|
23rd September 1915 Charge Against Belgian Miner Collapses At WhitehavenWitness Slow Witted Or Unmitigated ScoundrelAt the Whitehaven Police Court on Monday, before W. McGowan (chairman), R. Jefferson, and W. H. Watson, Esqs., Antoine Servais (29), a Belgian coalminer, Alabaster Cottage, Sandwith, was charged with having attempted and endeavoured to obtain the sum of seven pence by false pretences from the Whitehaven Colliery Company Ltd, on 3rd September. Mr. W. H. Chapman prosecuted, and Mr. E. Atter defended Mr. Chapman, who appeared on the instructions of the Whitehaven Colliery Company, said the defendant was in the service of the Company, and was of Belgian nationality. To put it in plain language the charge against him was the too familiar one of tub-sticking. After explaining the facts of the case to the Bench, Mr. Chapman said that if defendant told the Bench that he was not guilty of this offence, to him (Mr. Chapman) it would be a pleasure. Defendant belonged to a nationality to whom it had been this country's afforded pleasure to offer refuge, and for whom we had the greatest sympathy, and the fact that he was a Belgian made the case very much more painful than it would have been in ordinary circumstances. If he was guilty he had committed a mean and petty crime, and when these extraordinary occurrences happened at the pits the feeling of the miners was so intense that there was no other option for the Colliery Company but to initiate a prosecution, and have the facts ventilated by the Bench. Theophile Elderts, a Belgian collier, was sworn interpreter. Henry Martin, of Low Road, Whitehaven, said he was a coal-hewer at Ladysmith Pit, and on 3rd September he was working in the Jubilee Bannock Band district, with Edward Bryan and his brother James Martin. Their token number was 74. They went down the pit on the one p.m., shift. Defendant and his mates were working about 300 yards from witness's company, but they had to bring their tubs on to the same brake. About 8.30 witness took a full tub of coal on to the brake, and left it there. It was the first of a new sett being made up, and their token, 74, was on the tub when he left it. The token is a piece of metal bearing a number. Each working party has a number, corresponding with the number on the token. The token is attached to the tub by a cord, fixed to a staple inside the tub, the token hanging on the outside. When the tub arrives at the pit top the checkweighman books the number of the tub to the party working under that number. Witness went back to his working place, and at the end of the shift he and his brother James brought out another two tubs of coal on to the brake, each tub bearing the token 74. (About eighteen tokens are taken down the pit by each working party.) Witness looked at the tub he left at 8.30 p.m., and noticed that token "73" was attached to it. He did not know then whose number it was, but he knew it was defendant's party's. The string was wet. Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: He had worked for the Whitehaven Colliery Company at Ladysmith Pit for eight or nine years. The token numbers changed every quarter, and this was his company's third month for the token 74. The new quarter begins next month. Each company consists of three men, and there are three shifts daily. The system of tokens was the same now as when witness first started. Anyone can get tokens; they are not given out to them. They simply go into the cabin and get as many tokens as they like of their own number. It was possible for anyone to go in the cabin and take another company's token. By the Chairman: There is no one in the cabin when the tokens are taken, and no record is kept of who takes the tokens, and number. Sometimes tokens were lost in the working place. They put their tokens on a nail on a prop in the working place. Each token hangs on a separate string in the cabin, and the string is provided by the Company. The same kind of string is attached to tokens of different numbers. If they have any tokens left after the shift, they leave them in the working. If they get more tubs out than they have tokens they chalk the number inside and out. Mr. Atter: You never borrow tokens from the other workings? (Laughter) — I don't see where the laugh comes in. Witness said they did not borrow tokens. There were 13 or 14 different working places between 73 and 74 working and each would have three workmen. He did not know what other numbers were on the sett with his company's tubs. His company had 17 tubs on 3rd September, and he trailed them. He did not put the tokens on the tubs. He knew defendant had been a shot firer at Ladysmith Pit, but he was not aware that he was a deputy. There were a lot of Belgians at the pit. Mr. Atter: Do you not know that he is the only Belgian deputy at the pit? Witness: No, sir. Mr. Atter: Do you know that there is a lot of jealousy because he has that appointment? Witness: No, sir. Continuing, he said they could do a man great injury through spite, if they changed a man's token and put it on another man's tub. James Martin, Bearmouth Cottage, Low Road, Whitehaven, said he worked with his brother, Henry, and Edward Bryan, on the same shift on 3rd September. Witness put the token "74" on the tub taken out by the last witness, at 8.30 p.m., and fastened it on the staple inside the tub. Shortly after, at the close of the shift, he and his brother brought out two tubs. He then saw that the tub brought out by his brother at 8.30 p.m., (about three-quarters of an hour previous), had the token "73" on it, and that the string was wet. He went back into the working for one of his own company's tokens, and placed it on the tub, also leaving the token "73" on. Thomas Hunter, 5, Low Kells, Whitehaven, said he was an overman at Ladysmith Pit. On the 3rd of September a report was made to him by James Martin, and he went to the brake. He found the first tub of the sett to have two tokens on — "74" and "73." He wrote on the tub that it had to be sided off at the pit top, and had not to be booked to anyone. Richard Kerr, colliery weighman at Ladysmith, and living at Arrowthwaite, said that as the tubs came up the pit a boy called out the numbers on the tub; this was heard by witness and a check-weighman in the cabin, and they entered it on a sheet, to the working party bearing the number. The sheet goes to the Colliery Office for booking purposes. On Saturday, the 4th September, on the report of the last witness, he sided off a tub that came up the pit. The tub had two tokens on it — "73" and "74." The tubs going up on that day were those worked on the one p.m., shift, and on the preceding day. Number "73" had ten tubs credited to them on witness's sheet on the Saturday, and the one tub in dispute would have made eleven. Cross-examined by Mr. Atter: He was not aware, that a fortnight previous to this, defendant and his companions lost seven tubs, and made a complaint. There were so many, both English and Belgians, losing tubs. They would complain to the checkweighman and not witness. Thomas Hutchinson, night shiftman at Ladysmith Pit, and living at Nicholson Lane, Whitehaven, said that on 3rd September he was on the night shift, and was on the brake about nine p.m. He saw defendant and other Belgians (his working party), and also saw Henry and James Martin, who called his attention to the token "73" on the tub. The string on the token was wet. Joseph Curvers, a Belgian, working at Ladysmith Pit, said that on 3rd September he was working with defendant and Lambert Masset in "73" working. He and his mates filled ten tubs that day. Lambert Masset, also a Belgian, working at Ladysmith Pit, said he worked with the last witness and defendant on 3rd September. They filled ten tubs that day. On Saturday, the 4th, he spoke to defendant about the tubs. He told defendant that an Englishman had told him that No."73" had stuck a tub, and asked him "Did you stick a tub?" Defendant said, "No. If somebody says I have stuck a tub I'll kill him." Mr. Atter (to the interpreter): Ask him if he ever took part in digging trenches for the Germans. The interpreter did so, and he replied "He says, not half a minute." Mr. Atter: Has he been in trouble in Belgium before he came here? Interpreter (after questioning witness): He got into a bit of trouble in Belgium before he came here. Mr. Atter: Does he know Bolderson's house, 38, South Row, Kells. Interpreter: He says he does, He lodges next door. Mr. Atter: Did he tell Bolderson he had got into trouble, and was off to London next night? Interpreter: He says he did not. Mr Atter: Did he go to defendant's house on Saturday night and see defendant's wife? Interpreter: He says "Yes." Mr. Atter: Did he ask if defendant would go with him to London? After some conversation between witness and the interpreter witness opened speech in broken English, stating, "If you will excuse me, gentlemen, to tell the truth, I did ask Servais, and the witness actually signed his name to it. In his opening statement, Mr. Chapman said Lambert Masset said that he asked defendant how many tubs their company filled, and defendant replied "Eleven." Masset replied, "No; we only have ten, and if we have eleven, one must have been stuck." He then went so far as to say defendant said, "Yes, it has been; say nothing to the English. I am going back to London; you had better come with me, too." Masset was either slow witted or an unmitigated scoundrel. Under these circumstances he withdrew the case. Mr. Atter said that as publicity had been given to this case he ought to be allowed to give the most emphatic evidence of the accused, who was a most unlikely man to have committed this wrong. He had memorials as to his character. He was 29 years of age, and had been a manager at a coal pit in Belgium. Whilst he had been in England, he had been a deputy at Ladysmith Pit, and this had caused jealousy among some of his companions. The Chairman: Did I understand Mr. Chapman to say he had withdrawn the case? Mr. Chapman said that was so. The Chairman: Is it worth while going on then, Mr. Atter? Mr. Atter said it was a serious charge made against his client on the statements of Masset whose word he (Mr. Atter) had been told, by his character in his own country, would not be accepted. If there was a wrongdoer, he was the man. He made statements whether they were true or not. Whether he was a fool or a rogue his (Mr. Atter's) friend did not know. He did not hesitate in saying that in saying that if any of the defendant's company did change the token this man Masset was the man, and that a most wrongful and cruel charge had been made against his client. Masset had been in trouble in Belgium, and was one who helped the Germans to dig the trenches in August and September last year, instead of being one of our allies, he had been the very opposite. There was jealousy because of defendant's position at the pit, and he (Mr. Atter) suggested that this token had been used for the purpose of personal spite and ill-will, and as regards the defendant, he would swear on oath that he did not stick a tub and was ignorant of the accusation made against him. Mr. Chapman: Can I help matters by saying that the Colliery Company will gladly take Servais back into their employ without the slightest suggestion that as regards this charge, there is anything whatever against his character? Mr. Atter said his client's father died in Belgium in October last, and his brother was killed in July. He got a letter from his mother on the 22nd August asking him to go back; and he was to do so early in September to bring his mother back here with him. If it had not been for this charge, he would have now been in Belgium with his mother. Mr. Chapman: You must not take it that I say the Colliery will take him back without the slightest suggestion that as regards this charge, there is anything whatever against his character. I only assume so. The Clerk: You plead not guilty, Mr. Atter, and consent to jurisdiction? Mr. Atter: Yes. Defendant was sworn, and gave evidence in support of the statements made by Mr. Atter. He produced certificates testifying to his management of pits in Belgium, where he had 700 men under his control. He also produced characters. When questioned as to whether he stuck a tub or not, he said he was not "coward enough" to do so. There was jealousy among his companions at the pit, because he was the only Belgian deputy, and he had offered his resignation to the manager three times and asked to go on as a coal-hagger, but the manager refused to accept it. He knew Masset in Belgium, and lived in the same village. Masset helped the Germans to dig trenches in August and September last year, and he had been in gaol many times. Masset said to him in Bolderson's house on 4th September, "I am going back to London tonight. Will you go back with me? Defendant replied, "No, I have no trouble in Whitehaven; I will stop here." He had four or five witnesses in Court to speak for him if it was required. The Chairman: The Bench dismiss this case.
Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() |
||||||||
|
Mail: Webmaster |
Back |
Home |
Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors Registered Charity No: 1110608 Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022
|
Search |
|
|||