|
17th February 1916 The Montreal Pit FatalityAdjourned Inquest At Cleator MoorOn Tuesday afternoon, Mr. G. A. L. Skerry, coroner for the Lordship of Egremont, held the adjourned inquest on James Byrne and George Irving, who were found dead in their working in Stirling's Montreal coal mine, Cleator Moor, on the night of Tuesday, February 1st. Mr. J. Steele was foreman of the jury, and there were also present: Mr. Granville Poole (Newcastle-on-Tyne) and Mr. G. Cook (Whitehaven), H.M Inspectors of Mines; O. F. Ormrod, representing the executors of Mr. Stirling (deceased), owners of the mines; and T. Cape, on behalf of the relatives of the deceased. William Ward, coalminer, 29, Cross North Street, Cleator Moor, with whom James Byrne lodged, and worked at the same colliery, said that on Tuesday, February 1st, he was on the afternoon shift and descended the pit at two o'clock with Byrne. He was driving from the "bannock" to the 5ft seam. Byrne and Irving, who were working together, passed witness about 150 yards down the main band "dib" about twenty-five minutes to three. They were going to their working place in the "bannock" band, to commence work. He was working about fifty yards from them and would start to work at a quarter past three. He could see Irving trailing coal. He saw them both with the deputy Samuel McKenzie at the "flat sheets" about five o'clock. There had been some shots fired in their working place by the deputy, and they were waiting until the smoke got out. Witness asked them how things were doing and they said "All right." He was talking to them, maybe three minutes, and they then went back to their work. The deputy proceeded on his journey to other workings. About 6-30 p.m. Witness saw Byrne and Irving at the bottom of the brake; they were sitting eating their "bait." Witness spoke to Byrne and said "How's things going tonight, Jim?" and he replied, "Grand." After that time he saw coming out with tubs again, and at seven o'clock go into his working with an empty tub. Witness told him to keep in because he was going to blast. Irving was trailing after seven o'clock and up to half past seven, but after that witness did not see him nor Byrne again. As they did not come out of their working; they were a long time in casting coal, because the shift was going to be up. Witness got uneasy about a quarter to nine. He thought their absence rather odd, and he asked William Gilhooley if "those men were not going to make a start tonight." He replied, "They're a long time," so witness said he would go and see what was up; he was getting uneasy. He looked at his watch and saw it was between a quarter and ten minutes to nine. He went to the deceased's working place, and Gilhooley waited outside. Witness shouted "Helloa there!" but got no answer. He went on a dozen yards or so. All was in darkness, and he shouted again, but still got no answer. He had a lamp with him and it showed gas, so he went back. At this point a plan of the working was produced and explained to the jury by Mr. Duncan Robertson, surveyor at Stirling's mines. Continuing, Ward said that when he returned he went to the bottom of the brake, out on to the platform, with the intention of asking the boys if they had seen Irving or Byrne. The deputy (Samuel McKenzie) came up, and witness asked him if he had seen Byrne or Irving. He said he had not, and witness told him he was afraid it was a bad job, as all was in darkness in their working and he could not see them. With the deputy, who headed the way, he went back to deceased's working place. The deputy went in and came out with Byrne in his arms. He gave him over to witness, who took him on to the "flat sheets," at the entrance of their working. The deputy went in for Irving, and with the assistance of witness, brought him out. They were both quite dead and very cold. Witness tried artificial respiration, but there was not the least sign of life in either man. Gilhooley sent for a tram and both bodies were placed on the tram and taken to the "dib." Dr. Eaton was at the surface when they arrived up, about ten minutes past ten. Witness knew nothing about ambulance, but David Costine, who was an ambulance man, said it was no use doing anything, as deceased were "beyond aid." Witness had worked at Stirling's mines for twenty-nine years and knew every part of it very well. Gas had been found in the workings when the seam was opened out, but not of late. There were no serious injuries on either the deceased men, and witness's opinion was that they had been gassed. He had had experience of gas himself. His lamp showed signs of less gas on his second visit to deceased's working, but there was gas there. By Mr. Poole: Shots were fired in deceased's working about half past four, Byrne said afterwards that the compressed air was better that day than it had been. They were working in the back drift, and were expecting to hole through. They were driving for this purpose, but they said nothing to witness about it. Byrne said it was rather warm work, but it was good. By Mr. Cape: He did not see the first shift deputy that day. He fired his own shots and had a permit. There were places unoccupied in that district, but he did not know why. There were complaints about ventilation at first, but not now nor some time before accident. By Mr. Ormrod: If they found any gas they reported it to the deputy or the manager. It was not an uncommon thing to find gas; they had simply to report it and get rid of it. By Mr. Murphy (juror): The method of ventilation was by compressed air. There was never any suspicions that there was gas in this place — at least Byrne, his brother-in-law, had never complained. William Gilhooley, of Keekle Terrace, and a labourer with Ward at Stirling's, said he had his bait at 6-30 p.m. On February 1st with Irving and Byrne. There was nothing said about the working. Again, about half-past seven, he saw them but never spoke about the working. He did not see them again, although he went along the brake every ten minutes. He went in for Irving's tub when he thought he was not using it himself. He found it standing empty on the "flat sheets." He saw there was no light in the deceased's working and he told Ward, who got rather anxious; ultimately going himself into the working. Witness did not go into the working again. By the Inspector: That was about 8-30 or twenty minutes to nine. By Mr. Ormrod: Only five minutes would elapse between the time he returned to Ward with the tub and Ward going into deceased's working. Samuel Todd, 90, Birks-road, Cleator Moor, and a deputy at Montreal Colliery, on being questioned by the Inspector, said he inspected all the workings on February 1st. He did not inspect the back drift because it was knocked off since January 8th. His report on the 1st February said, "No gas, except in 115 place up gantry wheel." Gas might have been there and him not see it. His second report was that there was no gas. After the place was stopped the compressed air was reduced. They used air drills, and when the pressure was low the machines were sometimes stopped. He did not know that places, which were temporarily stopped, had to be inspected on the fore shift. The Inspector read the section of the Act which provided that all working places in which work is temporarily stopped shall be inspected. Witness: I think I have read that section. The Inspector: But you did not quite understand it, probably? Witness said he did not know this place (the back drift) was temporarily stopped; he thought they were going to work on the other side. The Inspector: But it was temporarily stopped because according to what you say you anticipated that it was going to be worked in two months time. Witness, replying further, said he was now inspecting places which were temporarily stopped. He always expected gas and prepared himself for it. This place had been given the full quality of air. He did not know what the distance was through to the back drift. The Inspector: And yet you allowed shots to be fired there. Witness: yes, but not that day. Did no one tell you what the distance was through to the back drift? — I did hear someone talking about it. Did it never strike you that it would be desirable to go round and give them a knock on the far side? — I did not expect it holing so suddenly. When you met the deputy of the other shift did he not give you any information about the back drift? — No, sir. Did the air pipes go up to that place? — No, sir. Mr. Cape: Why was the working at the back drift stopped? — Because it was a disadvantage for the workmen getting coal out. Was it not stopped on an account of bad ventilation and gas? — Not that I know of. When did you last examine the place? — On January 8th. And not since? — No. Surely, seeing that this place was a district known to have gas in it would (it not) have been wise to examine it, especially as this place was going to be holed into. Did the management say anything to you about it or give you special orders to take precautions? Witness said he had heard them talking about keeping an eye on the place, but he had no special orders. No.115 was between 30 and 40 yards away from the place where the accident happened. It was in the same ventilating area. He always expected to find some gas in these places. Mr. Cape: Then does it not stand to reason that if gas was liable to accumulate in these places it would accumulate more rapidly in a place that was standing? — Yes. Yet while you thought it wise to be cautious in a place where they were working you never thought it wise to inspect this place which was going to be holed into? — I did not examine it, anyhow. In further reply to Mr. Cape, witness said that the place was fenced off, and he had made one or two reports. He did not let the men out of No.115 go into their working until it was clear of gas. Mr. Cape: Can you tell me what method you have of passing men into their working places? How do you let the men know if their places are all right before they go in? Witness said he reported to the deputy coming in. He did not examine the men's lamps that day. The back shift deputy would do that. You made an inspection that morning and found gas in 115? — Yes. If that gas had remained in 115 in what way would you have conveyed the fact to the men belonging to that place, and going on the back shift? — The gas was not there for the back shift. I got it cleared. You always find gas on the first shift? — Yes; and we always clear it out. How? — With pipes. Were these men on the back shift allowed to go into the place without any deputy giving them any orders whatever? — That is the way they go in likely, but if that place had not been cleared I should have stopped them. But they would have to take their chance likely if you were not there. Do you think that is a proper manner in which to conduct a mine? — I'm not sure. By a juror (Mr. Murphy): He had never seen a case like this one before. He had no suspicion that the men were so near holing through. He had no plan or measurement. Mr. Ormrod: I am told you deputies always meet when you are changing your shift? — Yes, but on this particular day I was late. You are always supposed to meet the other deputy? — Yes, I generally meet him every day. Mr. Ormrod: You did not make that clear to Mr. Cape. Mr. Cape: But you have made it clear for him. Replying to further questions, witness said sometimes he met the other deputy going out and sometimes at the pit top. Questioned upon his reports of gas in the report book and the rules concerning the same, witness repeated that he did not know that the place referred to was temporarily stopped. Asked if Mr. Atkinson, the under manager, told him the week before that it was expected to hole through the place, witness replied in the affirmative. He told witness to be careful in firing shots. Mr. Ormrod: And you knew it was dangerous, and you did not report it in your book? — I did not think it would be dangerous. Samuel McKenzie, Main-street, Frizington, said he was a deputy at Montreal Colliery, and was on the second shift — from two o'clock to ten — on the 1st February. He was in Byrne's and Irving's working place about 4-30 p.m. And examined it. He found all right and fired two shots. He went back after the shots were fired and found all right. He tested the place for gas with his lamp, but found none. He thought the men would be getting near the back drift by that time, but he did not think there would be any danger in holing into it. The shots were fired off the side. He did not think there was any need to be careful in getting through the back drift. He thought there might be a little gas in but he did not think it would be dangerous. He did not say anything to the men about holing through. The last time he inspected the back drift was on the 23rd January, and the place was clear of gas. They had full pressure of air on that day, and that would keep the place clear. Between the men stopping work and the 23rd January he was in the place once. He just looked in to see what it was like, but he did not make any special examination. When he went into the working place with Ward on the night of February 1st he found both Byrne and Irving lying on the floor. He brought them out; he thought they were quite dead. He rubbed them, but they were cold. He did feel any effects of gas himself, and took no precautions. It looked very like as if the men had been gassed. There was no fall or anything. His lamp did not show gas. The Foreman: Do you know anything about artificial respiration? — No. The Foreman: I am rather surprised. You ought to. By Mr. Murphy: They had not holed into the disused drift at all. He had no suspicion as to how the gas had accumulated so as to cause the death of the men. The place was holed into the drift but not as the effects of the shot; it must have been done by the men after they fired. By the Inspector: When he was on the fore shift he always inspected places that were temporarily stopped; he thought it was not going to be worked again. He did not know the distance of the bore or how far it had to go before it holed through. He did not measure it. The Inspector: And yet you fired shots? I am very much surprised that you did not take the trouble to measure that bore, to see how far it had to go before it holed through. Further questioned by the Inspector he said Byrne was lying on his face, head down bank, as though he had been trying to get out. He knew that men breathing pure gas became unconscious almost immediately, and he thought this had occurred in this case. He saw the man who worked in the working before that shift, but he said nothing as to how far the drift was holed through. Witness examined it, and thought it was solid. He did not tell the men to be careful. By Mr. Cape: It was a new district, and they could expect gas in a place like that. By Mr. .Cape: And you only seem to have a primitive mode of ventilation. By Mr. Cape: He did not consider it necessary to make an inspection every day. He sounded the place at the forebreast, and it sounded solid. Did you think that was a practical way to see if a place was nearly holed or not? — I would think so. Don't you think it would be a more practical way to have gone round into the back drift, and sounded through to the main working on the other side? — Yes. He thought when he sounded the forebreast that it would have been "drummy" had the men been nearly through. He had no knowledge of ambulance, and only judged that the men were dead from their appearance. He had no instructions from the manager as to this particular place. Mr. Ormrod: Did Mr. Atkinson, the under manager, not tell you on the Friday before the accident that you ought to see the place where the men were going to hole into and also the place where they were working; to examine them carefully, as it was thought it would not be long before it was holed through; to keep the compressed air pipes well up, and to see that it was clear for holing on both sides? — He told me to put the pressure on to the places, but he never told me to examine the place. Surely you did not want to be told to examine the place? — I was not aware that I had to examine the back drift place. You were aware that you had to examine those places that were temporarily stopped? — I did not think this was temporarily stopped. I did not think it was going to be worked again. He was not given a special shift on the Sunday before the accident to clear this particular place. John Venables, 6, Asby, coalminer, said he was working in the deceased's working on the previous shift on February 1st. He did not know how far he was away from the back drift. He did not know what it was like, and he had never been in it. He was not given any instructions about holing into it, and was not told to be careful. No one made any test to see how far they were from it. By the Inspector: He thought the place was near holing when he left, and he told Byrne to be careful and keep it timbered up. There were no shots fired on his shift. He was surprised the morning after the accident when he knew the place was holed through. There was no gas in his working before the accident. By the Foreman: He had been working at Montreal Mines about six weeks. By the Inspector: He told the deputy, Todd, that he thought the place was near holing, because it was working a bit easier. By Mr. Cape: He told the deputy and Byrne the result of his findings on the Monday. The timber was seven feet off the forehead. Is it not a fact that there had been complaints about gas in that district, and that it was badly ventilated? — I have not been there very long. Have you made any complaints? — No. Michael Burns, 15, Ennerdale Road, Cleator Moor, working in the dib at Montreal Mine, said, in reply to Mr. Cape, that he worked in the back drift, but was not brought out on account of gas. He had no complaints while there about gas. By the Foreman: He had been well acquainted with the place for some years. Thos. Atkinson, under manager, of the Montreal Colliery, in reply to Mr. Ormrod, said he was not on duty at the time of the accident. The deputy in charge was named Samuel McKenzie. With regard to the system of passing in the men, the deputies were expected to meet each other at some part before the men got to their working place so that they could explain if anything had gone amiss. On the Friday before the accident, witness mentioned to McKenzie about keeping the pipes well to the face, as very surely they would hole either that week or the next. He told him to keep the place well ventilated. For three Sundays before the accident men had been sent in to ventilate the place as well as to attend to other work. This was done because of the long stand between Saturday and Monday morning, and the full quantity of air was turned on the respective places. He felt sure that this would clear any gas away. With regard to places temporarily stopped he expected that the deputies would examine them. By the Inspector: He did not know why the deputies did not go into the back drift every day. He did not go into the back drift himself during the time it was left. Asked if he was quite satisfied about it, witness said that he had such faith in his men that he thought they would put sufficient air in, and there would be no danger at all. Were you quite satisfied that the single brattice sheet was quite sufficient between the intact and the return? — Yes, if it was kept tight. We had made arrangements for two doors to be made, and we were meaning to put them on. The Inspector: That is better, certainly. Probably if the doors had been fixed the gas would have been drawn directly into the return. — Yes, it would have been — with the pressure as well. By Mr. Cape: This district was opened really under his supervision. He did not know that it made a lot of gas. He knew it made a little. There was no bad roof there. Why take all these special precautions if it did not make any gas, and there was no bad roof? — We took the precautions to ventilate. It took half an hour with full pressure of air to clear what little gas there was. There was likely to be more accumulation during the weekends than during any intervals between the shifts, and he thought that warranted him in giving special instructions in view of the holing. Assuming you gave the deputy so many instructions, as under manager don't you think it would have been better if you had given it some extra attention as well? — I gave it all I could, I have had a lot of trouble with the haulage and the main road. The haulage system that we have I don't know whether it suits that district, and I have had a lot of trouble. Well that frequently happens in a pit. They are not a drawing room, you know. — I think we have more there than other places. Don't you think that a new district that gives off gas, and is ventilated in a manner that this one was, that you ought to have given it your immediate attention? — Yes. But you did not do it. — Oh, yes, I did. But you say you were never in the back drift all the time it was standing? — Not to this particular place. Were you in the place where the accident happened, before the accident? — Yes, on the Monday morning — the day previous. He knew then that the place was near holing. Mr. Cape: As under manager, did you not think it wise to go and inspect that place which going to be holed into? — I did not think there would have been any danger, if the pipes had been turned on as they ought to have been. But you did not go to see? — No. And you did not instruct the deputy? — I instructed him on the Friday. By the Coroner: He went into the places himself when he could and made inspections. He did not test the deputies about this particular place, and went to look for the marks they put up in the districts. By Mr. Murphy: They had a meeting place for the examination of lamps and for keeping the report book. He looked through the reports there in the morning, and got information about places that had been examined. On that particular day the deputies seemed to have passed each other without giving their reports. As a rule they always expected them to meet. The Coroner said the facts seemed to be very simple, and he thought and he thought the jury would be able to find very easily the cause of death of the unfortunate men. There was no doubt, he thought, that the men had been gassed with the gas coming through from the back drift, which evidently had not been inspected properly. One deputy said that the last time he was in the place was nine days before the accident, and the other stated that he was last in about 24 days before. Gas, he supposed, had been accumulating in any event, since January 23rd, and it came through as soon as the back drift was holed into, with the result that the two men were rendered unconscious at once, and, nobody then going near them, probably they were dead by the time they were pulled out, though no very good test seemed to have been made to ascertain whether there was any possibility of artificial respiration bringing them round again. According to the Mines Act, the back drift should have been inspected. The section of the Act dealing with the matter said that not only working places must be inspected every day, but also working places which were temporarily stopped, but the reason the witnesses gave for not inspecting the back drift was that they considered it was permanently stopped simply because the men were not going to be working through that end again or in the same way as before. But, evidently, the deputies knew the drift was going to be holed into or joined up with the new working, and therefore, it seemed to him (the Coroner) quite necessary that it should be inspected. The jury considered their verdict in camera, and found that Byrne, and Irving were accidentally suffocated by gas. They added that while they did not consider anyone criminally responsible they thought due precaution was not taken to keep the back drift clear of gas. They also considered that it was a pity the deputies had no ambulance knowledge. Mr. Ormrod, on behalf of the owners, expressed their keen regret at the sad fatality, and asked Mr. Cape to convey their expression to the relatives of the men. The mine, added Mr. Ormrod, had been singularly immune from fatal accidents for some years, and this, he thought, made the owners feel this sad occurrence all the more keenly. Mr. Cape said he would convey Mr. Ormrod's expressions of sympathy on behalf of the employers to the relatives of the deceased men. He had had five or six years close connection with the colliery, and it was the first fatality in his time. The two men he might say were always looked upon as very good workmen and very genial and good men. Mr. Ormrod: I intended to say that they were both excellent workmen. The Foreman: Perhaps Mr. Cape will convey the sympathy of the jury to the relatives as well. The deceased men were known to most of us.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||