|
30th June 1916 High Court Of JusticeChancery DivisionDamage To Schools from Colliery workingsDurham County Council v. The South Medomsley Colliery (Limited). (Before Mr. Justice Neville.) The plaintiffs in this case were the owners of about one acre of land at Dipton, in the township of Collierley, in the parish of Lanchester, County Durham, and of certain buildings thereon, which were erected more than 20 years ago, and were used for an elementary school and a schoolhouse. Several seams of coal underlay the plaintiffs land and the adjacent lands, and were being worked by collieries. One of these collieries was the Medomsley Colliery, which was being worked by the defendants. The plaintiffs alleged that at all material times they were entitled to have their said buildings and piece of land supported by the adjoining lands, that the defendants' workings near to and adjoining the plaintiffs' land had in and after 1909 deprived the plaintiffs of their right of support, and had caused subsidence of the surface of their land and serious injury to their buildings, and the plaintiffs claimed an injunction to restrain the defendants from working their mines in such manner as to destroy or injure the surface of the plaintiffs' land and the buildings thereon, or to deprive the plaintiffs of the right of support to which they were entitled for their land and buildings ; and they also claimed damages. The defendants denied that in 1909, or at any other time, they worked their mines so as to deprive the plaintiffs of support to their land and buildings, or so as to cause subsidence or injury as alleged. They also denied that the plaintiffs were entitled to support from any coal worked by the defendants ; and they also did not admit the alleged subsidence or damage, and said that such subsidence or damage, if any, was caused by workings other than those of the defendants. Mr. Jenkins, K.C., and Mr. Harman appeared for the plaintiffs ; and Mr. Ward Coldridge, K.C., and Mr. J. G. Wood for the defendants. Mr. Justice Neville, in delivering judgement, said that the case involved a very difficult question of fact, but he had come to the conclusion on the evidence that the plaintiffs were right in saying that they had suffered the damage alleged by the operations of the defendants. Undoubtedly there was subsidence of the surface and injury to the buildings in 1901, but in 1910 the buildings were repaired, and immediately after again showed signs of subsidence in 1914. Therefore the defendants were responsible for the damage suffered since 1909, and the plaintiffs were entitled to an injunction and to an inquiry as to damages. But, having regard to the parties and to the small amount of the alleged damage and to the enormous expense that the inquiry as to damages would entail, he hoped that the parties might come to some agreement as to the amount of damage. Solicitors. — Messrs. Sharpe, Pritchard, and Co. ; Messrs. Sayer, Ledgard, and Smith.
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||