|
23rd December 1915 The Explosion At Wellington PitThe Adjourned InquiryThe adjourned inquiry into the cause of the death of Mark Millican, was resumed on Monday at the Infirmary by Mr. Atter (coroner). There were also present: Messrs G. Cook, H.M. Inspector of Coalmines; J. Hanlon (Miner's agent) for the relatives of the deceased; O. F. Ormrod, representing the Colliery Company; and R. Steele, manager at Wellington Pit. Nichol Nicholson, who appeared bandaged on the head and right eye, with his left arm in a sling, and who is now an inmate of the Infirmary, was the first witness. The Coroner, addressing him, said they were pleased to see him alive, but were very sorry he was injured, and trusted he was making good recovery for getting better. In his evidence he said he resided at 14, Low Church Street, and was 39 years of age. He had worked at Wellington Pit as a collier and stone drifting for about nine years. On the 24th November he went to work about half-past four in the morning (the first shift) and commenced work about a quarter to five. His mate was the deceased, Mark Millican, and they commenced on a stone drift off the Main Band seam. They had worked there since the commencement of the drift. There was no official in that morning to give directions. They were dressing the roof down for safety. About a quarter to six o'clock they commenced boring in the roof and were directed by James Jollow. After about an hour's work deceased and witness examined the face to see where to start boring. Witness had not appointed a shot-firer. They bored with a compressed air machine and no one gave them directions; they used their own judgement. Witness was not at work on the 23rd (the day before) and therefore was not boring. They were boring one hole on the 24th, and deceased held the machine, assisted by witness. As a rule it took two of them to hold it. Witness examined an old socket with a copper scraper and found it to be about two feet six. They had the scrapers in the drift but he did not know who supplied them. He got this one from a manhole. He did not know who worked in the socket before; it was there when they went in. He worked in this place two days previously (Monday) and the hole was not there then. They examined it to see if it was clear. The scraper would have brought anything out of the hole, but the hole was quite solid at the back. They bored in six inches, then stopped the machine and oiled it. They were of opinion that there was nothing in the hole. They started again, and a very short time later there was an explosion. They did not put in a cartridge. There was nothing but stone came out of the hole previous to the explosion. He did not remember anything after the explosion until he was brought out of the drift. His head was injured, and he was rendered unconscious. They did not use any explosive and did not put a cartridge in. What do you think caused the explosion? — My opinion is that there had been an old charge left in the back of the hole and that part of the hole was closed up; that's the reason we found it to be quite solid. By the Inspector: He was the charge man on that shift, but he did not see the charge man on the previous shift before he went in. There was no message left by the previous shift. They examined the place before they started work. He did not know whether a deputy had been in that morning. At the face they did not find anything particular. They found this hole, and it was two feet six inches. They had to pull nothing out; it was quite clear. They did not feel anything at the back when they used the scraper. He was sure it was quite solid. The borings were nothing but stone, and he was positive there was no explosives in it. They used "Viking" explosive, and it was more like salt than stone. They could not have mistaken it because they were on blue stone, and the borings did not come out almost like flour. They stopped drilling after they had gone six inches to oil the machine. It was hard boring before that, and after oiling it he could not say how far they went; probably a couple of inches. They had full air pressure on the drill at the time. The drillings they got out were not like "stemmings." They went straight in and must have drilled into whatever was in the hole. It was stone for the first six inches and was solid. The drill went quite easy. By the Coroner: They had an electric lamp. By the Inspector: It was not usual to commence holes in old sockets, and was very dangerous if there was anything in them. They found out by examining it. When they were drilling the stone felt quite solid. They had not used any explosive that morning. They did so on the Monday, and it was in good condition. He could not say where the explosive came from. There was nothing lying about in the stone; the face was clear before they started. By Mr. Hanlon: It was the custom to see the deputy before they commenced on a hole. Mr. Jollow did not say anything to them. He had no idea as to how many shots had been fired on the previous shift. He thought that the hole had been fired and the socket left. As a rule they put a hole about six inches alongside the old socket, and it was wrong to go into the old socket. No one suggested to them that it was not safe. Sometimes an explosive might be faulty and leave something in the hole. He had no idea that any explosive or detonator were in the hole. He did not think the shot came right out of the hole; he thought it struck him sideways. There was no mark on the roof to show them that the hole was there. He did not know whether any instructions were given about the hole. By the Coroner: Witness had charge and deceased would have to obey his directions. There was always something to show if a shot had gone off, and on this occasion there was no trace of anything to show whether the shot had gone off. By Mr. Ormrod: Knox, the deputy, examined witness's lamp and he did not remember Quayle passing him; it was a sign that the working was in a satisfactory condition. Mr. Ormrod said there were no regulations to prevent them drilling an old hole. The regulations were with regard to misfires. Witness, answering Mr. Ormrod, said there was nothing to show them that the shot had fired, but the depth of the socket was sufficient evidence to show that the shot had exploded. If you had been drilling this hole would it not have been five feet deep before you put a charge in, and the fact of the short depth showed that the charge had gone off? Witness: Yes. He was the man to decide where the hole was to be bored. By the Foreman: There was no trace of any wires in the hole, and witness was quite taken in when the shot went off. Mr. Hanlon (through the Coroner): What were the symptoms to show you that the shot had gone off? As a rule it leaves a smoky nature round the hole. He did see some of that on the hole. The Coroner: What do you think caused the explosion? An old charge in the hole. Where do you think it came from? I could not say. Do you think it would from another hole? I could not say. The only conclusion that I can come to was that the hole had been closed up by and old charge. If there had been a misfire it was always notified. The Coroner, on dismissing the witness, hope he would speedily thoroughly regain his health, and wished him the compliments of the season. Dr. Harris said he first saw deceased on the morning of the accident between eight and half past eight at the pit. He was perfectly conscious and was peppered over the face. He had a big hole in the root of the neck, a wound in the abdomen, and his right arm was injured. He was more or less peppered over the whole of the body, but on the left more than the right. He was brought to the Infirmary, and was under witness's care until his death on the 13th December. During the first twenty-four hours he was in imminent danger of dying from shock, and after a time septic pneumonia set in, of which he died. He did not make any statements to witness as to the occurrence. The cause of death was septic pneumonia, occasioned by septic wounds, which could have been caused by an explosion such as they had heard of. The last witness, Nicholson, was suffering with both eyes very badly injured, and witness had taken a lot of grit and stone out of both eyes. They were all right now, but he had had a very bad ulcer on the right eye. It was witness's opinion that he would get sight in them both. He was making a satisfactory recovery. Witness took a little bit of bright wire about threequarters of an inch in length and bent, out of the deceased's shoulder. By the Inspector: He did not find any small pieces of copper wire. Both men were mostly injured on the left side and the upper part of the body. By the Coroner: The injuries were caused by stone and not by burning. Deceased's wife said he told her on the Thursday after the accident, that it was not his fault. He had been a stone drifter all his life, and was a steady workman. William Henry Johnston, surveyor, produced a plan of the working. James Jollow, Far Preston Hows, contractor at Wellington Pit, said deceased had worked for him about six years and was a steady reliable man. On the 24th November witness was in the working — witness, deceased and Nicholson. Witness told the latter that he had to get ready to put two girders in. They were in the working on the Monday; there was no work on the Tuesday. Deceased did not work on the Monday. Witness was about five or six yards from the deceased at the time of the explosion. It was a quarter to seven when deceased and Nicholson started boring. Witness was working with Johnston, and Walton was also near, filling metal. Witness was sitting on the scaffold, and after the explosion he was knocked off and that was all he could tell them. He was hit on the leg and side, Witness did not notice the hole in the facing, and did not see Nicholson scraping. The Colliery Company supplied the explosive. He did not know there was a hole. By the Inspector: He examined the face, but did not notice any holes. He had a casual look round. He did not see the foreman of the previous shift, but if there had been a misfire hole in the previous shift there would have been a message left. They had not had any trouble before with the explosives. They used two detonators, one to fall back upon, and they coupled them singly. If the first happened to fire one might be left unexploded? Not when they are on the same cap. Is there any special reason why they should have commenced drilling in an old socket? Not al all, sir. Previous to this day they made a report about charges — about six weeks since — and since that there had not been any cause for complaint. They had not had a frozen explosive this winter. He had not seen any, and could not say whether this would be a dangerous explosive. This explosive was of a salt type and like stone drilling. They usually used dynamite. Are you are aware that these explosive can be fired by the striking with a metal object. I can't say. I have not seen any. It would be dangerous to start drilling near to one? By Mr. Hanlon: He would have stopped them boring an old hole if he had seen them, but he did not know where the hole was that they were boring. He had no idea what number of shots had been fired on the Tuesday. He had not seen a more careful man than deceased in the pit. By Mr. Ormrod: They passed Knox, the deputy, when going in that day. Quayle (deputy) was on the back shift that day. The chargeman chose the direction of the hole and drilled it, and the shot-firer was there to fire it. He could not form any theory as to the cause of the explosion. He could not say whether it was in the socket or whether they came across stuff in another hole which had not exploded. It was no advantage to a man to bore into an old socket. What would you have done? Did they do right or wrong in using this copper scraper? I would have put the copper scraper in, but would not have drilled the hole, because I do not think it would have been an advantage. Is it a danger? I do not know about it being a danger. If a shot has gone off, you can see for yourself as a rule. From your experience and the experience that these men had, was there anything to show them that there had been a misfire or that a cartridge was in the hole? I don't think there was anything that either of these men could see that there was a misfire, as they were two practical men and would not have risked it if they had thought there was any such thing. There was a risk then in drilling this hole? Oh, yes; the contact with the drill might have caused the explosive to explode. Would you have done the same as these men, or would you have done different? I should very likely have done the same if I was satisfied I was at the bottom of the hole. How would you have found out? I would have used the scraper. What then, in your opinion, caused this explosion? It would be the concussion of the drill striking in the hole, and there must have been a cartridge or something left in, or it would never have exploded. I suppose the man who fired the hole with the cartridges would not know whether there had been a misfire or not? Ought it not to have been reported? Who was the man in charge? Well, Preston was my chargeman. Supposing there had been a misfire in the hole, who would be the man who put the cartridge in? Preston or Fitzsimons. What time would they leave their work? About twenty minutes to two on Wednesday morning. We were not in then. Now about the explosive. Is it inferior since the war broke out than it was before? Oh, yes. It is not as strong as it was before the war. The last few months it has been a good deal worse. More likely for misfiring? Yes. I have seen half a cartridge left in the hole and has not exploded, but since Mr. Steel made a complaint about it, it has been better stuff. How long is that ago? About two months. Henry Preston, 6, James Place, Whitehaven, a chargeman at Wellington Pit, said he had worked for Mr. Jollow for four years, and had been at Wellington Pit about four months. He was on the night shift on the 23rd and left about 2.20am on the 24th. They bored ten holes and fired ten shots on that shift. Every shot went off and exploded. They could tell that by the mark left on the hole. If half a cartridge had been left in the hole they could not tell very well, and it was quite possible. Fitzsimons was the shot-firer. There was no test to find whether the cartridge had fully exploded. It was to his knowledge that half cartridges only had exploded. He had known only one instance in four months. If some of the cartridges had been left in, a drill would have caused an explosion, and it was possible that some had been left in. They all went off, but he could not say whether they fully exploded. By the Inspector: He cleared out the holes before the shots were fired. Five cartridges were left in the right-hand side of the "sump." They thought they had the hole perfectly clear. There was no loose stone lying about, and it was quite up from the floor. They used clay for "stemming." The first two holes, rising and dipping holes, were fired together. They examined the face again and saw nothing that was likely to damage the other two holes which were charged at that time. They fired the left-hand hole next, and he was quite sure that was fired. About two feet of the socket was left on. He tried it with a scraper and saw that the charge had not done its work on account of the length of the socket that was left in. When they had other explosive they had not such a long socket. It showed the hole was too deep for the explosive. If they had had any idea that there was an explosive left, they would have put a hole in alongside of it. The shots were finished at nine pm on the 23rd and witness at 2.20am on the 24th. They did not drop or lose any cartridges. They used two detonators and were put in the last cartridge. By Mr. Hanlon: They never left word about the socket, because it was a very occasional thing. It was plain to be seen. Fitzsimons was the shot-firer, and not Quayle. Witness never looked at the shot-firer's report book. He would not think it wise to bore into the socket as there was a possible fear of something being in. When the shots were finished, the forebreast was cleared and every care used. He could not give any idea as to how the explosion happened, except on account of a stray or faulty cartridge. There might have been some dirt, but they cleared it to the best of their ability. By Mr. Ormrod: The whole of the ten cartridges went off because each hole was marked. The depth of the socket was not inconsistent with a full discharge of a cartridge. By the Foreman: The cartridges were six inches and a half long and were put in a cartridge to the foot. The Coroner commended the witness on the way he had given his evidence. James Fitzsimons, Bentinck's Row, Ginns, Whitehaven, said he had been employed in Wellington Pit for many years. On the 23rd November he was working with the last witness and fired ten shots. All of them went off. The Company supplied the cartridges. One, perhaps, might have been a doubtful cartridge and might not have gone off, but he had not seen it in his experience. He generally raked a hole after firing to see if he could find powder, but he found none. He examined all the holes that night and was certain that there were no detonators left in any of the holes. He could not explain how this explosion happened. It could have happened if there had been any powder left in the hole and the heat of the drill would explode it. He would not think that had happened on this occasion. He had never known such an explosion happened. By the Inspector: He examined the holes with a scraper. If four cartridges exploded on the back of another one, which was left hard in the back of the hole, would it not appear solid? Yes, sir, it might. And putting a scraper in would not tell you that it was there? Well, no; but if I got hold of the powder with the scraper I could easily tell if there was any powder in the hole. By Mr. Hanlon: He did not know there was anything in the hole. The socket was left like that in many a hole. He did not find any wires in the holes; he found nothing but bits of metal. He was satisfied there was nothing in between the stemming, and the stemming was clay. By Mr. Ormrod: The mere fact that the socket being left was not inconsistent with the charge having gone off. He had known this before. John Quayle, 2, West Row, Kells, for seven years a deputy at Wellington Pit, said he commenced work at ten pm on the 23rd November, and remained until five o'clock the next morning. He examined deceased's working at 4.30am on the 24th. He noticed about four drilled holes, and could see that the explosives had been fired. He was not in the pit when the accident happened. He did not see deceased and the other men. By the Inspector: He saw the previous shift, but did not see Preston and his men in the drift, so that they could not report to him. He was deputy of that part. Fitzsimons was acting deputy, and saw the men out. If there was anything to report he would have to report to witness. He had never reported anything about sockets being left on. He had had experience, about a month before the accident, about cartridges being left in the hole. That was found by putting in another hole — the proper procedure. Robert Steel, manager at Wellington Pit, said he was at the pit about half an hour after the accident. He examined the working, but could not come to any opinion as to what caused the explosion. No doubt there must have been an explosion of explosives. The deceased was a first-class workman, very reliable and steady, and one he could trust. He said the same as regards Nicholson, who was the next to be made chargeman. Quayle and Preston were particularly reliable men, and as far as witness knew, all mine regulations were being carried out absolutely to the letter. Is it to your knowledge that the explosives have not been as good lately, as you have previously been accustomed to? Yes; six or seven weeks ago Jollow brought up an explosive cartridge, and it had been in a hole. It was just like a piece of marble on hard rock, with the other cartridges going off, leaving it like that. We have asked for the best, and we have tried repeatedly various explosives, and we cannot get the best. It is much inferior and not half as strong as they used to be. To ensure safety they were diluted, and so their explosive power was reduced. Having heard the evidence, he was of opinion that there must have been an unexploded cartridge left in the back of the hole the deceased and Nicholson were boring. He examined the breast and fore-breast, and it was impossible for any other hole to come in contact with the one they were boring. They would have had to bore another three feet further to have contacted another. He formed a very strong opinion that the explosion was caused by a portion of an explosive being left in the hole. Undoubtedly, and his reason was that the hole was fired there was two feet still left, which proved that three feet was blown off the hole, and judging from other holes, he could not make himself think that other holes had blown away this hole. He was quite sure something had been left in the hole after it was fired. There must have been a remedy for this? Witness said to prevent a repetition of such an accident he had given instructions to all the chargemen and shot-firers that no hole must be started in an old socket, as a precaution of safety. He had given this in writing, so that there would be no mistake in the future. Undoubtedly there must have been part of a cartridge in the hole, and the friction of the drill caused it to explode. The drill would be going about four or five thousand revolutions a minute. Do you in any way blame the men for anything they did? I do not, for I have seen it done scores of times. As regards himself, he attributed no blame to anyone. By the Inspector: After making complaint about explosives, he had no reason to think iot would be better in any way, because it was made according to the "permitted" list. They could not tell by a scraper that a hard cartridge had been left in the back of the hole, and he did not suppose they could tell by a drill — it would become so hard. Everyone knew that the strength of the explosive had been considerably reduced, and he dared say they were getting the quality according to the permitted list. Do you think that the war may have more to do with the quality than the permitted list? Since the permitted list was introduced we have not had a good ---. As to the quality of the explosives. Is it or is it not different since the war began? I don't think there is any difference. The other witnesses say there is. They judge for themselves, but they don't know the quality. Do you agree that it would be better to have a rule in the Coal Mines Act to state no boring is to be started in an old socket? Yes, I do. By Mr. Hanlon: He agreed that an old hole should not be touched and that there should be a rule in the Mines Act to prohibit the starting of a hole in an old socket. The Inspector said there was not a rule in the Coal Mines Act against boring in an old socket, although there was a similar rule in Metalliferous Acts. The Coroner said the statement that had been made by Mr. Steel was one that he thought was a correct one, which he also thought the jury would agree with, that there was no fault to be found on the part of anyone. It was pleasing in one way that the exemption applied to the deceased and the men who were working with him, and Mr. Steel, who did not speak so much for his Company, exonerated them, but the way the evidence had been given, equally cleared them of fault or blame. The jury returned a verdict that deceased died from septic pneumonia, caused by septic wounds, occasioned by an explosion, accidentally caused whilst following his employment at Wellington Pit, on the 24th November. Mr. Ormrod expressed the Company's regret at the occurrence. They had heard Mr. Steel tell how much his services were appreciated, and he wished similar appreciation to come from the Company also. The jury coupled themselves with the remarks made.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||