|
24th August 1916 Sudden Death In Wellington PitJury Find It Due To Previous AccidentEarly on Tuesday morning, Mr. John Daley, 59 years of age, No. 20, Castle Row, Newhouses, died suddenly while at work in Wellington Pit, Whitehaven. He had been assisting to push tubs underground, and about two a.m., a fellow workman, Mr. Denvir, spoke to him, and, received no reply, but observed that he appeared as though he were going to sit down, commenced to breathe heavily, and then was falling backwards. Mr. Denvir caught him and prevented him falling and called for assistance. Attempts were made by the men to revive him, but Mr. Daley died about half an hour afterwards. This was the first shift deceased had worked since the accident on the 8th June to a set of tubs on which men were riding in. On that occasion, it will be remembered, a tub in which deceased, his son, and another man, were riding, was thrown up and jambed against the roof. The son was instantly killed, and deceased and the other man were injured. Deceased was attended by Dr. Harris after that accident, but he had always complained of internal pains after the accident, and it was not till Monday night that he had retuned to work, with this fatal result. It was stated that he had been a healthy man up till the time of that accident in June. The circumstances having been reported to the Coroner, he deemed it desirable that for the purpose of the inquest there should be a post-mortem examination, which was made. The inquest was held yesterday (Wednesday) morning, at the Y.M.C.A. Institute, Irish Street, by Mr. Atter, the Coroner. Mr. Councillor R. Wilson was chosen foreman of the jury. H.M. Inspector of Mines, Mr. Geo. Cook, Whitehaven was present. Mr. L. T. Helder appeared on behalf of the Whitehaven Colliery Company; and Mr. John Hanlon, miners' agent, appeared on behalf of the relatives of the deceased; and Mr. R. Steel, manager of Wellington Pit, was present. Sarah Daley, widow of John Daley, 20, Castle Row, Whitehaven, identified the body. Her son, Thomas, worked with her husband, and on the 8th June last they were working together and the son was killed and the deceased was injured to his leg about his ankle — between the knee and the ankle, and he complained of pain at the pit of his stomach and in his back, and the food he took he said stuck at his chest. Before the accident he was in good health, and had no ailment or complaint. They had been married about 28 years and during that time he had been a strong healthy man. After the accident he was laid up for some five weeks and was attended by Nurse Hampton and by Dr. Harris. Compensation was paid to her husband for his injury. He went to work, to start again, on Monday night. He went to work because the money he was getting was not sufficient to keep the house going. He had previously seen the compensation doctor, who agreed that he should go to work. He went to work at eleven o'clock on Monday night. He had been complaining that he did not feel well, but said that if he went to work it would maybe work off. He had been a coalhewer all his life: he had never done any other work. By Mr. Hanlon: He declared off compensation to take light work, having seen the manager previously. William Henry Johnston, engineer Whitehaven Colliery Office, produced a plan, the same as the one produced at the inquest on the 8th June, on the body of deceased's son. He explained the plan to the jury and the accident by which deceased was injured and his son killed. The witnesses who gave evidence at the inquest on the death of the son, were then called and repeated their evidence. John Oldfield, haulage hand, described how a tub got off the road and uncoupled itself, in which the deceased and his son were, and the son was killed and the father lamed. By the Inspector: They now made sure that the couplings were tight, by stretching them before starting. Mr. Hanlon: He knew that there was somebody to examine the couplings. He did not notice any slack in the couplings, and had not yet thought of anything that might have caused the tub to get off the road. Fletcher Young, coal hewer, who was working with deceased and his son on the 8th June, also gave evidence as to what happened on the occasion of that accident. He was injured as well as deceased. He had been back at work for the last nine days. The setts were now examined before they started. As far as witness knew deceased's health was good before the accident. By Mr. Hanlon: Deceased complained of his leg, which was injured, and of a pain in his chest. Witness was now on light work. Richard Denvir, shiftman, said he was at Wellington, on Monday night last, on the pit top, and saw deceased coming to work. Witness worked with deceased. Deceased was moving bricks in the tub, and he appeared to be intending to sit down for a rest and to "get a blow" — to get his wind, and he was falling back, when witness caught him. They thought he was fainting. They put water on him and loosened his dress, and otherwise tried to bring him round, but he died in about 25 minutes without having spoken. There was no gas or anything to have affected him. By the Inspector: Witness did not consider the work deceased was doing as heavy work. There were no fumes from any shots. By Mr. Hanlon: Witness did not notice deceased staggering or complaining before that. Fletcher Young, recalled, was one of the men who went to deceased's assistance at the call of the last witness. He had been working with the deceased previously, and deceased was not complaining before he sat down. By Mr. Hanlon: At light work a man could sit down and rest. Deceased never made any complaint until he sat down for the last time. James Kinsella, deputy, said that deceased was all right when he went to work on Monday night. Witness told him what sort of work he was to do. It was light work. There were four of them at the tub. Witness knew of no cause for deceased's death. David Gair, chargeman, said he knew deceased and saw him and worked with him on Monday night. He was taking the same share as the others and made no complaint. Witness heard Denvir call and went and was present and helped to bring the man round. Richard Steel, manager, said that since the accident they had taken full setts off while ridding setts were going in. Compensation was paid to the deceased. He came to the under-manager and asked for work and they gave him light work to prepare him for returning to hewing. By the Inspector: The couplings were now stretched. Dr. C. J. J. Harris said he had attended the deceased many times for bronchitis before the accident of the 8th June. He would not call him a robust man. After that accident he had a wound in the left leg. He had no shock whatever. He wanted to go on a crutch to see his son, but witness would not allow him. The injuries he suffered from were trivial. He could not make out that there was anything seriously wrong with him. It was the left leg he (Dr. Harris) attached importance to, which had a wound in it. He was not laid up at all. A nurse was in attendance on him. Witness called within ten days of the accident, and he was out. Witness could not say whether the widow's statement that deceased was attended by a nurse for five weeks was correct. It was several weeks since the deceased told him he was going back to work. Witness took it for granted that when the man said he was going back to work, he was fit to go; but he had not examined him, and could not give an opinion. Witness could not remember when he last saw deceased. Witness made a post-mortem. He found the abdomen full of blood. The mesentery was torn by the rupture of a blood vessel from which there had been haemorrhage. The heart was healthy. The right kidney had a cyst on it. The lungs, beyond the usual signs a coal miner, had in his lungs, black and carbonized, were all right. There were no signs of external injury, other than on the injured leg. The cause of death was rupture and haemorrhage of a blood vessel in the mesentery. The injury deceased received in the accident of the 8th June had nothing to do with the condition in which he found the body on post-mortem examination. The haemorrhage was occasioned by the rupture of the blood vessel, and the rupture was occasioned by disease of the blood vessel. There was nothing to indicate how long the blood vessel had been diseased. — More than six months, or any date? — It is quite impossible to say that. — Could that have been occasioned by anything that happened on the 8th June? — No. — Might it have been caused by violence? — No. — Natural causes? — Natural causes. By the Inspector: There was nothing he was doing that night that might have caused it? — No, sir, the blood vessel might have been ruptured by the man while he was in the street. By Mr. Hanlon: In anything he was suffering from might the work he was doing accelerate his death? — No, I cannot say that. Isn't it possible that the shifting of this tub, although the blood vessel might have been bad, might cause it to occur? — Anything likely to raise blood pressure might do it. Even if the blood vessel was diseased, might pushing the tub? — Yes, any exercise might cause a blood vessel to rupture. You cannot remember when you last saw him, you say. You did not see him during the last week? — No, the last time I saw him he seemed to be in his usual manner. Mr. Hanlon: When he came to me I don't think he was fit to go to any kind of work. Witness replied to further questions that he had known Daley for a great many years. He had always followed work as a coal hewer. Mr. Hanlon: I think you said he was not a robust man. He was not a big man :— No, he was not. But we have some rather frail men that are among the best workers? — Oh, quite so. By Mr. Helder: I only treated him for the injury to the left leg, and I don't attribute that as the cause of death. Dr. Eldon Pratt said that acting for Dr. Harris while the latter was away on his holidays, he saw the deceased, who had a wound in the leg and a bruise on his side. Saw him on June the 8th when, he was decidedly better, except for the pain in his side. Witness told him then that he would be back at his work in a couple of weeks. Witness was present at the post-mortem, and agreed that the accident had nothing to do with the cause of death. By the Coroner: The cause of death was haemorrhage from a ruptured blood vessel and he thought the accident had nothing to do with it. He probably had the diseased blood vessel long before the accident. The cyst on the kidney would not occasion death. By Mr. Hanlon: When witness said he thought he would be fit for work within a fortnight, he reported that to the employers. The pushing of a tub might have helped the blood vessel to burst; but it might have burst when he was lying still. The exertion might have contributed, but no further than the exertion of walking up a hill going to work. The Coroner said he wished to have the nurse called and Mrs. Daley's daughter as to the period during which the nurse attended deceased, and instructed Inspector Thornborrow, who went for them that there was to be no conversation with them, but that they were simply to be asked to attend. Mary Daley, daughter of Mrs. Daley, the widow, said the nurse remained two or three weeks, but she could not say for how long. Her father was in bed for about a fortnight and then for another fortnight he had his leg up. Her father always complained of his back. He always said that his food never got any further than his stomach. Isabella Daley, another daughter, said her father complained of pain under his heart and under his stomach and in the back. He had a nurse for about a month. By Mr. Helder: Her father was not out for five or six weeks. She did not know that he went to see Dr. Pratt on the 26th June. A third daughter of Mrs. Daley said that deceased complained of pain round his stomach and in his back. She could not say when he first went out before last Monday. The Nurse was not able to attend. The Coroner, addressing the jury, said the important question was whether the accident contributed to the cause of death. There was considerable difference of opinion between the witnesses; — Mrs. Daley and her daughters on the one hand, and Dr. Harris on the other. Dr. Harris said the injuries of deceased were trivial. There was evidence that the nurse continued in attendance for some weeks; and the evidence was that the man was a different man, and his physical condition was undoubtedly different to what it was before. The widow had stated that he constantly complained of pain in his stomach and back, and that his food stuck in his stomach. What was the cause of that? He was said to have had bronchitis before, but that did not seem to have kept him off his work. The medical evidence was that the accident did not contribute to the cause of death. What did? Dr. Harris gave it as his opinion that the deceased was not fit to go to see his son, who was dead; but he could not say whether deceased was fit to go to his work when deceased told him he was going to return to work. The Coroner asked the jury to find whether the deceased died simply from haemorrhage, unconnected with the accident, or from haemorrhage which was affected by the accident on the 8th June. The jury retired to consider their verdict, and after a short absence returned, and the Foreman said they were unanimous that this man did die from haemorrhage, occasioned by rupture of a blood vessel, and that that was caused by the injuries he received on the 8th June when he met with the accident.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||