Logo Museum
Museum
Friends of Durham Mining Museum
Events Calendar
e-Books and Books for sale
Photograph Gallery
Document Archive
Main Document Archive
Newspaper Articles
Articles by date
Articles by colliery
Personal name index
Local Record Extracts
D.M.A. Document Archive
Transactions of I.M.E.
Miners' Welfare
N.C.B. Archive
The Colliery Engineer
The Colliery Guardian
Mine & Quarry Engineering
Mining Journal
The Science and Art of Mining
Coal Magazine
Coal News
Coke and Gas
Master Name Index
What's new in the site
Mining
Mining History
Colliery Index
Colliery Maps
Company Overviews
Who's Who
Mineral Information
Managers Certificates
Educational Material
Bibliography
Statistics
Workers/Employee Lists
Notes for Family Historians
War Service information
Disasters
Disaster Reports
Names of those killed
Disasters in the 1700s
Disasters in the 1800s
Disasters in the 1900s
Memorials
Awards for Gallantry
On this day ...

Links to other sites of interest
Industrial Heritage Days Out
Former www.pitwork.net web site

Index to site

Contact and address details

Share Page with Social Media

Share on Facebook

Share with Reddit

Share on Delicious


 Newspaper Articles Index Newspaper Articles 

26th August 1915

The Fatal Mining Accident At Bigrigg

On Thursday afternoon Mr. G. A. L. Skerry and a jury, with Mr. J. Lindow as foreman held the adjourned inquiry on the body of Harold Brunton, killed at Parkhouse Mine, Bigrigg at the Frizington Council Chambers.

Mr. W. Leck, H.M. Inspector of Mines, Mr. J. H. Auld, for the Workington Iron and Steel Company and Mr. T. Gavan-Duffy (for the relatives) were also present.

Albert Roe, 9, Brookside, Cleator, said he was an iron ore miner, and worked at Parkhouse Mine, Bigrigg. He was on the shift from six a.m. to two p.m. on Friday the 13th, with deceased, Thomas Murray and Wm. Fisher. Witness examined the working shortly after six, and when deceased followed him in they both examined the place. Witness with a hammer, and deceased with his eye. They looked round the working for about ten minutes and found it to be practically straight. They went to take their clothes off, and Murray came in, Fisher following on shortly after ........ All four of them then gave the working an eye inspection and found it all right. Witness, Murray, and deceased said it looked quite safe, and the commenced work. Deceased and witness were filling, Murray was boring, and Fisher was trailing. They worked about two hours when a lump of stone and ore came away from the right hand side of the working, nine feet high. Witness did not hear any warning, but saw the lump coming. He shouted to his mates and jumped the bogey, and got away. Murray clung to the wall and Fisher was out with a bogey. Deceased was right under the fall and had not time to get away. He was killed instantly, and his legs and head were covered between one and ten ton of stone and ore. Witness shouted for assistance, and with others tried to liberate him. They had difficulty on account of the fall all being in one piece. It took them from a quarter of an hour to twenty minutes to get it off, and deceased was then quite dead. When they examined the working they could not see the piece that fell; there was a clean face and the piece that fell would be about four feet square. The size of the working would be about fourteen feet by twelve. They sounded the whole of the face and would not miss a part four feet square. It appeared to be a solid side. He could not say how long before there had been any spot tried, but there was no firing on their shift. They know there had been something done on the afternoon shift. He had been at iron ore miner between 31 and 32 years, and thought the working was perfectly safe and sound. He had known places appear like this and afterwards give way so that falls of this nature were one of the dangers miners had to run, nothing could be done but sound the place. There were no temporary precautions in their working and nothing could have prevented the accident. When they first went into the working witness found a note on a shovel inferring to a bit of ground on another road. That was warning all hands going past this road, and was left by Wm. Knipe a deputy. That meant he had been in their working between the shifts. There wasn't a deputy in their working between six and 8-30 a.m. The workings are inspected by a deputy before each shift, and they left notes if they found anything wrong. If there was not a note that meant everything was right.

By the Inspector: Knipe was on the night shift. The side of the working they examined was not the side they were going to work. The fall had come from a soapy back, and when they first saw it there was no indication of a soapy back. They thought the side was solid stone, and now they found it was mixed with ore and stone. Witness had worked at Parkhouse between seven and eight years, and had worked in the part of the pit where the accident happened about two years. He had worked with Brunton about eighteen months, and they were pretty well conversant with the character of the ground there. If it was necessary to put timber in they could have got the timber quite easily.

Mr. Leck: Do you not think that the more ore that is asked for has had the effect of lessening the safety of the mine?

Witness: Not a little, sir.

Mr. Leck: We don't want more ore if we can't have safety.

By Mr. Duffy: If was safer to take the lump down than to timber it up if they knew it was not safe. They made a second examination of the working by eye, just casually, with their mates, but they were satisfied with the first examination.

Wm. Sherwen, 36, Lowther Street, Whitehaven, mining surveyor at Parkhouse, produced a plan he had made of the working where the accident occurred. He calculated the weight of the fall would be about three tons.

Thos. Murray, 35, Duke Street, Cleator Moor, an iron ore miner at Parkhouse, and who said he had been an iron ore miner close on forty years, gave evidence. They came to the conclusion that the working was perfectly safe, and he thought that. Witness was boring a block hole and did not hear the fall give way. One part of it touched his leg, but he got away clear. His light was knocked out, and as the other men had got away he could not see until Roe came back. He heard Roe shout "Harold" (the name of deceased), and when he got no answer witness knew deceased had been caught. Had they known the facing was bad they would have taken it down, but they thought it was all right. They generally got each other's opinion and exchanged views one with the other as to the safety of the working. No one could have seen any danger in this working, and the sounding by hammer would not disclose the danger, which was a parting between the stones. He did not think it was possible to discover this kind of danger. The boring that witness was doing could not have any effect on the fall. No one could have foreseen the danger in this working.

By the Inspector: He had worked at Parkhouse eight years and had worked in this particular working about fifteen months. There were cases where the sounding did not indicate anything although it would not be well to give up sounding, as in ninety nine cases out of a hundred, sounding indicated faulty places. With a very large stone they would not get the "drummy" sound by tapping the place.

By Mr. Duffy: In all his forty years experience he had never come across workmen who did not differ in opinion as to the safety of a working. He had not rehearsed the evidence with anybody before today.

Wm. Knipe, 44, Dalzell-street, Moor Row, a deputy at Parkhouse, said that on Thursday and Friday last he was on the night shift from ten p.m., on Thursday to six a.m. on Friday. He examined the workings during the shift to see if they were safe. The men could see for themselves whether the places were safe. He examined the working place of deceased and the others about five a.m. on the 13th inst. He found it all right and safe. He marked a little place in the roof, which was a bad piece, out of the working on No. 16 road. He examined deceased's working with an iron bar about eight feet in length. He tapped the walls all over and found all right. He had no idea that a piece would become detached and there was no evidence of it. The side seemed sound all round. The piece had come off a slaped back, and its own weight must have brought it down. The examinations would not have helped to loosen it, and he did not know what could have been done to prevent it.

By the Inspector: He had been deputy at Parkhouse about three years. He did not know of any case where he had sounded a working, found it sound, and it shortly afterwards gave away. He thought sounding by hammer was generally sufficient.

By the Coroner: A piece might come suddenly from a slape back, and he did not think the face in this working would have given a "drummy" sound had it been examined at seven o'clock. He thought the piece that had fallen in this case would come without any indication, and sounding over so long would have no effect.

Wm. Davidson, iron ore miner, of Cleator, and working at Parkhouse Mine, said he was on the afternoon shift on the 12th inst. in the same working as that in which deceased and the others worked. When he left the working he examined his working. He left it well and good. A shot was fired about twenty minutes past five, and that was the only shot that was fired. They always reported if there was anything "wrong."

By the Inspector: Two deputies visited the working during the afternoon shift, and the last one was going in as witness and the others were leaving, about a quarter to ten.

Jos. Southam, 13, Springfield Road, Bigrigg, a deputy at Parkhouse, who sounded the working and found it all right, said in reply to the Inspector, he had nothing to suggest with a view to preventing accidents of this kind. He would not suggest a systematic system of timbering.

Mr. Duffy: Don't you really think this long, continuous examination of the working by hammers and bars caused this stone to give way?

Witness: No, I don't.

Mr. Duffy: I should imagine this was the most examined place that existed in an iron ore mine.

The Coroner said the evidence had been pretty straightforward, and there did not seem to have arisen anything which required comment, or which would give the jury any difficulty. The first witness, he considered, very satisfactory, and this witness told a very intelligent account of what happened. He (the Coroner) did not think there was any reason to doubt his statements, as the other witnesses seemed to have corroborated as far as they could. Although there were Acts of Parliament respecting the examination of works, probably in the case of this sort, nothing practically could be done to prevent the accident. If the sides in a mine were timbered all along it would make mining too expensive and probably hamper mining. Then this timbering did not always reveal, and the jury would probably find this an accident that could not be foreseen.

The jury returned a verdict that Brunton was accidentally killed by a fall at Parkhouse Mine.

Mr. Auld said he had been requested by the employers of deceased to say how deeply they regretted that this accident had occurred, as the result of which they had lost the services of one who seemed to have been a very careful and experienced workman and had the esteem of his fellow-workmen and the officials. He was also asked to say that the directors would like their expressions conveyed to the widow and relatives.

Mr. Gavan Duffy: I will undertake to see that this is done, Mr. Coroner.

The Coroner: I hope it will be some consolation to them to know that he was valued in this way, though it is very sad that these accidents should happen.

Newspaper transcript kindly provided by
West Cumbria Mines Research.


Names mentioned in this article

 

 Name  Age  Occupation  Notes 
Auld, J. H.    Solicitor  
Brunton, Harold    Miner  Deceased, Individual Page
Davidson, William    Miner  
Fisher, William    Miner  
Gavan-Duffy, Thomas    Miners' Agent  Whos Who Page
Knipe, William    Deputy  
Leck, William    H.M. Inspector of Mines  Whos Who Page
Lindow, J.    Jury Foreman  
Murray, Thomas    Miner  
Murray, Thomas    Miner  
Roe, Albert    Miner  
Sherwen, William    Mining Surveyor  
Skerry, George Albert Langford    Coroner  Whos Who Page
Southam, Joseph    Deputy  



Links to Collieries/Mines mentioned in this article

 

Park House (Iron Ore)  Park House (Iron Ore)


 

mail
Mail:
Webmaster
Back
Back
Home
Home
Open Government Licence   Contains public sector information licensed under the Open Government Licence v3.0.

Copyright © 1999-2024 by The Durham Mining Museum and its contributors
Registered Charity No: 1110608
Page last updated: 28 Nov 2022

Privacy Policy
 
Terms & Conditions
 
Search
Search
Print
Print