|
9th March 1916 Sequel To Mining FatalityDeputies ProsecutedSamuel McKenzie, colliery deputy, Main-street, Frizington, was charged at the instance of Isaac Brown, colliery manager, Workington, with having failed to inspect a certain working and ascertain the condition as to the presence of gas and general safety, in Montreal Colliery on the 29th January. Samuel Todd, colliery deputy, Birks-road, Cleator Moor, was similarly charged on the 1st February. Mr. St. Geo. Curwen prosecuted, and Mr. Atter defended both cases being taken together. Duncan Robertson, a surveyor at Montreal Colliery, produced a plan of the particular working, which he explained to the Bench. Isaac Brown, manager at the Colliery, said the two defendants were deputies and it was their duty to make necessary inspections under Section 64 of the Coal Mines Act. They had also to keep a record of their inspection in the book (produced). The part of the pit called "Bannock Seam" was a ventilating district of its own. Two men, Byrne and Irving, who were working in that seam on the 1st February, were gassed and killed. McKenzie was deputy on the 29th January and, as such ought to have inspected this seam. The report book, showing the result of his inspection on that date, and signed by McKenzie, stated that "noxious or inflammable gas — none." Todd was on the morning shift on February 1st, and it was his duty to inspect the seam. The report in the book stated that he found gas in one place — 115 place — but not in the back drift, the subject of the present charge. The place 115 was in the same ventilating district as the place, which was the subject of the charge, and about 50 or 60 yards away, and there was a barrier of coal between on that date. Todd ought to have inspected twice again that date, and though not compulsory he kept a record of one of those inspections. In this second record he did not report any gas. Work was last carried on in the back drift on January 4th. He gave word that the work had to be ceased in that place on that date, and that the men had to work in 115 place. The back drift rises very sharp - about 1 in 3, and he arranged for ventilation in the place that was temporarily stopped. There were three or four sets of timber left in this place. He was in the working on the Thursday before the accident, which occurred on the Tuesday, and he thought it would take seven or eight days to connect the two places in the drift. According to the Mines Act, the examiners must inspect places temporarily stopped. The subject of the charge was temporarily stopped. If it had been permanently stopped all the timber, rails, and accessories in the working would be taken out. He was at the inquest on the death of Byrne and Irving, and thought he heard McKenzie say he last inspected the back drift on January 23rd. Todd, he thought, said he had not been in since January 8th. Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: He had been manager at this pit for nine months and at other pits for five years. He had had a manager's certificate for nine or ten years. The under-manager was Thomas Atkinson, and there were four deputies. Todd and McKenzie were deputies at this pit when he came, and he did not know that Todd had been a deputy for ten or eleven years and McKenzie for three years. He had no reason to doubt this. He agreed that they were excellent workmen and still were employed as deputies at the Montreal Pit. There were three deputies on the first shift and one on the back shift, but the work was not equal. The majority of the men were on the morning shift, and on the back shift there were not so many working places to examine. The three deputies on the first shift had to inspect about forty or fifty and about eleven or twelve for the deputy on the back shift. To give them plenty of time, they should inspect the forty or fifty places in an hour and a half. He did not himself see the inspection, but it was the duty of the under-manager, to see to this. Witness knew he did this because he told him so, and also signed the book in which the deputies reported their inspection. Witness inspected the book every day. There was no record to state what time they began and ended their inspection. There ought to be, and he had found fault at their neglect. There was a space in the book for this information, and he had insisted upon it being done; but it was not done. Do you know that instructions were given these men to examine the places only half-an-hour before the shift commences? — The instructions were not given to my knowledge. He never examined this particular place when it was stopped, because he had the deputies and the under-manager to do it. I wonder what your duties are? — I have about a thousand. Do you do ten of then? — I do them all. He laid the information in this case, directed by the General Manager, Mr. Smith, as the result of the evidence given at the inquest by defendants. He was not aware, until then, that the defendants had not inspected the working. The Chairman: Do you know now? Witness said he only knew what they had said. He did not give evidence at the inquest, because he was not asked. The Chairman said the charge was simple, and it was purely a question whether the men made the inspection or not. Why were they labouring? They were not inquiring into the cause of death of the two men, and he did not see why Mr. Atter was introducing all this fresh matter, which, to his mind, had nothing to do with the case. Mr. Atter said the witness was complaining that defendants had neglected their work. According to the Act of Parliament the workings had to be examined within such time, not exceeding two hours before the commencement of a working shift. According to his information instructions were given to these men to examine the place half-an-hour before the commencement of a working shift. He concluded that the men had not time to thoroughly carry out this inspection. The Chairman suggested that if Mr. Atter would keep to the plain facts of the case they would get on much better. Mr. Atter: It is not my wish to extenuate, but rather to exonerate. Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, said he held an inquest on Byrne and Irving on February 15th. Amongst the witnesses called was Samuel Todd. His attention was direct to the back drift, and he said he last inspected it on the 8th January. Defendant said the back drift was all right on that day. He admitted that the place was temporarily stopped. McKenzie also gave evidence, and he said he hadn't inspected the drift since the 23rd January. McKenzie said he didn't inspect the place because he thought it was permanently stopped. By Mr. Atter: Todd didn't know the place was stopped for gas. McKenzie said he didn't think it was going to be worked again the way it had been worked. John Venables, Asby, miner at Montreal Colliery, said he was working on the shift of Byrne and Irving, and he thought there would be about a yard left between the working and the back drift. He spoke to Byrne when he was coming out, and said he thought the coal was working rather easy. McKenzie said he had been a deputy at Montreal Mine for the last three years, and before that worked about six years at the pit. He had never been charged with anything previous to this. He was on the second shift when the working — subject of the charge — was stopped, and the last time he examined it was about seven days before the accident. He thought the place was permanently stopped, because it was a poor place for getting coal out. Cross-examined by Mr. Curwen: He had never complained to the manager, that he had not time to make his inspections, but had nothing to do with this case. Todd said he had been a deputy at Montreal Mines about twelve years, and had worked at the pit 27 or 28 years. He had never been charged with anything until this affair. Thos. Atkinson, the undermanager, gave him his instructions, and he told him to make his inspections half-an-hour before the commencement of the working shift. In former times they examined an hour and a half earlier. When they inspected places they left a chalked mark and their initials for the benefit of the under-manager, to show him that they had been there. He last inspected the back drift on the 8th January, and he did not examine it after that because he thought it was permanently stopped as a working place. His impression of a temporarily stopped place was one where men were working and were stopped on account of some obstructions. There was no obstruction in this place. The ventilation was taken off to a certain extent, and was lowered so much, that it made it impossible to make an inspection; gas would accumulate and there would be so much gas in that it would not have been safe to examine it. He never had a complaint from either Mr. Atkinson or Mr. Brown, as to why he had not made an inspection. He thought, under the conditions, that he should have been informed that holing was going to take place, and he would have prepared the place and examined it. He had seen places temporarily stopped, and the timber had not been taken out at once. He was never told that the place was going to be worked again. Cross-examined by Mr. Curwen: He had never complained that he had not sufficient time to examine the workings. He had never known a place permanently stopped, and having a pipe, through which air was being pumped, left in. This was the case in this working. Venables told him that they would not be holing through. Knowing this; don't you think that it was most important to examine the place when you suspected gas? Defendant said he didn't examine it, because he did not think it was his duty. He thought it was Atkinson's duty, seeing that he was the superior. This concluded the defence. The Bench retired, and on their return, the Chairman said: We find the case proved against both of these defendants, and we order them each to pay a fine of £3, or one month's imprisonment.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||