|
30th March 1916 Dilly Fatality At Wellington PitRunaway Switch Propped OpenUncoupled Tubs Come AmainThe inquest on Thomas Cunningham, who met with his death instantaneously, on Wednesday morning, at Wellington Pit, Whitehaven, owing to having been caught by a runaway set on a dilly, disclosed the facts that the runaway set was uncoupled to the main set, and that the runaway switch, which is intended to prevent accident by diverting runaway tubs to the side, had not been properly used, but had been propped so as to make it ineffective. The cross-examination of Mr. J. Hanlon, the miner's agent, was directed to the question whether it was the duty of the miners to look after the dilly working, or whether there should not be someone whose special duty it was to look after coupling and the runaway switch. H.M. Inspector said that provision was made in accordance with the Act for the proper working of the dilly if the means provided had been made use of. The Inquest The inquest was held in the Magistrates' Court House, on Thursday afternoon. Mr. E. Atter was the Coroner, and Councillor R. Wilson was chosen foreman of the jury. Mr. O. F. Ormrod appeared for the Colliery Company; Mr. J. Hanlon, C.C, appeared for the friends of the deceased. Mr. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Mines, was present; and also Mr. R. Steele, manager of Wellington Pit. Martha Ann Cunningham said she lived at 5B, Catherine Street, Whitehaven. She was the widow of the deceased, who was 39 years of age, and worked at Wellington Pit as a collier, where he had been for nine months. He had been three years as a collier. On Wednesday, he left home to go to his work at four o'clock, in good health. He had never made any complaint about his work. Patrick Madine said he lived at 20, Swinburn's Court. He was a collier and had worked at Wellington Pit for about 12 years. Deceased and he had worked together about six weeks. On Wednesday he saw deceased about half past six. They were shortly after ten o'clock at the bottom of the dilly, close together, when the accident happened. Deceased had been coming out with half a set and left it standing to go for some lockings; and they were both going up by the dilly, when he heard the wagons rattle, and he shouted to Cunningham, "Look out, Tommy, here's a set amain." Witness just bare escaped the set — he was just about a yard away from the deceased on the same side as witness was. Witness had not time to look round. He did not know until afterwards how many tubs came down. He saw the position the tubs were in and he looked to see if he could see Cunningham. He thought he heard a low moan, and he shouted, "Tommy, are you clear?" He shouted this half a dozen times, and received no answer, and then he looked under the tubs, but they were all that fast together that he could see nothing and shouted for the men, telling them that he thought he was under the tubs. A large number of men came. One of the tubs was against the deceased's leg, and the coupling of another was across his throat. The tubs that came amain were full tubs, and there were seven of them. By the Inspector: Cunningham and he were working at the bottom of the dilly; and Cunningham's work was to provide half sets for witness to make a full set. Before the dilly is run, someone comes down to see if the way is clear; but generally witness whistled to them, as a signal. It was sometimes ten minutes or a quarter of an hour before they came but he never left until he saw a light and got a whistle back. He had whistled before the accident. He whistled with his fingers in his mouth. They could hear it 200 yards away anyway. It was about five minutes after he whistled that the tubs came down. After he whistled he did not allow anybody to pass the bottom of the dilly, if he could hear the tubs coming and knew the dilly was really running, but not otherwise — he did not think he had any right to keep people back. The Inspector: Why do you whistle, if you allow people to come past? — To let them know I am ready. The Inspector: But you allowed a man to come past after you had whistled. By Mr. Hanlon: Witness sends sets outbye from the dilly bottom. Then you are responsible for the dilly bottom? — I could not tell you that. Who is, then? — Cunningham helped me inbye from the dilly. Then you don't know whether you are responsible or not? — No. I am responsible, but I could not tell any man to do a job. Might I say you put the sweeps at the dilly bottom? — Yes. Then you will be responsible. I understand you whistled at the dilly bottom. Who to? — To the men at the top. And you have some knowledge that they would then prepare to make the dilly set ride? — Yes. Then would not it be your place to prevent anybody passing? — Well he was passing just at the same time as I was passing. But after you whistled the men are preparing, and in preparing a tub or two might come away? — Yes. Then didn't you think it was your duty to prevent anybody, or if you did not stop them coming by, that you ought to have warned them? — Oh, yes, they always get warning. Witness continued to reply to Mr. Hanlon: At the time of the accident Cunningham and he were walking on the dilly side. Cunningham was going back to his set. The system of whistling is all right if everything is all right at the top. There is no signal after that whether a set is coming or not. If the men at the top are ready before witness is ready, a man comes down; but if he whistled and all is right the man does not come down. They run ten or eleven tubs on this dilly; not more. Witness never had to go up to the top of the dilly. By Mr. Ormrod: There is about 1½ yards at the sides of the dilly bottom. There was room for deceased to have got clear if he had been where witness was. There was plenty of room inbye, but not much room there. There were rails at the bottom of the dilly which had the effect of stopping the tubs coming down the dilly brow, or getting on to the main engine plane. Asked if he usually put these sweeps down before or after he whistled, witness said before. By doing that it showed that you were ready and the line was ready? — Yes. If the sweeps were properly prepared at the top there was no danger? — No, sir. In this particular case I think the sweeps were not properly prepared? — No, sir. By the Foreman: The sets are let down by a wire rope. He did not think it would be better to have a whistle than to whistle with his fingers in his mouth. He always received an answer back to his whistle. Mr. Johnston, surveyor for the Whitehaven Colliery Company, put in a plan of his preparation which he explained. The dilly brow was an incline of 1 in 16, and was about 175 yards long. There was a block 10 yards from the top to prevent the tubs coming until they were ready, when they were let down with a rope. There was an arrangement by what was called a runaway switch whereby runaway tubs could be turned into the side. Tubs coming down without control would attain a very high speed. John Harrison said he lived at George Street, and had worked at Wellington Pit for two and a half years. He was there on Wednesday, trailing. He saw deceased about half past four, and not afterwards until he was killed. Witness had to do with the tubs. W. Smith and a Belgian were with him. He heard a whistle given by Madine at 10.10. He fastened some of the tubs; he could not say how many. When he heard the whistle he took the lockings out of the first tubs, thinking all was right, and the seven tubs ran amain. He was at the first tub when the accident happened. He was first down and found Paddy Madine, who said deceased was under the set. The seven tubs got amain because they were not coupled. To couple them was the work of three of them. He coupled some. Any of them could couple tubs. The Coroner: If no one does it, who is to blame for it? Witness said any of them was to blame. By the Inspector: He was at the top of the dilly when Madine whistled. He understood what the whistle was for and he whistled back. He had been whistling this quarter — for a month. Did you know that it was not legal to use a whistle; that when an incline is 30 yards long there should be a proper signal used? — No. sir. Have you seen a signal there? — Do you mean from top to bottom? Yes, or from bottom to top? — No. You have not seen the place today then. There is one there now. Witness further replying to the Inspector, said after Madine whistled they took out the chocks. They thought all the tubs were right. The runaway switch was open; the lever was propped. The Inspector: These things have been provided for the purpose of preventing accidents like this, and you do not use them? — It is the first time this quarter when the switch has been propped up before the set has been slipped. The Inspector: It has been once too often. By Mr. Hanlon: Witness brought full tubs and took the empty ones back, also filling when there was time. There were three men at the dilly top doing the coupling. There were twelve men at the dilly top, but there were only three that day. Then there will be three chances of a set not being coupled? — Yes. Did you never take notice of the signal on the dilly? — No. You never noticed anybody use it? — No. With regard to the danger check, did anybody instruct you that it was your duty to look after the danger check, being a collier? — No. There are no couplers employed on the dilly, no boy couplers? — No. Would not it be better if there was boy coupler, would not it be safer? — I don't know. What I mean is, if there was a boy there he would be responsible for the coupling, and there would not be you and somebody else, one man coming out with one tub and another perhaps from another working with a second, so that there is a great liability to mistakes if it is left to the coal hewers. Witness agreed that there was. Then you think it would be much better if there was a braker employed to do the braking? — No, I think if there was a signal from top to bottom, and if the set was coming amain, a bell could be rung at the bottom of the dilly to warn them, they would understand what the bell was rung for and clear away at the bottom. But what I want you to answer is, would it not be much safer if there was a person appointed as a coupler and dilly coal hewers' assistant, who would be responsible? — Yes. You are up the dilly this quarter, but you may be cavilled out of it next, and don't you think it is a great risk having four persons responsible for making up dilly sets? — Yes. Can you tell us whose tub it was that missed being coupled? — No, you never know how the tubs come, and you could not say whose tub it was. Tubs are generally coupled immediately, but sometimes when there are to be more than one to couple you leave it and don't couple it till you come back. The Coroner said the witness spoke of a bell as a warning of runaway tubs. But if the runaway switch were left operative, was not that a better system then a bell? — I don't know, I have seen tubs dropping a ton of coal coming down there. By Mr. Ormrod: You were trailing on this occasion, and it was part of your duty to attend to this danger check, and you admit having propped it open. You know that was wrong to prop it open? — Yes. It is part of your duty to look after that dilly all the way through, isn't it? — Yes. You made a suggestion about some other system, by the use of a bell. If you had carried out your duties, which unfortunately you omitted, the present system is a perfectly satisfactory way of working this dilly, I think, is it not? You have admitted that you made a mistake in propping this open? — Yes. If everything had been right, nothing would have happened; the tubs would have been caught? — Yes. As a matter of fact you are paid for trailing these tubs on the main engine plane, are you not? — Yes. By the Foreman: There were four of us on the dilly, and the other men had as much right to attend to things as I had, and I had the same right to attend to them as they had William Smith, Mid Street, Kells, stated that he worked at Wellington Pit along with Harrison and a Belgian, whose name he did not know. By the Inspector: Witness was at the dilly top on Wednesday, and heard the whistle, after which he started taking out the lockings from the tubs. Harrison would pull out the chock, he thought. Then the tubs went to the bottom. He was not aware that the runaway switch had been propped up. He did not look to see if it was propped up after the accident. He did not know whether it had ever been propped up before. This was his first day on the dilly. By the Coroner: The Belgian had been working there eight or none months and could understand English, but not much. By the Inspector: Does he understand the work? — You have to make signs to him as to what has to be done. But we don't understand that the Belgian propped up the switch? — Well, it is not my regular work on the dillies, and I don't take any active part in running it. Replying to the Inspector's further questions, witness said he knew the runaway switch was there and what is was there for. He was not used to dillying. It had been usual for the trailers to do dillying there. He did not think there was any other dilly in the pit. He thought the coupling would be safer if done by a boy. The Inspector: But if you have three men at the top and they do not look to see if the tubs are coupled, would you expect a boy to do better? — Well, the boy would have nothing else to look after. But it is not an unusual thing for a boy to undertake other work, and he may not couple them even though he knows it is his work. Would not it be better if the runaway check were used? — Well, it would have to be used if there was a boy there. There is no reason, is there, why it should not be used even if there were no boy there? — Not at all. By Mr. Hanlon: The usual trailer was off that day, and witness was completely strange to the work. Do you accept attending to danger checks as part of the work of a coal hewer? — I don't do it. Isn't it wrong for a coal hewer to bother with it at all; is it a safe system to have to look after all these things? — Not to look after so many things; I don't know that it is. Have you any rule or regulation that you have to attend to the danger checks? — No. How have you got accustomed to attend to them? — I don't know. Would you say that there should be a man to take the responsibility of dillies and brakes? — It would be safer. By Mr. Ormrod: Witness did not put any blame on the Belgian. All the signalling gear, switches, &c., on the dilly were in working order if they had been used, were they not? — Yes, as far as I know. The Inspector: You say you are not responsible for the safety checks. Do you know that there is a rule that no person shall omit to do any thing affecting the safety of the mine, and of the persons there. (The Inspector read the rule.)? — No, I don't know anything about that. You have got a copy of the regulations. Do you ever read them? — Some of them. We have not time to read them all, you know. Who were you working under. Did you think Harrison was leading you? — I was under Mr. Harrison. And the Belgian? I think he would be under Mr. Harrison as much as me, as regards the working of the dilly. Thomas Swinburn, Back Row, Newhouses, a deputy at Wellington Pit, said he had been a deputy for 24 or 25 years, and knew the system of working the dilly, which in his opinion was a perfectly safe one, if it was properly worked. The Belgian now was as good as any of them. At the time of the accident witness was in one of the other workings and was sent for. He asked Harrison what was the cause of the accident, and the latter told him that it was the check that had been propped open, but he did not say that he had done it. He would rather trust to a man than a boy to do the coupling of the tubs. A bell would be no use because of the noise; he did not think they could hear a bell or anything else if tubs were coming amain. By the Inspector: This duty was not a new thing, and they had not much trouble as regards the men understanding the work. At the beginning of each quarter they had to give other men instructions. He passed the dilly each day once or twice, and he had never noticed that the runaway switches had been propped up. Asked if he saw the switch propped up after the accident, witness said he did. It was propped up with a little chock underneath the lever. Was there any reason why it should have been propped up on this occasion? — No, none. Witness added in reply to the Inspector that he did not select the men for trailing. The men selected them themselves. So that the Belgian was there with the consent of his fellow employees. By Mr. Hanlon: In saying he would rather trust a man than a boy, he meant by a boy one of about 15. He would call one of 18 not a boy but a man. He had known of a boy of 15 at a dilly, assisting. He had seen a dilly working on the same system as this, with a smaller dilly wheel. He had known an accident happen before, and it happened the same way as this had happened, because the safety was chocked up some way. He had more confidence in having each man responsible for his own tub, than he would have in a boy coupler. But don't you know that the men here are responsible for other men's tubs? — They all come out to assist one another. You would not say it is a good system? — Yes, the system is all right. They have always done very well on it, any how. All the trouble was with the tubs not being coupled? — Yes, unless a coupling breaks; I have seen it break, you know. Do you not think the bell system is better than what has been spoken about today, about whistling? — It is a matter of form the men understand a system and work to it. But it is wrong to have a system not allowed by the Act? — Just so. By Mr. Ormrod: I am thoroughly of opinion that this system is the best that could be adopted, and that if the men do as they should do there would be no accident; it is an impossibility that there should be one. And do I gather that had this safety check not been as it was, fast, that this accident could not have happened? — No, it could not. One of the men saw that this was wrong and knew it to be wrong, so that these men were well acquainted with the system? — Of course they are. About this Belgian. How long has he been working? — I don't know. I did not know him until this quarter. Three months to your knowledge? — Yes, nearly. By the jury: It is my duty to instruct the men, and I do instruct them, and I caution them every day. When a new man comes on I tell them what they are to do, and make it a special duty to go with them, and tell them what they have to do, for the general safety of everybody else. Robert Steel said he was the manager of this pit. He was constantly at the dilly brow, and knew it well. The system there is the universal system, where there are dillies. If this system is worked as it ought to be, it is perfectly safe, if the appliances that are put down are used as they ought to be. It absolutely complied with the regulations. "Runaway switches shall be provided where practicable." This system is in full compliance with that. As to the suggestion of a bell, or a brake machine they did provide rapper signals, both top and bottom, where they ran in sets, ten full sets for instance bringing up ten empty ones. But this is not a brake, but a dilly brow, and the coal hewers work it, and are paid by the ton to deliver the coal on the engine plane. It is much safer for the men to come down than to signal by a rapper. Is whistling a good or bad system? As long as they are made known to each other. The trailer comes down into the engine plane to see if everything is ready so as to deliver the tubs from the incline on to the level, and he goes up and sees personally that everything is in working order, to knock out the chock, and they have a runaway switch for safety, and he closes that and the set comes down on to the level. But on a recognised brake, where the men deliver on the top, we supply a braker and a coupler. But that is where you have from twenty to thirty men. On this dilly, sometimes on a Monday morning when we have perhaps four men, we would have to have two men at the top and two at the bottom to deal with four men's coal. If this danger check is properly worked there is perfect safety? — Perfect safety, because even if a miss is made in the coupling of the tubs and the loose ones come away, the switch will catch them on the side and they will stand there. Further replying to the Coroner, witness said that at half past ten he was informed of the accident, and he was down at a quarter to eleven. He went straight to the place, and examined the danger check, which he found propped up, with two pieces of wood under the lever, which made a right of way as it were for the tubs to go to the bottom. He thought it was simply a matter of this being overlooked, the men being anxious to get their tubs down. He did not think it was wilful in any way, but just due to their anxiety to get the tubs away. It was the first time a fatal accident had happened there through that means, and the dilly had worked satisfactorily for many, many years. It had been admitted that the danger check was propped up. It is always lying open at safety, so that before the sets can pass a man must lift it to allow the sets to pass. It is the same system carried out in all the pit on inclines, brakes, and dillies. I could not improve on that system, if the danger checks are attended to. The Inspector: Were you aware of this whistling from the bottom to the top of the dilly? Witness: No, I always thought they came down to the bottom and made inquiries as they put their set out. By the Coroner: The length of the dilly incline was 175 yards. The Inspector: Wouldn't it be better to have a signal rather than whistling? — Whistling is rather an unsatisfactory arrangement. Witness said he had given instructions since the accident for a signal wire to be put up. Even with the signal, however, it would not alter the position as regards the danger switch. The Inspector: No, but for any place whistling is a bad way. We prefer to have a signal if a signal has to be given. Witness: Yes, but on a dilly brow the main signal would be going to us at the bottom. They can run it without orders from anybody at all. The Inspector: But we have it in evidence that the man does give a signal, and would it not be better to give a signal by rapper? Witness: Oh, yes, that could be done. The Inspector: The man at the bottom says he allows men to go past. Would not it be better not to allow anyone? — Once he gives the signal he should not allow anyone to come past the opening. In fact they have told me myself "You had better keep clear, the set's about to run." Of course if nobody had been allowed to go past this would not have happened? — Well, a yard would have cleared the poor fellow. Then we have a proposal for a bell to be fixed up to warn the bottom about a runaway. Would not it be better to prevent a runaway coming down than to signal that it was coming? — Oh, most decidedly. I believe in having the danger check in the right position, and that would avoid them running away. By Mr. Hanlon: It was part of the work of the hewers to attend to this dilly. He repeated that the men were paid for it. The men took a contract to run the dilly brow and ran the tubs to the level. That was part and parcel of their work. A dilly was not restricted to one or two tubs. The Company did not compel the men to do the work at the dilly. They put a dilly there and told the men they could use it and would be paid for it. When there were more than 9 men they got a penny a ton extra. Mr. Hanlon, added witness, was a party to this arrangement. Mr. Hanlon: Would I be wrong in saying that I have been on 100 deputations against coal hewers doing the dillying, and urging that it is a bad system? Witness: I don't think it is a bad system. But the system has got nothing to do with this accident. After this accident you say so? — Yes; any system is bad if it is not carried out. But my point is that somebody should be responsible; not the coal hewer? — Well, I dispute you. I say the coal hewer is responsible. The man who is paid is responsible. And after what has happened you still think it is better to go on with the present system? — Yes, I say the men are responsible — the three men who look after these nine or ten men. When they bring out the tubs, every man couples his tub, and before they draw the chock they should see that the tubs are coupled. By the Foreman: He did not know what advantage the men would gain by propping the danger check up. They had admitted to him that they were extremely sorry that they chocked it up rather than stretch the sett, and then go and close it. Had the check being lying open it would only have been a moment's work to lift the lever and allow the setts to go. The Inspector, in response to the Coroner's question as to whether he had any observations to make, said the dilly had been worked for three years, and it appeared to have worked satisfactorily. The only thing was that if the appliances referred to had been used in the proper way the accident would not have happened. If these things were put there for the safety of the men, and they did not use them, he did not see what else could be done. The Coroner said the inquiry had occupied some considerable time, and the matter before them had been thoroughly thrashed out. If the jury were satisfied with the evidence given by the deputy and Mr. Steel, they would probably agree that the system, if worked properly, was effective and that had it been so worked on Wednesday the accident would not have happened. It did seem that whether through carelessness, thoughtlessness, or negligence, Harrison had occasioned the accident. If he had attended to the duties as he should have done the chances were that the accident would not have occurred. He did not think, however, there was any gross neglect to be attributed to him. He thought, as the deputy or Mr. Steel had mentioned, he was in a hurry to get the sett away, and did not pay attention to the danger check, with the unfortunate result that the accident happened. If the jury were satisfied on that point he suggested that their verdict would be that Cunningham died from injuries which were occasioned by his having been accidentally crushed by some tubs while working in the pit. Referring to suggestions which had been made, he felt sure that if the jury thought fit to make any recommendation an experienced Company like the Whitehaven Colliery Company would do whatever might be necessary, but he did not think they should put too many suggestions upon them, but leave it to them and their management to do what they might consider desirable. They knew very much better than he or the jury did, and when they had an experienced Company, and an experienced manager, the less they interfered, except they saw good cause, the better. The Foreman said the jury returned a verdict in accordance with the Coroner's suggestion. As regards the switch they thought someone should be specially instructed with regard to this, and as to other matters upon which suggestions had been made they thought these should be left to the discretion of the management. Mr. Steel said the deputy warned everyone who went up these brakes, especially at the beginning of the quarter, to keep the danger check lying for safety. In addition to this the rules were posted at the pit for the men to read. A Juror (Mr. Clark) said it seemed as if the responsibility of attending to the safety check was left to too many men. Mr. Steel said the check was lying for safety. It was self-acting and full tubs could not get past it unless someone closed it or chocked it up and left it as a main line. That was when the danger arose. If any additional caution to the men would do any good he would only be too glad to do it, and to instruct the deputies accordingly. Mr. Ormrod, on behalf of the Company, expressed sympathy with Mrs. Cunningham in her trouble, and their great regret at this accident. Deceased was a most excellent workman, and Mr. Steel told him (Mr. Ormrod) that he was one they could ill afford to lose. The Foreman said the jury wished to be associated with these remarks.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||