|
6th November 1915 Barnsley Miner KilledFall of Roof at Wharncliffe WoodmoorDoubt about TimberingEdward Gronwy Evans (27), miner of 11 Southwell Street, Barnsley, died in the Beckett Hospital on Tuesday morning as the result of injuries sustained by a fall of roof in the Wharncliffe Woodmoor Colliery on October 4th. The inquest was held in the Town Hall, Barnsley, on Wednesday afternoon before Mr. P. P. Maitland (Coroner) and was attended by Mr. G. H. Danby (H. M. Inspector of Mines). Evidence of identification was given by the deceased's widow, who said her husband had worked at Wharncliffe Woodmoor about six weeks before meeting with the accident, which occurred on Monday October 4th. Deceased left home about 12.30 in the afternoon and witness heard of the accident about 8 o'clock at night, and though she saw him in the hospital he did not give her any explanation of the accident. Death occurred on Tuesday morning. Milton Jones, miner, 18 Redfearn Street, Barnsley, stated that he and deceased were working together at the time of the accident. Witness was about 23 yards from deceased and they were both getting coal. The deputy visited the place soon after 4 o'clock but made no comment. About 10 minutes past 5, witness heard a fall from the roof, and went to deceased, who was buried by a fall of stone weighing 5 or 6 cwts. He was covered with the exception of his head and shoulders. Deceased was crying out about his back. Witness and a man named King got the stone off him in about 2 or 3 minutes. They got a stretcher and removed deceased to the hospital. Deceased did not tell him anything about the accident, and witness added that there was plenty of timber. He could only see one prop which had come down. The coroner: did you notice what the stone or "muck" came from? — I could not tell you. I have not been in the place since. You cannot account for the fall? — No sir. You did not hear any weight bump? — No, we didn't hear anything. Ralph Winstanley, deputy, 7 Meadow Street, Barnsley, said he had known deceased for six or seven years but had only known him as a worker for six weeks. Deceased appeared to be a good workman. Timber had to be set within 5 feet of the face and 4' 6" apart. On the day of the accident witness visited deceased at ten minutes past 4. At that time there was sufficient timber set. Witness was called back after the accident, and his opinion of it was that in his work deceased liberated a slip which could not have been seen before. Witness had tested the roof and found nothing wrong. If the place had been well timbered would it not have prevented it from falling? — Witness replied that to his mind it was timbered alright. Mr. Samuel Diggle, manager of the colliery, gave evidence as to the accuracy of a plan produced which showed that there was after the accident, a lack of timber at that spot. The coroner: If there was no prop where the deputy said there was, would the absence of that prop at all account for the accident in your opinion? — Witness: that is a difficult question to answer. If there had been a prop there, do you think it would have prevented the fatality? — I could not say. It is an open question whether, if the prop had been there, his life would have been saved? — Yes. Captain Martin, R.A.M.C., house surgeon at the Beckett Hospital, said deceased, when admitted was very much collapsed and had a fractured spine. Death occurred on Tuesday from exhaustion. The coroner said it could not very well be said whether the place was properly timbered. The deputy in his evidence said it was, but the surveyor's plan showed otherwise, and the stone was lifted, and only one prop was found underneath it. He thought this had been a pure accident, and whether the place was sufficiently timbered or not they could not say, but perhaps it was only fair to say that they thought it was, for the deceased was a good workman. The jury returned the following verdict "Died from exhaustion due to a fractured spine, caused accidentally by a fall of stone onto him whilst at work in Wharncliffe Woodmoor".
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||