Hutchinson to another place further away; that was about ten o'clock, and witness did not see him afterwards. Witness did not know that Hutchinson was working where he was, and did not know whether anyone had sent him there or he had gone there without instructions. Witness shouted twice to warn the men, with perhaps three or four minutes between. During those four or five minutes he did not hear anybody working where deceased was afterwards found. There was no noise that would have prevented anyone where deceased was, from hearing witness shout. Witness had also sent a man further out to warn the men; and that man would have to pass where Hutchinson was. Hutchinson would be behind the canvas; but working with an electric lamp the man might have been able to see light through the canvas. It might be that the deceased may have thought that witness was firing in Lucas's place, and therefore took no notice of him shouting.

By Mr. Hanlon: This was the third place he had fired that morning. He had called out all the men on every occasion, and used all the care possible; he could not have done any different. He did not know deceased was working where he was. Witness sent him in an opposite direction. The depth of the boring would be 2ft 3in or 2ft 4in. He examined the hole after the explosion. The shot had done its work all right. He could not say what part of the hole was left. There was nothing unusual about it; the shot had done its work. Hutchinson was removed as soon as possible. Witness fired other holes after the accident. He did not know that he should not have fired the other holes after the accident. He did not think at the time that the accident was so serious; he did not at the time think it was a serious accident.

By Mr. Ormrod: From the place where I shouted to where the deceased was would be about 16 yards. Witness knew that other men further away than that had heard witness.

By the Jury: A man would be safe without any cover at a distance of about 50 yards. The men all knew that shot firing was going on, and they would all have been on the look-out, and witness could not understand how Hutchinson had remained where he was.

John William Chester, 2, Sea View, Hensingham, said he had worked at Ladysmith PitHutchinson, doing brattice cloth work, mending the canvas doors and putting a bush head in. Witness and Hutchinson had been working in the neighbourhood of the accident for about an hour. They were expecting to get Tunstall's signal and if they had heard him they would have gone into cover. Some tubs were running about the time before the accident, and if the shouts were given while the tubs were running that might have prevented them hearing. Witness did not hear any shouts. He thought Tunstall knew that they were there. They were accustomed to this method and nothing had ever happened before. Witness was quite close to the deceased and caught him as he fell.

By the Inspector: Witness knew that Tunstall did give warning in other cases, and he had no reason to doubt that he did shout on this occasion although witness did not hear it. They were using a hammer and making the noise of a good number of blows with the hammer, and anybody near them must have heard them.

By Mr. Hanlon: The noise of their working might have prevented them hearing. They had to saw two deals, and it might have happened while they were sawing. Hutchinson did not speak after he was struck, except to utter: "Oh!"

George Henry Lucas, 19, North Row, Kells, collier for 20 years at Ladysmith Pit, said he saw deceased and Mr. Chester, the last witness, shortly before the accident, near the place where they were when the accident occurred. Tunstall was then in witness's working. Tunstall had fired several shots before. Tunstall gave warning in every case and called out "Fire!" twice, before the shot was fired.

By the Inspector: Chester and deceased were walking up in the direction of the shot firing, when witness saw them. Witness did not warn them that shot-firing was going on.

By Mr. Hanlon: Witness was taking tubs when he met Chester and deceased. Witness heard Tunstall shout, and did not think the noise of the tubs would prevent deceased hearing; it did not prevent witness hearing. If witness had been working where deceased was, behind the canvas, he would have thought he was in no danger and would not have budged from where he was; not without the brattice cloth up — he regarded the brattice cloth as a protection.

By the Coroner: For a man to be perfectly safe, without any cover, one would have to be 50 or 60 yards away. He would have felt safe at 36 yards with the cover of the brattice canvas.

By the Inspector: He did not think the canvas was no more protection than a newspaper would be. The canvas was running in the same line as the shot, but was close to the face of the coal.

Thomas Connery, 2, North Row, Kells, a collier at Ladysmith Pit ever since it was started, said he was about 60 yards away when the accident happened. He heard a shout of distress after the firing of the shot, and remarked to his mate that that was an accident. They went and found that it was Hutchinson. Before the shot was fired he heard the shot-firer shout "Fire."

By the Inspector: Witness would not consider himself safe in the opening in a straight line from the shot at a distance of 50 yards. It would have been better if after the accident the remaining shots were not fired and the place was left as it was, but at the time witness did not regard the accident as a serious one.

By the Foreman: (Councillor Wilson): He knew Tunstall to be a competent shot-firer.

John Webb, master shifter, said he gave deceased orders about half-past nine which would take him to where the accident occurred. Witness told Tunstall where he had sent deceased. When Tunstall said after the accident that he did not know deceased was where he was, witness did not tell Tunstall "I told you that I had sent him there."

By the Inspector: I did not tell Tunstall when deceased was to be there, and Tunstall would not know when he would be there. Witness did not think deceased was seriously injured. That was the reason why the men continued working.

By Mr. Hanlon: Witness did not give the shot firer orders where to go. He just went where he was wanted. He did not think the shot firer was sometimes pressed to get through his work. He knew that there were three places waiting for him at the time. Witness agreed now that it would have been better that the place should have been left without further shot firing.

By Mr. Ormrod: The reason why witness did not stop the work was that at the time he did not regard the accident as a serious one.

George Kellet Fryer, manager of Ladysmith, said the custom of shot firing as in this case was the usual one, and witness did not know that it could be improved upon. Witness thought that the deceased and Chester may have just come up to the place where they were, at the very time when the shot was fired. Tunstall ought to have made very sure that everybody was warned. The men who were sent out ought to have warned anyone they came across.

By the Inspector: The work should have been stopped immediately on account of the accident. He thought Tunstall was a careful man. He had never seen him hurried or flurried at his work, and had every confidence in him. He thought a man passing at one side of a brattice canvas should be able to have known that someone was working there if there was anyone working with an electric light. Witness thought that men should have known, and that Tunstall should have made sure that there was no one there.

By a Juryman: If a man had been sent down the main road and another the other side of the brattice, there would have been no accident.

The Coroner read the rule with regard to shot firing, that the shot-firer should "see" that everybody had taken cover. He then addressed the jury on the evidence. The medical evidence was that the cause of death was shock. They would consider whether there was any blame attaching to Tunstall, remembering his long experience and the confidence the management had in him. He thought they could hardly say there was any blame though there may have been an error of judgement. Mr. Fryer had given his evidence very candidly and he thought Tunstall ought to have known that deceased was there, that shots should not be fired till the men sent out to give warning returned to say that all was clear. As to work being continued after the accident, the explanation of that was that no one considered the injury was a serious one. If the jury had any recommendations as to work in the future, they should give it.

The jury found that the deceased died from shock following on a wound received from shot firing; and they recommended that before shots were fired the man sent out to give warning should come back and tell the shot-firer that all was clear.

Mr. Fryer said he approved of that.

Mr. Ormrod said he would convey that recommendation to the Colliery Co., and he asked Mr. Hanlon to convey to the relatives the Company's.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Atter, Edward    Coroner  
Carno, —, Dr.    Doctor  
Chester, John William    Miner  
Connery, Thomas    Miner  
Connor, Thomas    Miner  
Cook, George    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Fryer, George Kellet    Manager  Whos Who Page
Hanlon, J., Councillor    Miners' Agent  
Harris, C. J., Dr.    Doctor  
Hutchinson, Thomas   63 Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Johnston, William Henry    Surveyor  
Lucas, George Henry    Miner  
McMillan, Ann      Sister-in-Law
McMillan, William    Miner  Brother-in-Law
Ormrod, O. F.    Solicitor  
Tunstall, Solomon    Shot Firer  
Webb, John    Master Shifter  
Wilson, R., Councillor    Jury Foreman  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Whitehaven Colliery  Whitehaven Colliery


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print