|
10th February 1916 Fatal Accident At EgremontThe Inquest OpenedOn Thursday evening, at the Whitehaven and West Cumberland Infirmary Mr. E. Atter (coroner) and a jury of which Councillor R. Wilson was chosen foreman, opened the inquiry into the death of Wm. Mitchell, 42 years of age, and a widower, of 36 Croft Terrace, Egremont, which occurred the aforementioned Institution shortly after his admission on Wednesday afternoon, suffering from injuries received as the result of an accident at Sir John Pit, Bigrigg, that afternoon. The facts of the accident, as reported to the Coroner, show that deceased who was for many years a winding engineman, but had of late been employed as a shiftsman, was apparently in his usual health when he descended the mine about six a.m., on Wednesday. He first of all prepared some engine bed in one of the main passages, and was working alone. He was visited by the Manager, Mr. Robert Wilkinson, of Moor Row, about 6.30 a.m., as a skilled and reliable worker, reported all in good order. About 12.30 a.m., as Mr. Edward Ratcliffe, mine-overman, of Moor Row, was talking to deceased, concerning his work, when a large piece of metal dropped suddenly from the roof, fell on Mitchell. Ratcliffe seeing that deceased had sustained injuries called for the assistance of Mr. Jas. Wilkinson and Mr. Forbes Farragher, both of Cleator Moor. They had the unfortunate man removed to the surface, and Dr. Jackson, of Egremont, who was immediately summoned, found that deceased had a fractured skull. He was removed with as little delay as possible to the Whitehaven Infirmary, and expired shortly after his admission. Blasting in the locality of the fall had been in progress on Tuesday, but no shots were fired on the day of the accident. There appeared, the report continued, no room to doubt that death was directly attributable to the injuries accidentally sustained by the fall of metal on his head. Wilson Mitchell, iron-ore worker, of Spring Gardens, Egremont, and brother of Wm. Mitchell, gave evidence of identification, and in reply to the Foreman said his brother had a daughter in the Infirmary at present, undergoing an operation. The Foreman: I am sure we all sympathise with you, on behalf of the family. Witness: Thank you. The Foreman: There is a large family is there not? Witness: Five. The Foreman: And, no mother? Witness: No. To allow the attendance of Mr. Leck, H.M.I.M. the inquiry was adjourned until Saturday morning, when it will be held in the Court House, at 11.30 a.m. The Adjourned Inquiry. The jury resumed the inquiry into the death of Wm. Mitchell, at the Court House, Whitehaven, was resumed on Saturday morning, before Mr. Edward Atter (the coroner) on Saturday morning last, Major Hope Brown representing the Bigrigg Mining Co.; Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines; and Mr. T. Gavan Duffy, for the deceased relatives, were present. Mr. W. Dixon produced a plan which had been prepared under supervision, showing the working just before the time of the accident, sinking for an electric engine at the bottom of the pit. Robert Wilkinson, Scalegill Road, Moor Row, said he had been the manager at Sir John Pit, Bigrigg, for about eleven years. Deceased worked under him 25 years ago, and also at Sir John Pit, and he was a very reliable, capable workman. On the day of the accident, about half-past six in the morning, he saw deceased bailing water in the working. He asked him if all was right above him and he said all was right, but the water was a nuisance. There was blasting in progress in that place the previous evening, but not on the day of the accident. Witness was down the pit immediately after the accident, and saw deceased, who was very well attended to. The under-manager was present, and got assistance and bandages. Witness got a stretcher, but in the meantime the men had improvised a stretcher and got deceased to the bottom of the shaft. Dr. Jackson was on the scene very quickly, and had deceased removed to the Infirmary. After the accident witness found that large pieces of metal had fallen from the roof, it seemed rather a mystery how it had happened, as it was a particularly safe place. There had been no inspection of the place after the blasting the previous evening. It was not the rule, as shiftsmen attended to their own workings. Deceased worked alone, but generally two men had worked in the place. By the Inspector: he was sinking a foundation to put up an air compressor to be worked by electricity. There was no timbering in that place; it was all very solid ground. The object of selecting that place for machinery was because it was considered a very safe place. Mitchell had not blasted any that morning. The man who fired the hole in the previous shift was present in court. It was the rule to inspect after a firing a hole. Deceased was a competent man. By Mr. Duffy: Witness was in the pit every day, and there was practically no work that was not done under his supervision. The roof in this place was particularly good, and it was not a place where they expected a fall. There was a bit of "slape" on the side of the metal that fell. Witness would not send any men to a place where he would not go himself. Edward Ratcliffe, Penzance Street, Moor Row, overman at Sir John Pit, said that on Wednesday he saw deceased by himself about half-past twelve. He was boring a hole. Witness turned his lamp on the roof, which was 13 foot in height, and examined it. It was sufficient examination in this case. The roof before a hole was blasted in this place. The roof should have been examined after blasting, and he thought Jos. Rumney, who blasted the hole, would examine it. Witness was talking to deceased, who asked him where he should bore another hole. Witness showed him where, and just then the metal fell, and hit deceased on the head. Witness was about six feet away from deceased. The fall did not give any warning. Witness called on men near to help him, and they lifted deceased out. He could come to no conclusion except that when the shots were fired in the hole, some of the stuff, together with the water in the hole, had been blown up to the roof, and might have loosened the piece of metal. By the Inspector: The men in the nearest working were about forty feet away. There were plenty of ladders for getting up to the roof to examine it. The witness examined the roof with a carbide lamp, which gave off a brilliant light. The roof was tried before they started to work in the place; there was no water coming from the roof. By Mr. Duffy: The overmen were quite familiar with the roof, and often examine it with acetylene lamps. There was nothing about it to make witness suspicious; if there had been he would had got a ladder and examined therefore if Mitchell had just finished boring a hole when witness got into the working. He thought the blasting on the previous night must have loosened the metal. By the Foreman: It was a big surprise to them that the metal came down. Joseph Rumney, Scalegill Road, Moor Row, said he was on the afternoon shift, the day before the accident occurred, and he blasted a hole left for him by deceased, about nine o'clock on Tuesday night. [The accident was on Wednesday]. After blasting, he examined the place well with a carbide lamp, and found all safe and right. The Coroner: Was the roof sounded after the blasting? — Yes, sir, you have to every time. Did you do it? — Yes Sir, just after the blasting at nine o'clock. What with? — A carbide lamp. Was that sufficient? — Yes, I thought so. It seemed all right. Had there been any blasting before Tuesday in that place? — No, sir. What do you think caused this fall? — Well the only thing I can account for is that this "sumping" hole throwing stuff up to the roof, might have shaken the piece of ground. Had you more charge in this than usual? — No, sir, I had five cartridges in it. That was about the ordinary charge; not an especially heavy charge. The Inspector: How long have been working as a shiftsman? — About six and a half years and I have been a miner for all my life, at Cleator, Woodend, and Bigrigg mines. By the Inspector: He had been working at this particular "sump" about four or five days. It was close by the travelling road. Before he started the working and on the instructions of Mr,. Wilkinson, he took a ladder and examined the roof and then dressed it down. In fact there was nothing to dress, it was so safe. The roof was of strong metal. On his last examination he did not use a ladder or bar, but just used the carbide lamps. The Inspector: Looking at it now, after the event — don't you think if you had examined it with a ladder, after firing, that you would have detected that this lump was not sound? — Well, maybe I might. The Inspector: Lumps don't fall when it is sound? — Yes, you can have a sound place, and lumps might fall. By Mr. Duffy: It was only an assumption on your part about the shots disturbing the roof? — You don't now. It might or it might not have been? — That is so. He put five cartridges in, and this was only a very normal charge. It was very slight. Mr. Duffy: Don't you find that the dynamite is very inferior, so that five cartridges would now be equivalent to two cartridges before the war? — I could not say that. Mr. Duffy: Well, I am told so. This would rather shake the idea that the explosion would do very much harm to a good roof? — Well, you would think so, but it might do that. Mr. Duffy: Do you think it would do much harm to a good roof? — I should not think it would, but, of course, you cannot tell. I had no suspicion about the roof. Mr. Leck: Would this dynamite you charged the hole with be the same that you had been using for the last few weeks or months? — It was the new stuff that we were using for this bed. We had only had it about a week. The Inspector: I thought it was the old stuff you were using? — No, sir. By the Foreman: He considered the St. John Pit a very safe pit, and it was very rare that they had falls of this kind. By Mr. Hogg (a juror): The size of the metal which fell was such that he could nicely fit it in his hands. It was a solid one, and came out like a pocket, right between the cheek. The concussion of the shots and the water together might have caused this piece to fall. It appeared as sound a place as a man could work in. Jas. Williamson, Duke-street, Cleator Moor, said he was working with Forbes Farquhar on the day of the accident, and they and others went immediately to Mitchells assistance after the accident. Dr. Tawse said he attended Mitchell at the Infirmary about twenty minutes past two on Wednesday afternoon. He was unconscious and dying. He had a fracture on both the base and vault of the skull. Death was due to a fracture of the skull, which had caused laceration and haemorrhage of the brain. The Inspector: Would any additional first aid have rendered any service in this case? — No, it was a hopeless case from the beginning. The Inspector, in reply to the Coroner, as to whether he had any remarks to make, said he had often been through the place, and as far as he could see, it seemed safe. It was very strong, solid ore there. The Coroner commented on the satisfactory manner in which the evidence had been given, and said there did not appear to be anyone to blame for this unfortunate accident. One sad thing about the accident was that there was a large family dependent upon Mitchell, who was a widower, and he understood that one of his children was at present in the Infirmary. Major Brown, on behalf of the Company, said they regretted very much the sad accident, which had deprived this poor man's children of their support, and the Company of a very useful, valued servant. Mr. Duffy said he would be glad to convey the expressions of regret to the children of the deceased. He was sure they were not a mere matter of form, because outside the direct relatives of the family no one, he felt sure, regretted the accident more than Mr. Wilkinson, the manger of the mine. He had known Mr. Wilkinson for a good many years, and a more careful and painstaking man, in regard to the safe working of the men, it was impossible to find. The circumstances of case were full of pity. The wife of the deceased died in the Whitehaven Infirmary a short time ago, and a daughter was at present in that institution, unconscious of the fact that her father was dead. There were also three little children, and it was a lamentable thing for them to be left without a father or mother. He was sure that the sympathy of the Company, would be entirely endorsed by the gentlemen of the jury. The Foreman said the jury wished to be associated with the expressions of sympathy.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||